Isn’t that Cindy Lee album not on streaming services? Are you going to make everyone buy a physical copy on Bandcamp to participate?

4 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

Isn’t that Cindy Lee album not on streaming services? Are you going to make everyone buy a physical copy on Bandcamp to participate?

It's on YouTube!

 

 

53 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Who can you replace her with? 

Still, Erika de Casier? I suppose for someone more mainstream there's Kali Uchis, though that's much less outright R&B. Kehlani? Chloe? (can't remember what hers sounded like tbh) My underrated queen Gavin Turek even tho that album was way more pop than her previous R&B record? That Amber Mark B-sides EP?

7 hours ago, Ewan Chaos said:

Still, Erika de Casier? I suppose for someone more mainstream there's Kali Uchis, though that's much less outright R&B. Kehlani? Chloe? (can't remember what hers sounded like tbh) My underrated queen Gavin Turek even tho that album was way more pop than her previous R&B record? That Amber Mark B-sides EP?

Chloe! Yes, @MP2K! Or Kehlani!

On 4/21/2025 at 9:41 PM, Ace Reject said:

It's on YouTube!

if it's easier for anyone i downloaded it when they were giving it away for nothing so i could put it up on a wetransfer for a week

 

tbh tho it's 2 hours long and i don't think it's likely to raise a lot of ATRL interest lol (takes 45 minutes to get going, sounds like reheated velvet underground), i think i'd switch it out for magdalena bay or something?

Edited April 26, 20251 yr by makeawish

On 4/26/2025 at 4:31 PM, makeawish said:

if it's easier for anyone i downloaded it when they were giving it away for nothing so i could put it up on a wetransfer for a week

 

tbh tho it's 2 hours long and i don't think it's likely to raise a lot of ATRL interest lol (takes 45 minutes to get going, sounds like reheated velvet underground), i think i'd switch it out for magdalena bay or something?

Totally forgot MB! Yes, much more ATRL coded.

Good evening mods, with the 10-year anniversary of the critically acclaimed album E•MO•TION fast approaching, I would like to humbly request permission to host the forum's much-requested and highly-anticipated first Carly Rae Jepsen discography rate to celebrate

6 minutes ago, penguintim said:

Good evening mods, with the 10-year anniversary of the critically acclaimed album E•MO•TION fast approaching, I would like to humbly request permission to host the forum's much-requested and highly-anticipated first Carly Rae Jepsen discography rate to celebrate

@Ace Reject this is a great idea. long overdue!

18 hours ago, penguintim said:

Good evening mods, with the 10-year anniversary of the critically acclaimed album E•MO•TION fast approaching, I would like to humbly request permission to host the forum's much-requested and highly-anticipated first Carly Rae Jepsen discography rate to celebrate

Sure!

@penguintim are we doing the carly rate

Speaking of discography rates , enough time has passed since Tension II to revive the idea of a Kylie rate, don't you think?
 

I might be willing to host… 

We should do a spiritual successor to the Pre-Madonna rate we had on OldTRL, but it's the Pre-Rihannas and focuses on R&B girls from the late '90s/early 2000s whose careers stalled once the Rih (and Bey) dominance really happened

 

 

The concept of this as a rate 

 

33 minutes ago, Eeveelution said:

 

The concept of this as a rate 

 

the way the listening for it would take 2 hours total

2 hours ago, Eeveelution said:

 

The concept of this as a rate 

 

The concept of This Was Bushwick 2025: Dunkin Checkers Popeyes Myrtle Ave station corner as Indie Popgirl symbolism

On 6/5/2025 at 11:18 AM, conatus said:

We should do a spiritual successor to the Pre-Madonna rate we had on OldTRL, but it's the Pre-Rihannas and focuses on R&B girls from the late '90s/early 2000s whose careers stalled once the Rih (and Bey) dominance really happened

time for ashanti chapter ii supremacy

4 minutes ago, makeawish said:

time for ashanti chapter ii supremacy

And when Rain On Me is the first song in ATRL Rate history to get a 10.0 average...

On 6/7/2025 at 11:25 AM, Eeveelution said:

 

The concept of this as a rate 

 

Let's have you host the Tension/That! Feels Good/The Loveliest Time/Something to Give Each Other rate first please!!!!

On 6/5/2025 at 6:18 AM, conatus said:

We should do a spiritual successor to the Pre-Madonna rate we had on OldTRL, but it's the Pre-Rihannas and focuses on R&B girls from the late '90s/early 2000s whose careers stalled once the Rih (and Bey) dominance really happened

 

You want to bring back the UOGs?

2 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

You want to bring back the UOGs?

Did we ever have an edition that covered those girls (Christina Milian/Ashanti/Keyshia/etc.)? It's been so long, I can't remember

 

26 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Let's have you host the Tension/That! Feels Good/The Loveliest Time/Something to Give Each Other rate first please!!!!

Poor Troye having to sub-in as the fourth diva because of Roisin Terfy's evil ways

 

 

But sure, I'll think about it!

8 hours ago, conatus said:

Did we ever have an edition that covered those girls (Christina Milian/Ashanti/Keyshia/etc.)? It's been so long, I can't remember

 

We DID. Christina Milan was in UOG: Teen Dreams with Hilary and Lindsay and Raven and them.

 

Ashanti, Keyshia, Amerie, Jazmine, Keri were in another UOG rate. (Obvi 1 Thing won!)

If.... hypothetically UOG were to come back, which 00s rate would do the best?

 

a) the indie girls (and not today's indie - I'm on that Joanna Newsom type shit!)

b) the non Amy/Lily Brit girls

c) the girl group members gone solo/Idol and X-Factor winners and runnerups

 

I made all of these playlists years ago btw.

 

@supaspaz@Reverie@EJQL8@Eeveelution@Achilles.@conatus@Graves@Tom Vercetti

I want British girls, but who exactly? The likes of Kate Nash, Amy Macdonald and Bat For Lashes or more like Pixie Lott?

8 minutes ago, Suilen said:

I want British girls, but who exactly? The likes of Kate Nash, Amy Macdonald and Bat For Lashes or more like Pixie Lott?

Two of those three... you see the vision. We go deep over here!