22 hours ago, Peroxide said:

Not sure if I have the time to organise or host it but a Gaga rate would get a LOT of interest... and there's a lot of material to work with.

I would love to host one after the Florence one

 

However, I do believe we should wait at least two-three more months before starting one, so that MAYHEM's hype can calm down and we have more "objective" ballots

17 hours ago, right where you left me said:

@Ace Reject can I get your approval to host a Rihanna Discography Rate? It's been a while.

WAIT! @Ace Reject let the good sis @right where you left me do this !! :D

 

say it coming for top 5

20 hours ago, right where you left me said:

@Ace Reject can I get your approval to host a Rihanna Discography Rate? It's been a while.

omg yess!!

I hope to see Amy Winehouse rate one day. It's probably gonna be a short rate cuz her discography is not huge () but it would be nice to have one if we didn't have it already before 

May I host an Avril Lavigne discography rate

On 3/19/2025 at 4:10 PM, right where you left me said:

@Ace Reject can I get your approval to host a Rihanna Discography Rate? It's been a while.

Sure!

Can I host a Dua Lipa discography rate? I've got the song list ready and ****

Edited March 28, 20251 yr by Peak Now

15 minutes ago, Peak Now said:

Can I host a Dua Lipa discography rate? I've got the song list ready and ****

Omg yes please 

1 hour ago, right where you left me said:

Omg yes please 

If I do it I'm gonna steal... I mean borrow your formatting

 

HI @Ace Reject! The "Florence + The Machine" megarate has successfully concluded! Thank you once again for approving the rate and allowing me to host it!

 

 

 

The winner is Cosmic Love with a 9.737 score! Here are the final results from the 45 partecipants:

 

Spoiler

RESULTS:

The overall album scores are the following ones:

 

1. How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful: 8.251 (8.437 if we consider just the STW-M run)

2. Ceremonials: 7.961 (8.360 if we consider just the OIFAN-LMB run)

3. High As Hope: 7.595

4. Lungs: 7.145 (7.627 if we consider just the DDAO-YGTL run, making it 3rd)

5. Final Fantasy XV EP: 6.816

6. Dance Fever: 6.612 (7.195 if we consider just the K-ME run, making it 5th)

7. Other Songs Section: 5.637 (Unreleased: 5.317; Featurings: 5.432; Others: 6.294)

 

The overall scores for the individual songs are the following ones: 

127. King (Poem Version): 3.263
126. Cassandra (Poem Version): 3.556
125. My Love (Poem Version): 3.684
124. Halo: 3.706
123. You've Got The Dirtee Love (with Dizzee Rascal): 4.176
122. Not Fade Away: 4.206
121. Jools Holland, Florence Welch - My Baby Just Cares For Me: 4.571
120. Ye Old Hope (Tear Out My Tongue): 4.600
119. Where Are U Now: 4.606
118. David Byrne, Fatboy Slim - Here Lies Love (ft. Florence Welch): 4.621
117. Flakes: 4.694
116. Throwing Bricks: 4.750
115. Donkey Kosh / Florrible and Misrabella: 4.765
114. My Best Dress: 4.778
113. White Cliffs Of Dover: 4.781
112. Felix White - Midnight (ft. Florence Welch): 5.033
111. The Rolling Stones - Wild Horses (ft. Florence Welch): 5.086
110. Postcards From Italy: 5.091
109. Rufus Wainwright - When In Disgrace With Fortune And Men's Eyes (ft. Florence Welch): 5.135
108. Hospital Beds: 5.139
106. ASAP Rocky - I Come Apart (ft. Florence Welch): 5.286
107. Halloween: 5.286
105. Ghosts: 5.333
104. Search And Destroy: 5.438
103. Restraint: 5.450
102. Jenny Of Oldstones: 5.467
101. Back In Town: 5.469
100. Taylor Swift - Florida!!! (ft. Florence & The Machine): 5.484
99. Cornflake Girl: 5.515
98. Are You Hurting The One You Love?: 5.600
97. I Love You All The Time: 5.606
96. Prayer Factory: 5.667
95. Baptize: 5.703
94. Kiss With A Fist: 5.743
93. Take Care: 5.758
92. Tantalus: 5.824
91. Tiny Dancer: 5.879
90. I Will Be: 5.912
89. Call Me Cruella: 5.985
88. Girl With An Eye: 6.000
87. Addicted To Love: 6.000
86. Just A Girl: 6.029
85. Haunted House: 6.047
84. Lady Gaga - Hey Girl (ft. Florence Welch): 6.171
83. Girls Against God: 6.206
82. Covered In Blood (WTF): 6.243
81. Grace: 6.348
80. Spectrum (Say My Name) - Calvin Harris Remix: 6.421
79. What The Water Gave Me (Demo): 6.429
78. I'm Not Calling You A Liar: 6.455
77. Mermaids: 6.655
76. Honey: 6.667

75: Hurricane Drunk: 6.727
74: Lover To Lover: 6.733
73: Bird Song: 6.781
72: My Boy Builds Coffins: 6.848
71: Remain Nameless: 6.909
70: 100 Years: 6.914
69: Stand By Me: 6.946
68: Landscape: 6.956
67: Falling: 6.968
66: Morning Elvis: 6.968
65: Patricia: 7.000
64: Swimming: 7.063
63: Light Of Love: 7.088
62: Sky Full Of Song: 7.167
61: Conductor: 7.177
60: Heaven Is Here: 7.189
59: Caught: 7.207
58: Hardest Of Hearts: 7.250
57: Bedroom Hymns: 7.276
56: Heartlines: 7.281
55: Between Two Lungs: 7.417
54: June: 7.438
53: Strangeness & Charm: 7.453
52: Blinding: 7.530
51: King: 7.531 

