1 hour ago, SweetOreosOfHeaven said:

Yeah madonna is such a relatable humble ny girl

Madonna has always been true to who she is and hasn't changed personalities or humour.

Gaga is very different compared to 2009-2014. She's become more Hollywood.

Y'all need to let this dumb Gar vs Medonster discussion go. Both albums are great in their own way.

27 minutes ago, Plasticdoll said:

Madonna has always been true to who she is and hasn't changed personalities or humour.

Gaga is very different compared to 2009-2014. She's become more Hollywood.

That's because she doesn't have a personality. She had to live under a faux persona in the public eye, which changes in direct response to whatever makes her popular. Her personal life is dull as dishwater. Madonna's core stems from the death of her mother. Gaga's stems from being jealous over her father's grief over his dead sister. Explains much.

Edited July 5Jul 5 by ____Summer

1 hour ago, ____Summer said:

That's because she doesn't have a personality. She had to live under a faux persona in the public eye, which changes in direct response to whatever makes her popular. Her personal life is dull as dishwater. Madonna's core stems from the death of her mother. Gaga's stems from being jealous over her father's grief over his dead sister. Explains much.

Don't get me wrong, I used to be a huge super fan of Gaga in my teens. I even took her side over the madonna mess back in 2011, but the humble new york girl seems to of disappeared. Especially now her tour ticket prices which now cost 1000s of dollars. Back then she would have been so against the machine and corporate capitalism.

You gays are overrating Madonna's album so much

On 7/4/2026 at 8:50 PM, LewisK said:

Not 100% into Confesions' overall genre or style, I'm much more an over the top maximalist gothic theater kid just as Gaga, so Mayhem will always win.

With that said, I was surprised by how brilliant, elegant, avantgarde and cohesive Confesions is. Except for a few songs, I thought Madonna had lost it the last couple of decades. But having this vision, this talent, this... Everything, so many decades into her career. Trully remarkable, nobody will ever reach her.

Exactly my thoughts.

Mayhem is an excellent theatrical, dark mood pop album, I like my **** more noisy. CII is very colorful, so it's not my cup of tea. However it's really good :)

18 hours ago, Plasticdoll said:

Madonna has always been true to who she is and hasn't changed personalities or humour.

Gaga is very different compared to 2009-2014. She's become more Hollywood.

the delusional takes in this thread are something else.

18 hours ago, ____Summer said:

That's because she doesn't have a personality. She had to live under a faux persona in the public eye, which changes in direct response to whatever makes her popular. Her personal life is dull as dishwater. Madonna's core stems from the death of her mother. Gaga's stems from being jealous over her father's grief over his dead sister. Explains much.

this is delusional and also disgusting on many levels.

Mayhem wins this with no problem.

45 minutes ago, Fishh said:

the delusional takes in this thread are something else.

oh honey this is coming from a die hard gaga stan all throughout my teens and early 20s.. but it's okay to admit gaga has changed.

MAYHEM for sure

13 hours ago, ElectricFrancis said:

You gays are overrating Madonna's album so much

me after my deaf diagnosis:

14 hours ago, ElectricFrancis said:

You gays are overrating Madonna's album so much

Confessions II obviously

Chromatica is a much better album than Mayhem.

I'm not listening to a madonna album in 2026.

OT: Gaga

Not the one which will be forgotten next week without any strong/memorable single and grindr promo runs out

I hope it manages to stay at least 4-5m daily or at least 10+ more variants produced to milk those gays

For me Mayhem, but Confessions II is GREAT and only Madonna can do that. Queen.

1 hour ago, Anna Mesha. said:

produced to milk those gays

4 hours ago, oceans said:

She's not overrated, she's fairly scored and awarded 💋

Edited July 6Jul 6 by ElectricFrancis

4 minutes ago, ElectricFrancis said:

but they are so happy with their 83 or w/e

I prefer Mayhem as a whole, but both are great albums and exciting returns to form.

5 hours ago, Fav said:

me after my deaf diagnosis:

Hmm, I wrote that the album is good, I never said it's trash or anything. I am just stating the fact that gays are acting as if it's some sort of masterpiece when it's clearly not.

However I understand, your bar is absolutely low after the 3-album-punch she previously released, all of them are awful, unlistenable pieces of trash.

8 minutes ago, ElectricFrancis said:

Hmm, I wrote that the album is good, I never said it's trash or anything. I am just stating the fact that gays are acting as if it's some sort of masterpiece when it's clearly not.

However I understand, your bar is absolutely low after the 3-album-punch she previously released, all of them are awful, unlistenable pieces of trash.

6 hours ago, ____Summer said:

Like mother like daughter and you cant argue that its not designed for "milking"

Mayhem. No competition