Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues
New Music Out Now!! 🎧💿

Lady Gaga

This is part 1 of the Lady Gaga discussion.

Featured Replies

10 minutes ago, Mercurio said:

The music may have not been what we expected, but with Joanne she made sure we were fed. We need the same publicity for LG7.

Superbowl, Coachella, SNL, 6 month single run of Million Reasons, documentary,  'gift for the fans' single The Curan.

 

yes, we were fed

 

ezgif-2-adc0f09115.thumb.gif.3c39ad3acc8

 

  • Replies 457.3k
  • Views 18.9m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Topics in this Discussion

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

2 hours ago, PlERRE said:

Joanne gave us the Superbowl, Coachella and the Victoria secret fashion show. I can't hate the era.  :jonny6:

Literally the less Joanne things of the era :deadbanana2:

1 hour ago, chosensparkles said:

Joanne era >> Chromatica era

When in actual fact Labels would take 3 TTH songs all with 150-200m playlist reach over a superbowl performance in one country with no guarantee a song will hit 

 

spacer.png

10 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

When in actual fact Labels would take 3 TTH songs all with 150-200m playlist reach over a superbowl performance in one country with no guarantee a song will hit 

 

spacer.png

I know but I meant in terms of enjoyment and content

I met Mark tonight and told him I’ve loved his dancing since I was in middle school :heart2: he was very kind and sweet

8 hours ago, Almodusa said:

SAG Awards’ latest tweet is about Gaga

Ga Ga needs to win SAG if she ever wants to win Best Actress. The past few SAG Actress winners have also won BA.

The only reason Chromatica underperformed commercially is because she gave up on the era (and led the era with that HORRIBLE song Stupid Larva)

Had she actually showed she gave any single *** then Chromatica would have prob been a lot more successful because we would have gotten Sour Candy as a single and possibly more music videos. Maybe a performance and interview here and there too...I get there was the pandemic and riots but all other artists were still doing things especially later. Looking back at it retrospectively it feels like she used that stuff as an excuse to not push Chromatica and just sit at home taking D and eating (which is fun I guess)

36 minutes ago, WildAmerican said:

Ga Ga needs to win SAG if she ever wants to win Best Actress. The past few SAG Actress winners have also won BA.

I feel like SAG is the more narrative based award. 

How can you say Chromatica underperformed when it performed better than her previous 2 albums, ARTPOP and Joanne? 
 

It was one of the best selling albums of 2020. No need to rewrite history. #1 album with a #1 song and a Grammy

spacer.png

3 minutes ago, Vroom Vroom said:

How can you say Chromatica underperformed when it performed better than her previous 2 albums, ARTPOP and Joanne? 
 

It was one of the best selling albums of 2020. No need to rewrite history. #1 album with a #1 song and a Grammy

spacer.png

Chromatica did not perform better than ARTPOP, and it has yet to pass Joanne in the US and some other countries, so not sure what are you basing your claims on.

10 minutes ago, Vroom Vroom said:

How can you say Chromatica underperformed when it performed better than her previous 2 albums, ARTPOP and Joanne? 
 

It was one of the best selling albums of 2020. No need to rewrite history. #1 album with a #1 song and a Grammy

spacer.png

maybe in weeks, but in total units? not really

in US it still goes: ARTPOP (1.7-1.8M) > Joanne (1.5M) > Chromatica (1.3M)

global units it goes: ARTPOP (4.6M) > Chromatica (4M) > Joanne (3.8M)

24 minutes ago, IBeMe said:

The only reason Chromatica underperformed commercially is because she gave up on the era (and led the era with that HORRIBLE song Stupid Larva)

Had she actually showed she gave any single *** then Chromatica would have prob been a lot more successful because we would have gotten Sour Candy as a single and possibly more music videos. Maybe a performance and interview here and there too...I get there was the pandemic and riots but all other artists were still doing things especially later. Looking back at it retrospectively it feels like she used that stuff as an excuse to not push Chromatica and just sit at home taking D and eating (which is fun I guess)

Albums die in the streaming era upon release and Gaga is not a hitmaker, she goes for 2 singles an era and the albums don’t show potential for more, look at how she struggles on radio. The problem is she is a woman over 30 and if you’re gonna do the same pop shtick as what was popular ten years ago you have to deliver a certain way to hit wider demographics and not just your base.  This is Katy Perry’s issue too.  
 

Spoiler

good example is how Madonna night finally get a hit for the very first time in streaming era, but it’s not her ‘brand’. she’s masked in a very trendy song between two males doing a verse that any female could do. It’s not just about the music in streaming. Chromatica was a good record for fans esp but they wouldn’t have approached the era like that without ASIB imo. 

 

5 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

Albums die in the streaming era upon release and Gaga is not a hitmaker, she goes for 2 singles an era and the albums don’t show potential for more, look at how she struggles on radio. The problem is she is a woman over 30 and if you’re gonna do the same pop shtick as what was popular ten years ago you have to deliver a certain way to hit wider demographics and not just your base.  This is Katy Perry’s issue too.  
 

  Reveal hidden contents

good example is how Madonna night finally get a hit for the very first time in streaming era, but it’s not her ‘brand’. she’s masked in a very trendy song between two males doing a verse that any female could do. It’s not just about the music in streaming. Chromatica was a good record for fans esp but they wouldn’t have approached the era like that without ASIB imo. 

 

define hit?

#8 on US iTunes, #58 on AM US and #3 on Spotify US first day

let's wait before calling it a hit

1 hour ago, Vroom Vroom said:

How can you say Chromatica underperformed when it performed better than her previous 2 albums, ARTPOP and Joanne? 

ARTPOP: 4.7M
Joanne: 3.4M

A Star Is Born: 9.6M

Chromatica: 3.5M

 

Its a flop sorry, especially since it had #1 single.

 

 

Looks like Sarah is heading to London

 

Wonder if Gagz is coming with 

7 minutes ago, LunaUniverse said:

Looks like Sarah is heading to London

 

Wonder if Gagz is coming with 

Haus Labs event at Sephora

17 hours ago, Marry The Gods said:

I enjoyed the Joanne era to the point where I get nostalgic about it every once in a while. The perfect illusion teasers, PI music video release, Dive Bar Tour, Million Reasons single release, Japan promo, The Victoria Secret Fashion Show, Million Reasons promo, Superbowl, Surprise John Wayne video, Coachella, The Joanne World Tour, The Cure AMA performance, the beautiful performance of Joanne/Million Reasons at the Grammys 2018 and so many other moments I'm probably missing.  

 

Music eras are so much more fun when sales and streams aren't the main focus. 

Take me back to those times. She really had her heart into that album.

So i just saw ASIB for the first time and im shook.. Everything about it was a serve.. The ending tho :chick3:

 

If joker 2 is good i might have to stan actress gaga. 

 

Anyway.. I noticed that shallow in the trailer was different from the one in the film/soundtrack. 

 

Is there a full studio version of the trailer out? 

  • ATRL Moderator
5 minutes ago, Johnny Jacobs said:

Anyway.. I noticed that shallow in the trailer was different from the one in the film/soundtrack. 

 

Is there a full studio version of the trailer out? 

As close as we are getting.

I love the trailer version more tbh.

 

 

Can she at least fly to London and serve us a look or sumn 

 

fab0f2f3170e6c43ff805f8394f689ef.jpg

  • ATRL Moderator

She should hit up some recording studios in London and Amsterdam. That’s where some gems were made. :duca:

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.