Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues

Beyoncé

This is part 1 of the Beyoncé discussion.

Featured Replies

I - :rip:

 

Saw all the new pages in the past eight hours and never imagined the breakdowns. 
 

In music related news, I’m still obsessed with Heated.

  • Replies 143.5k
  • Views 7.1m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Topics in this Discussion

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • It was the best concert of my life, bar none. Idc!    It was extraordinary, it was ineffable.  I knew I loved it based on the videos but I... Hey I don't know.    Best moment

  • SashaDevachelli
    SashaDevachelli

    I know this award is a joke but the point is, she has cemented herself in history with the likes of Whitney and Lauryn. And on top of that she won an award for a genre that completely ridiculed and ex

  • Potentially #1 in the US, UK and Canada in the same week   

1 hour ago, sillycilla said:

Yup, folks don’t want to admit it. They’d rather think a Tiffany commercial was something LoL.

I mean, I get that they want to build excitement and I think B likes to starve her fanbase before feeding them, but something's off about this timeline. The videos should have been out a while ago now. 

2 minutes ago, giRLbye. said:

 

you are way off...YOU are the only person trying to tie-in what Jay Z was doing in comparison to his wife. I already know Beyonce can do the same as him and catch this...I also know she DOESN'T have to do the same thing as him. meaning he can do sit-down interviews, go on Twitter spaces every week, release his albums to streaming, be papped and she can say NO to all of that. so mentioning what Jay Z does as a way to hint that Beyonce "needs" to be doing the same thing off the basis of her husband doing it is once again NOT the argument you think it is.

 

and to your 2nd point....Beyonce actually can & IS doing all of that easily. ya'll didn't hear her when she said in that interview in 2013:

 

"The Super Bowl’s one thing, but after that, I’ll be very selective. What I love is performing and making the album. I don’t really have to do anything that I don’t want to do anymore. And that feels damn good.”

 

https://thegentlewoman.co.uk/library/beyonce

She doesn't have to do the same thing as him. But the point is that she's doing NOTHING. Yall got all these excuses for her being tired, wife and mother when there are literally so many others who debunk all these narratives. Especially when you can see her on a yacht, throwing a party or going to a musical.

 

Beyonce deserves her rest and flowers. But this half ass rollout is not it. Its giving "my work speaks for itself so buy my tour tickets and album". Meanwhile girlies who write and sell a hell of a lot more WITH kids don't pull this. I've watched so many try to put the pieces together concerning this era and she does nothing. Some were saying we might get something for the fall solstice? Well now we pushed it back and are hoping for something on the first week of October. Then it'll be praying she makes a move before Taylor. 

 

With that said, I'm inclined to believe we will get something this upcoming month. But there has to be better execution going forward. This is sloppy and only act I of iii.  

A couple weeks ago I would've joined in on the meltdowns, but my fave song from Bey in the past 6 years is currently smashing so I'm quite pleased with the era atm!
vogue_73-questions-dua-lipa.thumb.jpg.5f

10 minutes ago, Dreajae said:

She doesn't have to do the same thing as him. But the point is that she's doing NOTHING. Yall got all these excuses for her being tired, wife and mother when there are literally so many others who debunk all these narratives. Especially when you can see her on a yacht, throwing a party or going to a musical.

 

Beyonce deserves her rest and flowers. But this half ass rollout is not it. Its giving "my work speaks for itself so buy my tour tickets and album". Meanwhile girlies who write and sell a hell of a lot more WITH kids don't pull this. I've watched so many try to put the pieces together concerning this era and she does nothing. Some were saying we might get something for the fall solstice? Well now we pushed it back and are hoping for something on the first week of October. Then it'll be praying she makes a move before Taylor. 

 

With that said, I'm inclined to believe we will get something this upcoming month. But there has to be better execution going forward. This is sloppy and only act I of iii.  

 

The disconnect comes from you mentioning what these other artists are doing. they are NOT Beyonce, Beyonce is NOT them. BEYONCE DOES NOT WANT IT. Go find another fighter. She always said her career would come to the point where she wants to release albums and then go on tour. dassit. ya'll can't marvel at the video clip of her predicting & achieving what she wanted to do before 40 and then disregard all the rest of the stuff she said in other interviews about what she wanted the future to look like. we're living in the future that she talked about 10 years ago. this is it & this is all.

 

this is the same woman who released a new song in the middle of Drake's first album week. what gives the impression that she cares about Taylor's new album or Rihanna's? i personally don't even give af about their new music. yall seriously need to wake up. Beyonce has nothing left to prove....they can sell a bajillion records & stay at #1 for a year. i swear Beyonce ain't moving.

