Which is the better album?

Edited September 8, 20233 yr by Rv1709

Midnights

Guts by FAAAAAAAAAAAAR.

Midnights is really an embarrassant of an album, a collection of demos thrown around together and she had the nerve to say she wrote those songs after midnight in the tourment of the night. Thank god it houses Would've Could've Should've (And Maroon / The Great War / Bigger than the whole Sky, but especially WCS).

Edited September 8, 20233 yr by D.Va

the PLAGIARIST defeated MIDnights 

Midnights 100%
 

Maroon alone > GUTS

Guts by far and I don't even like it that much

 

Midnights is literal crap. There's a reason why Cruel Summer is smashing all over it

Guts.

Midnights is not even one of Taylor's best albums  

Didn't take long to prove me right 

 

On 9/2/2023 at 4:51 PM, Klein said:

Wait for next Friday, I can guarantee you the very first thread of the day will be GUTS vs Midnights (cause it's their last one), then you'll have GUTS vs Fearless (cause it's their second album), and maybe even GUTS vs Speak Now (TV) (cause their both represented with the color purple). 

GUTS is far better than Mid-nights 

The standard edition of Midnights is one of Taylor’s worst albums, so Guts >>>

Nothing on GUTS is better than Maroon, Snow On The Beach ft More Lana Del Rey or Labyrinth.

The album that has Maroon and Anti-Hero

Yeah. Guts is good but I don’t think Olivia is as good as Taylor is writing really emotional pieces that touch people’s hearts, like YOYOK for example. Anyway, Taylor is longer in the game it’s not a fair comparison.

Midnights is much better album. GUTS is a dull effort. 

Edited September 8, 20233 yr by Steve Johnson

The album that doesn’t have Anti-Hero and Karma wins

All of ATRL need to band together and stop replying to this user's threads

Why do we always have to compare things? 😭 

We need to leave them alone, they are two distinct entities for god's sake.

Let Olivia be.  Let Taylor be.

Obviously Midnights. No song in olivia's discography comes close to Would've Could've Should've

Edited September 8, 20233 yr by Timeless

MIDnights has like 4 good songs out of 20

Predicting a GUTS v Happier Than Ever thread soonish

Midnights by a thousand cuts 

MIDnights is tay’s worst, so why compare it with that

Every song on Midnights sounds the same, so guts wins

Let's just say that if midnights was a flop that poll wouln't have those results on atrl

And if guts ends up being huge it will change

Edited September 8, 20233 yr by Digitalism

1 minute ago, Punky Rooster said:

Every song on Midnights sounds the same, so guts wins

Time for an ear-check then