Discuss

I don't know the stats but Legend X feels the biggest, maybe because I'm old

Only on ATRL could Xtina be winning the poll so far.

 

Miley had an overall bigger career and Avril has a bigger legacy.

1 minute ago, PerfectCure said:

Only on ATRL could Xtina be winning the poll so far.

 

Miley had an overall bigger career and Avril has a bigger legacy.

I mean it's literally 2 votes 

Just now, tost1 said:

I mean it's literally 2 votes 

2 is a bigger number than 0.

 

Miley is the biggest 

Miley for both

Xtina will win one of these polls one day

 

If you didn't vote for avril in legacy  go do your homework. Literally

Edited August 23, 20251 yr by Johnny Jacobs

Miley has the bigger career.

 

Avril has the bigger legacy. Her career definitely lasted way longer than Xtina's IMO. She also just sold out a Greatest Hits tour. Xtina could do a Greatest Hits tour and I honestly don't see it selling. Not easy for all the girls to do that.

Miley for career, Avril for legacy. 

Only miley is relevant out of these and has 2 big hits

Miley is the biggest (and the better artist overall)

 

Avril's and Xtina's legacy feel the same to me, I don't care about any of them so I voted Xtina

29 minutes ago, hrjox97 said:

Only miley is relevant out of these and has 2 big hits

Genie In A Bottle is Christina's Flowers

 

Don't even go there. That's one of the biggest pop songs ever.

Britney fans are so preoccupied with Xtina's place in the music industry, living rent-free. 

Miley is obviously the biggest. 

 

Legacy could go any way tbh. Avril has definitely inspired more newer artists, Xtina's legacy is actually pretty strong culturally and Miley has Hannah which a lot of people say Miley/Hannah raised an entire generation. 

42 minutes ago, Sharamee6 said:

Genie In A Bottle is Christina's Flowers

These are not even slightly close in terms of numbers and general success. 

Miley?

Miley for everything

Avril for everything!

1 hour ago, visions said:

Avril has definitely inspired more newer artists

This is such a lie. You can't listen to one singing competition show without hearing  Christina Aguilera songs & all the new big pop girls listed Christina's inspiration. 
 

What we are not going to do is downplay Xtina impact just because she quit music.
 

 

Complicated alone is bigger than any Xtina hit. Just check Spotify and watch the numbers. Xtina biggest hits in the platform are the collabs.

 

As a celebrity, Miley sweeps and she has three massive hits (Wrecking Ball, Party In The USA and Flowers) but Avril has never flopped as miserably as Miley did this year with Something Beautiful. 

Edited August 23, 20251 yr by Tyrion_LMG

56 minutes ago, Appletree said:

This is such a lie. You can't listen to one singing competition show without hearing  Christina Aguilera songs & all the new big pop girls listed Christina's inspiration. 
 

What we are not going to do is downplay Xtina impact just because she quit music.
 

 

I'm not downplaying it? I just think Avril has inspired more and bigger artists, so now what? 

 

Huge influence on two of the biggest gen z artists with Billie & Olivia and every 2nd gen disney girl (Miley, Demi, Selena etc.) had songs that were clearly inspired by Avril. 

this site is gone miley (not hannah) literally started out as an avril clone 

Edited August 23, 20251 yr by Mocha

Miley > Xtina > Avril for both.