 

Edited by giRLbye.

3 minutes ago, giRLbye. said:

 

The disconnect comes from you mentioning what these other artists are doing. they are NOT Beyonce, Beyonce is NOT them. BEYONCE DOES NOT WANT IT. Go find another fighter. She always said her career would come to the point where she wants to release albums and then go on tour. dassit. ya'll can't marvel at the video clip of her predicting & achieving what she wanted to do before 40 and then disregard all the rest of the stuff she said in other interviews about what she wanted the future to look like. we're living in the future that she talked about 10 years ago. this is it & this is all.

 

this is the same woman who released a new song in the middle of Drake's first album week. what gives the impression that she cares about Taylor's new album or Rihanna's? i personally don't even give af about their new music. yall seriously need to wake up. Beyonce has nothing left to prove....they can sell a bajillion records & stay at #1 for a year. i swear Beyonce ain't moving.

 

#1 where? And this is why Beyonce is as pretentious as she is tbh. At this rate, her legacy will not be as strong as her predecessors. That is the truth. It's going to take more than cosplaying as Prince and Sade to sell herself as this unbothered legend who still submits her mess to the major awards, only to lose cause she won't campaign and knows she has a fanbase that cries racism and whatever else.

 

She's lucky the music is good and is trying to stick to the charts despite her aversion aversion for it. Now we're holding out for a record breaking world tour because thats her crowing jewel as an artist. We'll see.

The thing about the releasing albums and going on tour thing is that Bey wants her fans engaged.  She wants that IVP money.  She wants people to watch those documentary's.  She wants to be a cultural icon (by her own admission).  She wants to sell luxe items. 

 

You are not a cultural icon if no one checks for you.  No one will check for you if you are not engaging.  And not caring about commercial performance =/= no effort.  

@giRLbye.is right. I’m sure none of us agree with what Beyoncé is doing but this is her career and there’s nothing we can do about it. If all of the bs she’s doing bite her in the ass in the future then so be it. This is obviously what she wants :michael: 

all I want is for her to send Cuff It to radios at this point 

knowles.thumb.png.3db853821b2a3edca8d638

3 minutes ago, kimberly said:

if you're so tired of her, stop checking on her then :celestial5:

This :michael:

1 minute ago, period sis said:

all I want is for her to send Cuff It to radios at this point 

knowles.thumb.png.3db853821b2a3edca8d638

Listen to it on your own. That’s what I do. I haven’t listened to radio in over a decade.

3 minutes ago, kimberly said:

if you're so tired of her, stop checking on her then :celestial5:

This. I can't imagine putting this much time and what seems to be anguish over an album and career that isn't mine.

 

I got the meltdowns when we were six years out from a solo album and starving for music but now we have it. It's time to go put this energy into another artist or learn to take a breath and step back. I'm admittedly not as interested in Bey as I used to be (she's still my only fav) but honestly I don't need to know her every move or lack thereof when I haven an album this good to listen to every day.

3 minutes ago, ShouldersSideways said:

This. I can't imagine putting this much time and what seems to be anguish over an album and career that isn't mine.

 

I got the meltdowns when we were six years out from a solo album and starving for music but now we have it. It's time to go put this energy into another artist or learn to take a breath and step back. I'm admittedly not as interested in Bey as I used to be (she's still my only fav) but honestly I don't need to know her every move or lack thereof when I haven an album this good to listen to every day.

This. The album has been out two months and I’ve listened to it damn near everyday since its release. No one else streaming it doesn’t affect how I feel about the album.

10 minutes ago, Dreajae said:

#1 where? And this is why Beyonce is as pretentious as she is tbh. At this rate, her legacy will not be as strong as her predecessors. That is the truth. It's going to take more than cosplaying as Prince and Sade to sell herself as this unbothered legend who still submits her mess to the major awards, only to lose cause she won't campaign and knows she has a fanbase that cries racism and whatever else.

 

She's lucky the music is good and is trying to stick to the charts despite her aversion aversion for it. Now we're holding out for a record breaking world tour because thats her crowing jewel as an artist. We'll see.

 

and if her legacy is not as strong as her peers or predecessors then guess what!?! that's fine too!

 

Beyonce doesn't care...its not your fight. none of this angst is hitting home. she'll submit, lose, and still show up b/c none of this is really that serious. yall look crazy. take her lead & rest.

