DaphneGuinness

Gaga can be NYC, Malibu, Rio or Tokyo

Olivia Dean will most likely win all pop categories this year. Olivia Rodrigo should win AOTY though. Slayyyter and Madonna can share the dance ones.

TFM: Dance in the dark, Speechless, Paper Gangsta could've had videos and been singles/promo singles BTW: Government Hooker, Americano, Sheiße and Heavy Metal Lover could've easily been singles ASIB: ARUTW and INLA shoud've been radio singles with the same promo as Shallow. Mayhem: Vanish into you, Garden of Eden and How bad do you want me shoud've been singles with videos as well

Both are bigger than several of their peers

It has almost 3M more units than Renaissance worldwide. It also performed better than Renaissance on the Billboard Global chart as well as the IFPI chart. Maybe step outside the USA?

Mayhem has 400k pure units in USA. Like I said before, we've calculated this several times on Gaga chart forums and around 50% streaming units come from DWAS.

That's objectively wrong. The album has moved more than 2M units and around 1M of them are because of DWAS. That's 50% not 70%. And it's normal for albums with ginormous hits to have that ratio.

Yawn

Gaga has already honoured Marilyn and Judy in Dance in the Dark but I'd love an Italian inspired song about Sophia Loren

Olivia Rodrigo should win. Olivia Dean is also a cute winner. They definitely defined the year with their music.

It's a beautiful album

She's definitely more brave and outspoken than 99% of ATRL's favourite "legendary" pop girls so it's fine

The way both Billie and Olivia have said that they admire Gaga and now they share the same record as their fave. We love to see it

The Fame Monster is a reissue of The Fame and it was still nominated for AOTY separately. That's like two AOTY nominations for one album. Your fave could never.

Vanish into you feels way more emotional. Maybe because I saw it performed live and I will always associate that beautiful summer with this song

Magnesium does the same thing and is also good for you. I love taking melatonin on the plane though

Imagine thinking Telephone isn't legendary

Anyone who attended the Mayhem ball (her best and biggest tour so far) will say the opposite

Mayhem singles on the German chart: DWAS: #4 (72 weeks) Abra: #4 (52 weeks) TDD: #12 (14 weeks) That's 138 weeks for one album alone. Who else can compare?

Yes it did lol. Both DWAS and Abra were #4. Even The Dead Dance was #12 in Germany. Mayhem was a huge era in the country.

This too

Lady Ga Ga has like countless alter egos so we can't choose one

This is just one metric. One artist can be bigger in countless other ways

Yeah, covers of 100 year old songs obviously have more streams than original pop music, right?

Not the gotcha you think it is because Gaga's discography has 3 jazz cover albums and 3 remix albums that inflate her total tracks. Let's focus on the 10 BILLION streams lead she has over your fave.