Christinas grammy nominated #1 UK smash & #48 US peaking flop vs Britneys UK top 5 hit & US top 30 lukewarm hit. 

 

 

 

Youtube Views:

Dirrty 169 million

IM a slave for you 173 million

 

Spotify:

Dirrty 191,134,563

Im a slave for you 168,725,020

Like, Dirrty is fun but I prefer IAS4U it’s such a vibe and the video is amazing.

MV: Slave

Song: Dirrty

Dirrty by far, for both categories. Aggie was really serving multifaceted ace in that rollout, and even to this day I still get kind of shocked with how far she dared to push it, given what was still considered taboo in entertainment at that time. Dirrty was just infinitely catchier, as well.

 

Britney looked great in the Slave video, but I can never shake the feeling that the song might've been better, had it been sung by someone else.

Edited February 10, 20233 yr by Rhythm

Dirrty by far for both. IAS4U is overrated as all hell.

Dirrty. That breakdown still gets me going every time

 
 

Dirrty actually hits way harder. She ate that right on up

Edited February 10, 20233 yr by Mezter

Slave for both. Dirrty is an average song though the video is still great and one of her finest works aesthetic wise. 

What’s with the constant Britney vs Xtina threads? 

ot: Slave 4 U for both

Dirrty is one of the most mediocre songs ever and one of the most cringeworthy attempts to plagiarize another popstar’s hits. I still like it, but it’s a 7/10 on a good day.

 

IAS4U is a great song and it has one of the best videos ever.

Slave for both 

5 minutes ago, Eternium said:

Dirrty is one of the most mediocre songs ever and one of the most cringeworthy attempts to plagiarize another popstar’s hits. I still like it, but it’s a 7/10 on a good day.

 

IAS4U is a great song and it has one of the best videos ever.

No one remembers IAS4U video. It's forgettable. However they remember her iconic MTV performance. 

 

If you ask a normal GP they'll remember her with the snake they won't remember that video. It's actually one of Britney's lesser watched videos. 

Dirrty is great but Slave >>>

Slave>>>>≥

Dirrty is the better video. Everything thing in that video is super stylized. Every shot can be an ad. 

 

Christina invented female UFC, aline skits with buckles, Platinum grey hair, Furry fetish.

 

Miley in We Cant Stop and Gaga in Just Dance used the furry fetish. 

 

Britney tried to make a sexy video but all she did was wear a bikini bottom over leather boot cut pant and tied some fabric on her arm. Or wore a lace embellished top with over embellished boot cut low rise jeans. meh... 

 

Again what made IASFU iconic was the MTV awards. The song and the video weren't great. 

 

 

Edited February 10, 20233 yr by JustLikeHoney

Both girls served but Dirrty is better. I really miss the days when popgirls served quality music and videos.

Dirrty is such a JAM every time it comes on so that

Slave for both. Love Dirrty though

46 minutes ago, Eternium said:

Dirrty is one of the most mediocre songs ever and one of the most cringeworthy

 

46 minutes ago, Eternium said:

I still like it,

Please dont take this person opinion seriously just smile yall ….

Slave4U is just sexier, although I really love how Xtina sang the first few verses of Dirrty.

4 minutes ago, Power love said:

 

Please dont take this person opinion seriously just smile yall ….

You know damn well that the Fighters wouldn’t use it, either, if Christina had more hits to choose from

Dirrty.

Can't listen to a song called Slave since Britney has all the c-ship issues because it feels to on the nose so Dirrrty. 

Dirrty  

Slave for both. I haven't heard Dirrty in YEARS actually.  Still remember the chorus and it's cute, though.