1 hour ago, Scorp said:

I've said it for years, BEYONCE' has always wanted to be a Mary J/Aretha (cultural QUEEN).  I feel her father always wanted her to be this global popstar and she never wanted it. She always wanted to be a hood girl singing and rapping. Literally read the room. Every feature is RAP. Every single has a RAP in it. She markets her career like a US based HipHop act. Why do you think she literally ONLY focused on Us/Europe for so long? It all makes sense with Church Girl being pushed like crazy release week when her actual POP SONGS were PRAISED by the label :lmao:She doesn't like that pop star ****. CLEARLY. Technically, she's released more rap style singles than pure vocals since 2010 anyways. I feel she hit her perfect mark on this album which is why it's my personal fave. She's never gonna be a typical pop/r&b singer again and y'all jus have to understand that. Her next album might be NO ID style HipHop and I just know the meltdowns are coming. 

Dreamgirl teas :lmao: but very true. The only thing is she wouldn’t have been the “cultural force” she is today without the commercial success and machine backing her.

Today may be a new low :coffee2:

 

Yall gotta stop letting these other big names rattle you so much. All this kicked off again cuz Taylor promotes and people are excited about RiRi. Beyoncé has had her opportunities throughout her career to maximize and capitalize and she’s decided to just chill out now. It is what it is. 

 

She’s slowly pivoted from being that girl over the past decade and she doesn’t care, period. Yes, it would be easy to send **** to radio, do bts studio clips, record an acapella moment, or check in thru social media more, I agree with that and I laugh and smh at the decisions made as well, but she don’t want to do any of it.
 

We all know her approach isn’t doing her any favors in the long run but If she wants to do this semi-retired thing, let her get on to the fast track to legacy act lane in peace :fan:

1 hour ago, giRLbye. said:

 

Beyonce's reason is that she doesn't care about that **** anymore...period. You can't force a mindset to change overnight. you mentioning her husband & what he does for a male-identified hot take like their supposed to be siamese twins sharing the same brain is not the argument you think it is.

 

married people don't have to agree on everything in life and how Beyonce & Jay Z view the music industry, their individual careers, and what the future of those careers look like for themselves is their own separate ideology. they don't have to align on anything except their marriage and how they raise their children. not whether one wants more streaming numbers and the other is fine where they are. lets get serious with these takes pls.

Beyoncé shoots visuals for every album. Stop with “she doesn’t care” narrative. Artists that don’t care go on hiatus and you don’t hear from them. Y’all make it seem like Beyoncé is is Sade or Anita Baker or someone that stays under a rock. She still puts out music very consistently, whether it’s a side album or a feature. Even her side album received an accompanying visual. She always goes on tour, and attends the Grammys. Stop saying she doesn’t care as a reason why this roll out sucks. She cares! Her team has just been mishandling eras, nothing more, nothing less. Releasing an album, with an accompanying visual, then going on a world tour is way more effort than most artists. Other than this album she’s put a lot of effort into the the accompanying material, it’s just hasn’t propelled the era. The better question is why does she put effort in things like BIK once the era is dead, rather than doing something at the time of release?

 

How do you put effort into a visual album, but not put effort into sending the singles to radio? Make it make sense.

17 minutes ago, Blumoon said:

The thing about the releasing albums and going on tour thing is that Bey wants her fans engaged.  She wants that IVP money.  She wants people to watch those documentary's.  She wants to be a cultural icon (by her own admission).  She wants to sell luxe items. 

 

You are not a cultural icon if no one checks for you.  No one will check for you if you are not engaging.  And not caring about commercial performance =/= no effort.  

This is what I'm saying. They make it seem like Bey is some artist selling mixtapes out of her trunk for the love of it. No. Bey pops out and wants to push multi million dollar campaigns and release albums about knocking Basquiats off the wall. She gloats about cultural currency and being an icon. 

 

But wait. Bey just wants to be a wife and mother. None of the facets of stardom matter. Let her rest and have her privacy after a 6 year studio album break and 2 side projects no one really asked for and she didn't even promote. So what's exhausting her or stopping her from her "joy"?

 

No ones asking Bey to bend over backwards. Imagine saying people need to get some air cause they're wondering why Beyonce hasn't been seen since her album dropped 2 months ago. "Oh she's done enough". Yeah, withholding her music from streaming for years and yachting. 

