Like I see this a lot, especially from Mariah fans.

Mariah would screech and the comments are like:

"WOW!!! Impressive F5"

"No, the D4 was flat"

"Who else could belt an E7 like that"

"effortless G5 right there"

or whatever it is they say

like.... hoe what?!

like how do they all just know this lol? it's like that with celine, whitney types too. it's like they come out of the womb knowing they'll be stans and somehow just know this

like, i get it, they stan vocalists but it's just so odd

with other pop stars, we don't care and don't keep track of that. even adele stans don't.

Edited June 15Jun 15 by Carbohydrates

I'm tone-deaf I guess

Edited June 15Jun 15 by milliondoses

I guess it's what happens when you spend years and years watching videos of your fave's vocals being analyzed by "vocal experts". I'm no expert but I can tell what note my fave is hitting just because of that lmao. Whether the technique or the note was properly executed is a different thing tho.

Edit: I've also noted that the fanbases which are more into vocals are those whose faves present themselves as "vocalists".

Edited June 15Jun 15 by thatsmydemi

Mariah stans being such vocal snobs is hilarious looking at how Mother's vocals are now

No, I'm a Lorde stan so I obviously don't know what a F5 is

its music theory !! and it makes sense that people who are really into music have at least a cursory knowledge of it, especially if what they enjoy is an impressive vocal

u learn through making ur own music, or playing instruments, or singing yourself !! but tbh i think maybe now a lot of people developed a working knowledge and some relative pitch from watching vocal analysis videos

By that logic im straight af

i couldnt guess what a note is to save my life , honestly up until a few years ago i thought singing was just free-balling it and doing what your ears were telling you sounds good

its an inherent ability of gays, if you dont have it your atrl account will be revoked

8 minutes ago, May said:

i couldnt guess what a note is to save my life , honestly up until a few years ago i thought singing was just free-balling it and doing what your ears were telling you sounds good

lol same

There is no note theory for Gracie Abrams stans. We just love the instrumental and vibes

The weirdest thing ever tbh, who cares if it D6 or H8

i dont see any katy perry gay stans doing that but ok

Some users have a musical background.

not since Zara's debut album left my hearing irrrreparably scarred

As a mariah/ariana stan, it's fun to see those analysis on tiktok

Wish I could get better at recognizing the notes, sounds like a cool skill to have

I'm tone deaf

50 minutes ago, Everyperfectsummer said:

No, I'm a Lorde stan so I obviously don't know what a F5 is

learn *****

1 hour ago, Everyperfectsummer said:

No, I'm a Lorde stan so I obviously don't know what a F5 is

the skream i let out

I love the mariah videos where she's barely hitting a note and then goes a bit higher for one and the screen is filled with "G7!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

me with ariana tour note compilation videos

You just don't like music enough.

No wonder Beyoncé stans are the most educated ones when it comes to this.

Only singing gays do. I used to be note obsessed. I'm still singing a lot and trying to improve my breath control, just as not as note obsessed.

I remember that one Mariah vocals YouTube channel posting a video of her yelping during her COVID shot and was like "Supported C5!!!!!11" like

Edited June 15Jun 15 by YourFavoriteWeapon