Two of her most underrated albums compared to the fan favorites like : 1989, reputation and Folklore

AOTY winning Fearless sweetie. It has timeless appeal which SN lacks. 

Speak Now for all. I feel it's an underrated album from Taylor but it has many great songs and lyrics. Love it more now than in the past.

Speak Now has Last Kiss. 

Speak Now is better and has a better tour but Fearless has better singles definitely

The Fearless singles run is still unmatched. All 10/10 certified classics, and the release order was genius.

 

1. Love Story - ”young love” song that romanticizes the relationship with cinematic and literary comparisons

 

2. White Horse - a breakup song that directly contrasts the preceding single, explicitly stating “I’m not a princess…”

 

3. You Belong With Me - the ultimate teen crush song

 

4. Fifteen - a coming of age song that directly contrasts the preceding single, explicitly stating that there are more important things than boys and crushes and high school romances

 

5. Fearless - a fantasy of the perfect first date

 

 

Going by this, The Way I Loved You ought to have been the sixth single as it is the flip side of “Fearless” in that it describes disliking a relationship that seems perfect on the surface

So easy.

 

Speak Now is the better album and tour (by far). Fearless had the better singles (also by far). 

Fearless vs. Mine

Fifteen vs. Sparks Fly

Love Story vs. Back To December

Hey Stephen vs. Speak Now

White Horse vs. Dear John

You Belong with Me vs. Mean

Breathe (feat. Colbie Caillat) vs. The Story Of Us

Tell Me Why vs. Never Grow Up

You’re Not Sorry vs. Enchanted

The Way I Loved You vs. Better Than Revenge

Forever & Always vs. Innocent

The Best Day vs. Haunted

Change vs. Last Kiss

Today Was A Fairytale vs. Long Live

 

 

Speak Now wins easily

Edited August 23, 20233 yr by KatyPrismSpirit

Speak Now: 2/3

 

Fearless: 1/3

Enchanted and Haunted clears Fearless for me idk what to tell yall 

Slay Now because of Timeless

Fearless vs. Mine

Fifteen vs. Sparks Fly

Love Story vs. Back To December

Hey Stephen vs. Speak Now

White Horse vs. Dear John

You Belong with Me vs. Mean

Breathe vs. The Story Of Us

Tell Me Why vs. Never Grow Up

You’re Not Sorry vs. Enchanted

The Way I Loved You vs. Better Than Revenge

Forever & Always vs. Innocent

The Best Day vs. Haunted

Change vs. Last Kiss

Jump Then Fall vs. Long Live

Untouchable vs. Ours

Come In With The Rain vs. Superman

You All Over Me vs. Electric Touch

Mr. Perfectly Fine vs. When Emma Falls In Love

We Were Happy vs. I Can See You

That's When vs. Castles Crumbling

Don't You vs. Foolish One

Bye Bye Baby vs. Timeless

 

12-10, both super close but I think Fearless wins for me slightly.

Speak Now has always been my favourite album until Folklore

fearless is super mid but the single choices were stellar

speak now is a far better album in almost every regard. it had stronger songwriting, she did all of the songwriting alone, the album had more variation in it's tracks, it has far less filler, and a far better album cover (Original and TV) compared to the hideous fearless platinum edition cover - i have no idea why they chose to make the background black and do a bad job photoshopping her hair. fearless had better singles though

 

anyway here's my ranking

 

Fearless vs. Mine

Fifteen vs. Sparks Fly

Love Story vs. Back To December

Hey Stephen vs. Speak Now

White Horse vs. Dear John

You Belong with Me vs. Mean

Breathe vs. The Story Of Us

Tell Me Why vs. Never Grow Up

You’re Not Sorry vs. Enchanted

The Way I Loved You vs. Better Than Revenge

Forever & Always vs. Innocent

The Best Day vs. Haunted

Change vs. Last Kiss

Jump Then Fall vs. Long Live

Untouchable vs. Ours

Come In With The Rain vs. Superman

You All Over Me vs. Electric Touch

Mr. Perfectly Fine vs. When Emma Falls In Love

We Were Happy vs. I Can See You

That's When vs. Castles Crumbling

Don't You vs. Foolish One

Edited August 23, 20233 yr by thetea

Fearless is actually much better than some of y'all and the fandom give credit for, but Speak Now still wipes the floor with it so there's that.

I'd even argue that its singles were better: if Mine hadn't been force released ahead of schedule and gone #1 (highly possible, after all Today Was A Fairytale went #2) y'all would appreciate it better

Didn't Fearless win Album of the Year???

Speak now.

15 minutes ago, jdmc219 said:

Didn't Fearless win Album of the Year???

Weak competition 

2 minutes ago, Axelios said:

Weak competition 

Nah. Not even. Sasha Fierce, The Fame, or The E.N.D could've easily taken it. Hell, even probably Dave Matthews since they were the most unknown. lol

Sparks Fly is the best song from both eras.

'Fearless'

'Speak Now World Tour'

'Fearless' singles

1 hour ago, jdmc219 said:

Nah. Not even. Sasha Fierce, The Fame, or The E.N.D could've easily taken it. Hell, even probably Dave Matthews since they were the most unknown. lol

Not really. None of these albums were that well received and Fearless was the most succesful in the US.

Is neither an option? Thank God she's evolved because these are easily her worst two albums. 

5 minutes ago, Black Jesus said:

Is neither an option? Thank God she's evolved because these are easily her worst two albums. 

Worse than Loser and Eversnore?