50: You've Got The Love: 7.576
49: Wish That You Were Here: 7.583
48: Too Much Is Never Enough: 7.591
47: Breath Of Life: 7.636
46: No Choir: 7.647
45: The Bomb: 7.656
44: Third Eye: 7.667
43: Long & Lost: 7.677
42: Hiding: 7.727
41: Calvin Harris - Sweet Nothing (ft. Florence Welch): 7.771
40: Moderation: 7.806
39: Breaking Down: 7.809
38: Leave My Body: 7.864
37: Make Up Your Mind: 7.897
36: Heavy In Your Arms: 7.900
35: South London Forever: 7.956
34: Over The Love: 7.970
33: Pure Feeling: 8.061
32: All This And Heaven Too: 8.061
31: Ship To Wreck: 8.103
30: Choreomania: 8.133
29: As Far As I Could Get: 8.233
28: Big God: 8.250
27: Seven Devils: 8.265
26: Dream Girl Evil: 8.273

25. St. Jude: 8.338
24. Daffodil: 8.345
23. Which Witch: 8.368
22. The End Of Love: 8.406
21. Mother: 8.414
20. Drumming Song: 8.419
19. Delilah: 8.500
18. Cassandra: 8.543
17. Shake It Out: 8.545
16. Free: 8.547
15. Spectrum: 8.679
14. Howl: 8.710
13. Various Storms & Saints: 8.710
12. My Love: 8.800
11. Only If For A Night: 8.814
10. Hunger: 8.824
9. Rabbit Heart (Raise It Up): 8.933
8. Dog Days Are Over: 9.059
7. No Light, No Light: 9.197
6. What Kind Of Man: 9.282
5. Queen Of Peace: 9.410
4. Never Let Me Go: 9.485
3. How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful: 9.500

2. What The Water Gave Me: 9.588

1. Cosmic Love: 9.737

 

Gimme More is #1 song. Next rate I'm gonna host (previously approved) gonna be Divas rate - 4th edition, but not now tho, I kinda wanna to rest after hosting since August lol

 

Following the success of the Girls Aloud singles megarate, when can I do one for The Saturdays? 

Thank you both! 

 

@Freaky Prince Do The Sats have a big enough audience for... um...

On 9/24/2024 at 9:57 PM, Saddy said:

I'd love to host it, but idk if I can host 2 rates at the same time tbh 

Now's the time if you wanted to host SOFT LANDINGS! 

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

Now's the time if you wanted to host SOFT LANDINGS! 

Omg I don't even remember what it was lol let me check it 

On 9/24/2024 at 10:23 PM, Ace Reject said:

Looking for a host for SOFT LANDINGS of '23/'24 (Doja, Kacey, Dua, Megan) next!

 

So, it's gonna be Scarlet Claude, Deeper Well: Deeper into the Wall, Radical Optimism (non-extended version) and Megan: Act II or just standard versions?

51 minutes ago, Saddy said:

So, it's gonna be Scarlet Claude, Deeper Well: Deeper into the Wall, Radical Optimism (non-extended version) and Megan: Act II or just standard versions?

Standard versions of all four! (The bonus tracks from Megan were already in a rate.)

2 hours ago, Ace Reject said:

Thank you both! 

 

@Freaky Prince Do The Sats have a big enough audience for... um...

Idk probably not, I was gonna shelve it if it has less than like idk 30 submissions 

I know she's fallen out of favour with, like, sanity, but have we ever done a Gwen Stefani (+No Doubt) rate? I'd be so here for it if somebody wanted to host it!

I was lowkey thinking of doing a TLC Discography Rate (if one has not been done/hasn't been done in a while). I'm just afraid they're might be like 10 people in the rate 

Edited April 1, 20251 yr by gagacasanova

I should keep my mouth shut cause I need to finish or revamp my Hiatus rates... but I'm all about the R&B representation so what about

State of R&B 2024: Access All Areas (Flo) v. Bird's Eye (Rayvn Lenae) v. DOPAMINE (Normani) v. TYLA (Tyla)

Thought I had recently: I remember years n years ago we did a Madge ballads rate, about 50 ballads from the queen's entire discography or something. Maybe we oughta do a sequel rate with her heir to the throne, Miss Cowboy Carter?

On 4/8/2025 at 10:28 AM, Graves said:

Thought I had recently: I remember years n years ago we did a Madge ballads rate, about 50 ballads from the queen's entire discography or something. Maybe we oughta do a sequel rate with her heir to the throne, Miss Cowboy Carter?

You think she's the ballad queen now?

On 4/4/2025 at 12:47 PM, MP2K said:

I should keep my mouth shut cause I need to finish or revamp my Hiatus rates... but I'm all about the R&B representation so what about

State of R&B 2024: Access All Areas (Flo) v. Bird's Eye (Rayvn Lenae) v. DOPAMINE (Normani) v. TYLA (Tyla)

Dopamine will be in the "OH SHOOT: At Least You Tried" rate of 2024, alongside her former bandmate plus J. Lo and Ms. Perry. Who can you replace her with? 

Oh right.

 

Even with Charli and Bey and Billie and Sabrina in other rates, we have to discuss (?) THIS WAS 2024.

 

The Cure. Vampire Weekend. Cindy Lee. St. Vincent. Kendrick Lamar. Fontaines D.C. MJ Lenderman. Mkgee. Clairo. Tyler the Creator. Waxahatchee. 

 

What selection of albums would make the best rate?