This coming just a few months after Jump feels quite reductive.

The styling is also all over the place…

Gabriela had a clear sound and aesthetic, like it was a proper pop moment and it rightfully smashed. Was the message not clear enough?

2 hours ago, GloryDays said:

It was ok, MV looks good and the song will grow on me with the performance.

Daniela looks fire, Sophia gets little to no lines (again) + the scene with drag queens adds nothing specially with the reveal being Dani

Unrelated but now with Manon allegedly being out and judging how they subtly pushing Daniela. I wouldn't be surprised if she's the new FOTG / Center given she's the white girl of the group.

8 minutes ago, sleepevaded said:

idk how i feel about the song but the editing of the MV is so choppy nnnn…. i can barely see Lara during the dance scenes which was depressing. i rly liked the bike setup the most

literally!! I can't appreciate the choreo because the frame doesn't stay still at all

5 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

Unrelated but now with Manon allegedly being out and judging how they subtly pushing Daniela. I wouldn't be surprised if she's the new FOTG / Center given she's the white girl of the group.

Daniella seems to be the Camila of this group in the sense that she's being pushed to the center very notably. It's not even subtle. Lara and Manon seem to have more organic interest. But it's interesting how Sophia is practically invisible considering she's the leader and was the top ranked after the survival show.

5 minutes ago, Sharon Stone said:

Daniella seems to be the Camila of this group in the sense that she's being pushed to the center very notably. It's not even subtle. Lara and Manon seem to have more organic interest. But it's interesting how Sophia is practically invisible considering she's the leader and was the top ranked after the survival show.

I wouldn't blame this to Dani but again it's their label. Even their gay stylist humberto clearly loves her and he wants her to be the shakira like his saying along those lines. Manon / Lara whilst being strikingly gorgeous but they are clearly added for the diversity quota.

Sophia is the most underutilized member I agree ( consistenly being the best live performer ) and guaranteed will have a florishing career post Katseye. The western side of the fandom undervalues how much she brings to the group like their streams alone are like 8/10 from her region.

Edited April 9Apr 9 by Odette Violet

7 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

I wouldn't blame this to Dani but again it's their label. Even their gay stylist humberto clearly loves her and he wants her to be the shakira like his saying along those lines. Manon / Lara whilst being strikingly gorgeous but they are clearly added for the diversity quota.

Sophia is the most underutilized member I agree ( consistenly being the best live performer ) and guaranteed will have a florishing career post Katseye. The western side of the fandom undervalues how much she brings to the group like their streams alone are like 8/10 from her region.

You're a pathetic racist. Not shocking to see a hate-filled lowkey conservative filipino user calling the most talented person in the group a DEI hire because she's Indian while calling the less talented filipina the most underutilized member when she literally is the leader of the group, gets masses of lines, and leads every interview. Just disgusting and shameless. There's a reason we ran you out of the kpop base, I hope the rest of the forum follows suit.

The fact that you kept on pushing this "KATSEYE is only famous for DEI" narrative for hours and hours in this thread and other users gave you the benefit of the doubt until you came out and named the two girls with complexions deeper than wonder bread, you're sick in the head.

Edited April 9Apr 9 by Sheep

18 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

I wouldn't blame this to Dani but again it's their label. Even their gay stylist humberto clearly loves her and he wants her to be the shakira like his saying along those lines. Manon / Lara whilst being strikingly gorgeous but they are clearly added for the diversity quota.

Sophia is the most underutilized member I agree ( consistenly being the best live performer ) and guaranteed will have a florishing career post Katseye. The western side of the fandom undervalues how much she brings to the group like their streams alone are like 8/10 from her region.

What are you talking about lol? Can you imagine this group without Lara Raj? She's the star of this group. I like Sophia and the other girls as well but they are nowhere near to Lara. Y'all know this.

1 minute ago, Vorfreude said:

What are you talking about lol? Can you imagine this group without Lara Raj? She's the star of this group. I like Sophia and the other girls as well but they are nowhere near to Lara. Y'all know this.

Manon being a "diversity hire" too when literally every kpop group, including the ones @Odette Violet stans have a dedicated position for a girl who's prettier than the rest of them and lacking in talent compared to the others. Just say you have a problem with groups that aren't strictly east asian or strictly white and move on.

