Well...

I think Abracadabra is the better song but it's important to say that Never Really Over is soo fun and I want to encourage her to make music like that.

Only time will tell, but...

 

Spotify Global Peak

Abracadabra: #2

Never Really Over: #9

 

Spotify US Peak

Abracadabra: #1

Never Really Over: #10

 

Spotify UK Peak

Abracadabra: #2

Never Really Over: #9

 

Days in Spotify Global Top 10

Abracadabra: 12 (So Far)

Never Really Over: 6

 

Days in Spotify US Top 10

Abracadabra: 8 (So Far)

Never Really Over: 1

 

Days in Spotify UK Top 10

Abracadabra: 9 (So Far)

Never Really Over: 3

 

The set up

 

Abra is slowly becoming a cultural phenomenon while NRO has one of Katy's worst recurrent streams for a single.

 

I do love NRO though and wish she went that direction for Smile era

The one that's not over.

Why do we need to ask the class simple math questions? Just check the numbers and you can see which one is bigger.

Abra

 

But I used to enjoy NRO a lot more back then

So mu vote goes for it out of nostalgia 

Edited February 20, 20251 yr by Trent W

NRO is arguably Katy's best single in the past 10 years, but Abra is clearly the bigger song generally speaking

Why did the OP make a poll when they provided stats that already answer the question? 

NRO is one of Katy's best songs ever and I wish it smashed.

 

Abra is obviously bigger tho, I mean look at its performance in Europe alone

Abracadabra screams hit and it is already bigger.

 

Never Really Over was really good but instantly flopped.

Abracadabra by far .. that song really is unique 

 

Never really over just sounds like any other song however harleys in Hawaii was a good song

Id say both are similarly sized hits. Not their biggest, definitely not flops either. But as for now Abracadabra does have a (small) edge over NRO.

It seems Abra is bigger, but NRO is an amazing track that deserved to be a smash hit (and didn't do bad at all)

Abracadabra instrumentals alone eats up NRO 

7 hours ago, Pop Art said:

Only time will tell, but...

 

Spotify Global Peak

Abracadabra: #2

Never Really Over: #9

 

Spotify US Peak

Abracadabra: #1

Never Really Over: #10

 

Spotify UK Peak

Abracadabra: #2

Never Really Over: #9

 

Days in Spotify Global Top 10

Abracadabra: 12 (So Far)

Never Really Over: 6

 

Days in Spotify US Top 10

Abracadabra: 8 (So Far)

Never Really Over: 1

 

Days in Spotify UK Top 10

Abracadabra: 9 (So Far)

Never Really Over: 3

 

.

Abra had an organic moment that NRO never really had. Whether it will have legs or not remains to be seen, but it's already bigger.

 

Never Really Over was a very solid moderate hit, but it was always flying right under the radar, waiting for that extra push that would catapult it higher, which sadly never happened.

Never Really Over is such a beautiful song

poor gaga, getting compared to sewage water x

I like Never Really Over and I think it was a step in the right direction for Katy. But Abracadabra is bigger.

13 hours ago, Pop Art said:

Only time will tell, but...

 

Spotify Global Peak

Abracadabra: #2

Never Really Over: #9

 

Spotify US Peak

Abracadabra: #1

Never Really Over: #10

 

Spotify UK Peak

Abracadabra: #2

Never Really Over: #9

 

Days in Spotify Global Top 10

Abracadabra: 12 (So Far)

Never Really Over: 6

 

Days in Spotify US Top 10

Abracadabra: 8 (So Far)

Never Really Over: 1

 

Days in Spotify UK Top 10

Abracadabra: 9 (So Far)

Never Really Over: 3

 

The present. The ultimate truth teller

NRO did nothing for Katy. Abra instead is culturally more impactful !