7 minutes ago, BrooklynBoy said:

Beyoncé shoots visuals for every album. Stop with “she doesn’t care” narrative. Artists that don’t care go on hiatus and you don’t hear from them. Y’all make it seem like Beyoncé is is Sade or Anita Baker or someone that stays under a rock. She still puts out music very consistently, whether it’s a side album or a feature. Even her side album received an accompanying visual. She always goes on tour, and attends the Grammys. Stop saying she doesn’t care as a reason why this roll out sucks. She cares! Her team has just been mishandling eras, nothing more, nothing less. Releasing an album, with an accompanying visual, then going on a world tour is way more effort than most artists. Other than this album she’s put a lot of effort into the the accompanying material, it’s just hasn’t propelled the era. The better question is why does she put effort in things like BIK once the era is dead, rather than doing something at the time of release?

 

How do you put effort into a visual album, but not put effort into sending the singles to radio? Make it make sense.

 

she doesn't and yall gaslight yourselves into thinking she does b/c she's not tired of the recording process & the visual part of things yet. once those things become daunting & unexciting for her...that will stop too & she'll be in full retirement. there's a marked difference from the Beyonce who admittedly said her 20s were focused on commercial success & establishing herself and the Beyonce of today. lets say the visuals were mishandled, okay, you mean there were no TV appearances or anything else lined up for 4 months?? come on...this is deliberate. the old Beyonce that cared & had something to prove would've been on stage at the BET Awards for BMS release and would've went on her bday trip the day AFTER her performance at the VMA awards instead.

 

she doesnt care...this as much effort as she cares to give at this point in her career. welcome into stanning for a veteran artist.

I’m actually satisfied right now, cuff it is smashing and promoting the album, and we got a tour coming. 
 

my biggest complaint was her best album not reaching people, and I feel like it definitely is now. I can bop in peace. 

30 minutes ago, ShouldersSideways said:

This. I can't imagine putting this much time and what seems to be anguish over an album and career that isn't mine.

 

I got the meltdowns when we were six years out from a solo album and starving for music but now we have it. It's time to go put this energy into another artist or learn to take a breath and step back. I'm admittedly not as interested in Bey as I used to be (she's still my only fav) but honestly I don't need to know her every move or lack thereof when I haven an album this good to listen to every day.

:cm:
 

I literally cannot stop listening to this album, I can’t even listen to anything else besides this album. After waiting for 6 long years this album is everything I ever wanted and more, and that’s all I need. I refuse to give myself a stroke ranting and raving about all the missed opportunities of this era because this is nothing new. That, and I don’t care about “stanning” and tracking her every move. I will be more than happy with an album, tour, and visuals whenever they might decide to come out.

 

I don’t care about the state of her career or legacy unless god forbid I see the headline “Beyoncé filing for bankruptcy, tour a colossal failure” and she’s homeless on the streets and a forgotten fad like Keri Hilson. Until that day comes, (which it never will) I don’t give a damn that she’s a silent hermit, and I suggest you guys learn this quick or just move on:cm: This convo is past beating a dead horse, the horse is mega dead.

Let’s say she and her team is mishandling everything, what are you all gonna do about it? Stop supporting and spending your money on her if you all feel like this about it. I for one won’t be buying any more box sets, vinyls, digital albums or singles. I’ll just continue to stream on Tidal.

31 minutes ago, Dreajae said:

This is what I'm saying. They make it seem like Bey is some artist selling mixtapes out of her trunk for the love of it. No. Bey pops out and wants to push multi million dollar campaigns and release albums about knocking Basquiats off the wall. She gloats about cultural currency and being an icon. 

 

But wait. Bey just wants to be a wife and mother. None of the facets of stardom matter. Let her rest and have her privacy after a 6 year studio album break and 2 side projects no one really asked for and she didn't even promote. So what's exhausting her or stopping her from her "joy"?

 

No ones asking Bey to bend over backwards. Imagine saying people need to get some air cause they're wondering why Beyonce hasn't been seen since her album dropped 2 months ago. "Oh she's done enough". Yeah, withholding her music from streaming for years and yachting. 

The ones that are so above this Beyonce conversation need to remember yall are on a stan website logged in talking about Bey lol. If the convo bores you just scroll. 

 

Mixtapes lol…cause why is a hermit indie artist doing Vogue layouts. That is what gets me ?!  It takes more effort to shoot the editorials than send a song to radio.  Its backwards and feels try hard.  Thats what I dont like.  

 

I wonder what act ii is gonna sound like.  I really like Virgos Groove and the production, as well as Cuff It.  Bey shines when she is doin funk and retro (see: Cadillac Records and Work It Out).  I really need a full CD of that energy. 

Edited by Blumoon

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.