Which album does ATRL prefer? I'd imagine the votes spread out very evenly between these two, we'll see!

My vote goes for Chromatica

 

   

Edited June 3, 20233 yr by Avariko

Don’t love either but Chromatica is more in line with the sort of music I listen to. 

i love both so much!!

I voted for Midnights though because Midnight Rain exists 

GODMATICA

Midnights, without a doubt. Maroon, Would've Could've Should've, The Great War, Bigger Than The Whole Sky, High Infidelity... 

midnights by far; as a former liddo i must say chromatica is the only gaga album i don’t like, however 911 was such a return to form i hope we get more of that. rain on me, replay and sour candy are cute too tbf

Chromatica. Only 911 and Babylon are skips.

 

I do like Midnights, but it has more skips.

Midnights sounds like your average radio fooder from irrelevant acts.

so Chromatica by default.

Replay alone is better than anything on Midnights so

chromatica 

Gaga is my #1 fave but Midnights is a better album. Gaga hasn't served anything really really really exciting since ARTPOP, imo. (Excluding ASIB) 

GODMATICA 

Chromatica only has 2 skips while Midnights have a lot more so...

Love both but Replay stomps

Chromatica has higher highs

but both have fillers

Gaga, sweetie, Gaga….. one album actually makes you want to move whereas the other is made for H&M and Forever21 to play in the background to fill the silence while the cashiers check ppl out! 
 

Edited January 13, 20233 yr by Kh-Loud

Both are 10/10 dark pop albums

Midnights is mid but Chromatica is terrible, so Midnights.

 

Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve and The Great War > Anything Gaga has put out since The Fame Monster

Chromatica is a lot more consistent, but Midnights has much higher highs (Maroon, Karma, Mastermind, Would've Could've Should've).

 

Still went with Chromatica because I love the inclusion of the instrumental interludes.

Edited January 13, 20233 yr by ithinkheknowsoutsold

Chromatica didn’t give what it was supposed to, however it does have Rain on Me, 911 and Plastic Doll and is fun overall, whereas Midnights is full of skips save for Anti Hero and Mastermind so I guess Chromatica wins 

Edited January 13, 20233 yr by Blue Monday

Alice alone >>>

love em both, chromatica takes the edge tho

Love both - Chromatica as a whole, tho. 

Album with higher mc score

Chromatica sounds like your average radio fooder from irrelevant acts.

 

so Midnights by default.