3 hours ago, visions said:

Miley, Demi, Selena

Interesting for you to mention them as all 3 took a page from stripped era with Selena & Demi doing the black/white album cover stating stripped out their mouths & Miley literally copying & paste stripped aesthetic during bangers era.

 

 

3 hours ago, visions said:

Huge influence on two of the biggest gen z artists with Billie & Olivia

Xtina has Sabrina & Dua Lipa who both have videos stating inspiration & influenced. Mega stars. 

 

So what you're saying can be said about Xtina as well. 

 

1 hour ago, Appletree said:

Interesting for you to mention them as all 3 took a page from stripped era with Selena & Demi doing the black/white album cover stating stripped out their mouths & Miley literally copying & paste stripped aesthetic during bangers era.

 

 

Xtina has Sabrina & Dua Lipa who both have videos stating inspiration & influenced. Mega stars. 

 

So what you're saying can be said about Xtina as well. 

 

Fair point but I still see the Avril influence a lot stronger than the Christina for the Disney girls. 

 

And I half agree for Bangerz.. The influence is for there but aesthetically I'm not seeing much similarly, especially not enough to call it copy paste nn

I feel like Avril's legacy is so underestimated. I think she had bigger eras than Christina globally and in terms of longevity. Overall career I think Miley has the biggest one out of all them, followed by Avril then Christina.

Stripped>>>>>>>>>>the other 2 careers

 

Miley's career feels bigger but Xtina has the greatest legacy

 

Avril is bigger in Asia tho

 

 

7 minutes ago, HANZ94 said:

Stripped>>>>>>>>>>the other 2 careers

 

Let Go came out the same year as Stripped and it's way bigger, more influential, and actually remembered in 2025 

Miley >>>>>>>>> Avril > Christina

Avril > Miley >>>>>>>> Xtina

1 hour ago, Appletree said:

Xtina has Sabrina & Dua Lipa who both have videos stating inspiration & influenced. Mega stars. 

 

Miley has influenced Sabrina, Billie, Olivia, Tate, Addison, Chappell, etc. Literally all of Gen Z's biggest stars. Sabrina is the only Gen-Z artist who claims Xtina. And no, 30 year old Dua Lipa isn't Gen-Z.  

 

OT: Miley > Avril > Xtina, for both career and influence.

Edited August 23, 20251 yr by Anticipating

1 hour ago, Anticipating said:

Let Go came out the same year as Stripped and it's way bigger, more influential, and actually remembered in 2025 

I am talking about the quality of the album

Stripped is better than anything the other 2 ever did

 

Edited August 23, 20251 yr by HANZ94

Christina. She has iconic pop hits, an overall successful career and a voice that's instantly recognizable.

Avril for legacy. She was that gurl in the 2000s and had 3 great eras

1 hour ago, Anticipating said:

Sabrina is the only Gen-Z artist who claims Xtina

Another lie from this user shocker! 

5 minutes ago, Appletree said:

Another lie from this user shocker! 

Name at least five Gen-Z artists who cite Xtina as a major influence. I'll wait. 

12 hours ago, Sharamee6 said:

Genie In A Bottle is Christina's Flowers

 

Don't even go there. That's one of the biggest pop songs ever.

I don't think I've ever heard that song 

Avrilis foreverythingeveryth.

Can someone post some receipts for sales

 

Im kinda leaning towards Avril for all. Miley is a bigger celebrity but Avril easily has the biggest musical legacy