Edited April 9Apr 9 by Sheep

Just now, Vorfreude said:

What are you talking about lol? Can you imagine this group without Lara Raj? She's the star of this group. I like Sophia and the other girls as well but they are nowhere near to Lara. Y'all know this.

yall loves to hypes Lara as if she's going to be the next big super star but the real question here will there be a market for her as a dark skinned Indian? Sophia / Yoonchae got the Asian market ( East and Southeast Asia ) Dani has LATAM, Manon has most of the black support, Megan is in a tricky place.

Katseye without Lara is just your Kpop group / light skinned girls.

Edited April 9Apr 9 by Odette Violet

i love so much the song and i don't miss manon...

strange but...

4 hours ago, Asscatchem said:

still pandering to tiktok

they are 18 to 23 years old PLEASE

2 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

will there be a market for her as a dark skinned Indian?

oh that mask is off

hope you enjoyed your time on atrl

Edited April 9Apr 9 by Sheep

Everything was going so well until Gabriela/last year. The way everything started to collapse since then….

That being said, I truly believe the hate train the girls have is pointless and underserved. Like….what did they do exactly ?

8 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

yall loves to hypes Lara as if she's going to be the next big super star but the real question here will there be a market for her as a dark skinned Indian? Sophia / Yoonchae got the Asian market ( East and Southeast Asia ) Dani has LATAM, Manon has most of the black support, Megan is in a tricky place.

Katseye without Lara is just your Kpop group / light skinned girls.

India is a part of Asia too

2 minutes ago, Odette Violet said:

yall loves to hypes Lara as if she's going to be the next big super star but the real question here will there be a market for her as a dark skinned Indian? Sophia / Yoonchae got the Asian market ( East and Southeast Asia ) Dani has LATAM, Manon has most of the black support, Megan is in a tricky place.

Katseye without Lara is just your Kpop group / light skinned girls.

Good luck with booking that Asian markets you speak of lol.

That being said, I have mixed feelings about the song. There are some parts that I love and others quite bad.

Daniela and Megan killed both video and song imo, they had the best verses.

The video could have been better, I feel like the editing set them up.

1 minute ago, Gyro Zeppeli said:

India is a part of Asia too

That user is asian. It was intentional to word it that way.

I grew to like Gnarly in the end , but Pinky Up is genuinely terrible . The Lyrics along with the music video make no sense whatsoever.

I'm not just saying it cause she's not there but they actually look visually incomplete/like something is missing without Manon as well!

This has to be their worst song and I'm not being dramatic. Their team keep searching for another big Gnarly moment but it keeps getting worse.

their team hates them because no way this is better than anything on BC

Edited April 9Apr 9 by chris1991

1 minute ago, Vorfreude said:

Good luck with booking that Asian markets you speak of lol.

Considering how tribalistic / ethnic prideful and colorist the Asian market are. I think the non American Asian girls will just do fine going back to their home countries.

This isn't meant to be an attack towards Lara or any dark skinned Asians but there is a reason why there's only one Asian girl who was able to breakthrough as MPG and why it took decades for that to happened yet come to think she isn't even fully Asian.

Edited April 9Apr 9 by Odette Violet

This sucks

what is happening in this thread? It feels like whatever is going down with this group, their fans, etc. has turned really dark-sided I'm not feeling it

Anyway lets just ignore it and let the mods handle

Terrible song, terrible choreo, terrible video, terrible group chemistry. I continue to be in awe of the things people are fans of, complete slop. I could not care less about this group and its nothing burger drama as a whole, but Manon's absence makes this nothing bruger lineup look like boys world 2.0

Touch and its ep was very cute, baffling that their management said no to that sound and vision. Charlie xcx is doing irrepreable damage to musicians from all walks of life, her brand and musical styling cannot be replicated by manufactured barbie dolls, please stop trying to even attempt it.

The biggest problem with Pinky Up is that they barely showed Daniela's pink buss down. They need to surgically attach that wig to her scalp. She has literally never looked so cunty.

Do you guys think Britney is out there somewhere gagging at the number of sharp objects in this mv?