Now that MAYHEM's complete:

 

 

 

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

Marry The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

 

Born This Way: 11

MAYHEM: 6

 

Born This Way, album of the Millennium  Both masterpieces though.

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

 

TEOG / DWAS was hard to choose

 

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

 

Mayhem: 10

BTW: 7

 

Kind of surprised cause I thought BTW might be better but honestly Mayhem is just really solid across the board. BTW has very high highs but some its lows brought its score down.

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

 

Born This Way: 8

MAYHEM: 9 SCREAMING FOR ME BABYYYY

Marry The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road to Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill for Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow of a Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü and I / Blade of Grass

The Edge of Glory / Die With a Smile

 

11-6

Born This Way is a much better body of work, but Mayhem has standouts. 

Marry the Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

Scheiße / Killah

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus ✝ Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road to Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill for Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow of a Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü and I / Blade of Grass

The Edge of Glory / Die With a Smile

 

Born This Way, sweetie...

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

 

BTW: 12

Mayhem: 5

4 minutes ago, Curaga said:

Yoü and I / Blade of Grass

BTW all the way…

2 minutes ago, tost1 said:

I don't like Blade of Grass, but I hate Lüc more 

Mayhem wins 

Disease 

Abracadabra

Government Hooker

Judas

Americano (luv CSTH though)

Vanish Into You

Killah (luv scheibe)

ZombieBoy

Black Jesus

Bad Kids

Fashion of His Love

Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover

Electric Chappel

The Queen

Blade of Grass

The Edge of Glory

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug 

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

Edited September 3, 20251 yr by samngchaoyu

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

 

Born This Way: 11

Mayhem: 6

BTW is still superior in her discography

 

TEOG alone is way better than anything from Mayhem, let alone Judas and MTN

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

Scheiße / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

Born This Way: 11
MAYHEM: 6

Marry The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

Scheiße / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus † Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

 

BTW: 12
Mayhem: 5

Marry The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

Oh Mayhem don't do the girlies like that 

 

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden (tie)

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy (tie)

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love (tie)

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

 

Mayhem 10, BTW 4, 3 ties. All three ties are coincidentally on BTW's three best tracks, in my opinion, but happen to also be where Mayhem has some of its best highlights! I just couldn't give either one a clear win for those. I love Born This Way, but I think Mayhem did the "classic Gaga" thing so well and so compellingly that it comes out clearly ahead.

Mary The Night / Disease

Born This Way / Abracadabra

Government Hooker / Garden Of Eden

Judas / Perfect Celebrity

Americano / Can't Stop the High

Hair / Vanish Into You

ScheiBe / Killah (feat. Gesaffelstein)

Bloody Mary / Zombieboy

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / The Dead Dance

Bad Kids / LoveDrug

Fashion Of His Love / How Bad Do U Want Me

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Don't Call Tonight

Heavy Metal Lover / Kill For Love

Electric Chapel / Shadow Of A Man

The Queen / The Beast

Yoü And I / Blade Of Grass

The Edge Of Glory / Die With A Smile

Mayhem sweetie