Whenever pop stans are discussing their favorite albums from our ex-act girls, these four are usually the ones mentioned the most for each ex-act girl.

 

All of these albums are undoubtedly solid efforts on their own, but which girl has the best magnum opus?

 

 

 

 

Edited May 15, 20233 yr by Scars

Sour is the best ex-act album.  

the way none of these are their magnum opus!

 

 

Hilary/Dignity for all.

1. Tell Me You Love Me

2. Dignity

3. Revival

4. Plastic Hearts

5. Sweetener

 

I LOVE when I can listen to a song and know exactly who it's about. That's exactly what happened with Tell Me You Love Me (about Wilmer Valderrama, Luke Rockhold, Bomba, Nick Jonas) and Dignity (Joel Madden, Mike Comrie). And both albums explored MANY phases of love, like devastating break ups but also hooking up with new guys and finding love again. I put Dignity second only bc she doesn't have the vocals or versatility that Demi has lmao, which pushed me to favor TMYLM more. #3 and #4 are definitely solid, #3 could be more interesting and creative artistically (airs on generic, yet is very personally enjoyable), and #4 could be more personally enjoyable (yet is creative)

Edited May 15, 20233 yr by Freakshowvato

TMYLM is so good and underrated. 

Daddy Issues, Ruin the Friendship, Only Forever, Cry Baby, Concentrate... Not a single bad track.  

Revival, Good For You, Sorry Not Sorry.
 

TMYLM and NTLTC are a very close second for both though.

For the singles,

 

Midnight Sky > Play With Fire > Sorry Not Sorry > the rest

 

but it's VERY close, I actually love all three of these songs, they're so unique sounding and playful, and they're all about post-break up glow ups and lowkey shading exes (Liam Hemsworth, Joel Madden, and Wilmer Valderrama)

PH clears followed by Revival.

The way Plastic Hearts clears all three 

For me: 

Album: Revival > PH > TMYLM > Dignity > Sweetener 

Lead Single: Good for You > Midnight Sky = No Tears Left to Cry = Sorry Not Sorry > Play With Fire

Opening Song: Stranger = Revival > SNS > WTF Do I Know > (....) > (....) > (....) > Blazed. 

Album: Plastic Hearts >>>>> Dignity > Sweetener > TMYLM > Revival

1st single: Midnight Sky > No Tears Left to Cry > Good For You > Play With Fire > Sorry Not Sorry

1st song: WTF Do I Know > Stranger > Revival > Sorry Not Sorry > Blazed

Breakout by Miley and it's not even close

Im proud of these albums (minus Ariana, you should've picked TUN lmao)

 

Selena for all tbh

Milene for all

Miley sweep. 
 

Plastic Hearts, Revival, and Can’t Be Tamed are the top 3 ex-act albums.

Demi stomps them all, second is Revival and Dignity rest is meh

Sweetener for all, as it's my favourite Ariana album and one of my favourites ever, although I think TUN should've been there instead, as both GP and fans usually agree that's her magnum opus, on top of being the most successful. 

Miley clears. Sorry but none of the other girls have plastic hearts in their discography or legends like billy idol, joan jett and stevie nicks on their albums 

 

 

I love Dignity & Plastic Hearts but chose Revival, though my vote could have gone to any of the three. Also really love Midnight Sky & NTLTC but Good For You is my favorite Selena song so that one by default. Strangers clears in the openers. 

Dignity

Midnight Sky

Blazed

Of these choices, Sweetener and Midnight Sky >>

Plastic Hearts

No Tears Left to Cry

Stranger