Comparing her new music to old, even if we compare to her more "fun" songs, it pales in comparison:

 

 

Thoughts?

 

 

Obviously lol. NARAS agrees.

No, it's a fun bop. She'll have her emotional ballads still when the album drops.

 

Side note – I'm just gonna ignore that one delusional Xtina fan in the reply above me

 

 

She has been creatively and artistically bankrupt for a long time.

 

miles better than Type Dumbass

Yes she lost her touch with this AI generated song Type Dangerous.

I wanted to love the song but it's unlistenable. 
 

she's great at songs like touch my body and obsessed. I think that's the direction she should've followed. She's still a big legend and can still get a big hit. Obviously she had a very traumatic experience losing her mom and sister the same day that's rough and it would impact anyone no matter how strong they are.

 

she definitely can still get a hit she has the personality to go viral.

Not really. She can still make a good R&B track, she's just past her prime so no matter what she puts out, she'll never smash like that.

 

Nostalgia always blurs objectiveness too.

No. Never count Mariah Carey out.

well no, her last album caution was INCREDIBLE

 

let her do different styles of songs dammit!

no she hasn't she lost her voice. Dont try to fight me on this lambs you know she does like 90% lipsyncing now

Edited July 16, 20251 yr by Ryusei

Not a fan of the new single but Caution was a good album. It's just sad to hear her damaged voice nowadays

Caution is her last album, so I will not judge her new one by the buzz single

Her last album was amazing so no

She just released a bad a single…something ALL of our faves are guilty of ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ 

She still has it and one single isn't really an indication of the quality of the album.

22 minutes ago, Supernatural94 said:

I wanted to love the song but it's unlistenable. 
 

she's great at songs like touch my body and obsessed. I think that's the direction she should've followed. She's still a big legend and can still get a big hit. Obviously she had a very traumatic experience losing her mom and sister the same day that's rough and it would impact anyone no matter how strong they are.

 

she definitely can still get a hit she has the personality to go viral.

 

4 minutes ago, king_queen said:

She just released a bad a single…something ALL of our faves are guilty of ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ 

caution was outstanding and this song eats

 

you're wrong!

 

26 minutes ago, TaylorsSquad said:

Yes she lost her touch with this AI generated song Type Dangerous.

music video? sure its a mess and we blame Kahn

 

song? no way

as a non-stan, i don't get why little moos hate Type Dangerous so much... it sounds like a typical Mariah song to me 

30 minutes ago, Supernatural94 said:

I wanted to love the song but it's unlistenable. 
 

she's great at songs like touch my body and obsessed. I think that's the direction she should've followed. She's still a big legend and can still get a big hit. Obviously she had a very traumatic experience losing her mom and sister the same day that's rough and it would impact anyone no matter how strong they are.

 

she definitely can still get a hit she has the personality to go viral.

On the hot 100 ? No, she can't. 

Ya'll are pressed.   The queen stays queen.

Caution is her third best album and made multiple year end lists and was released 28 years into her career. 
 

Dangerous isn't great but neither was With You so I have hope that she'll deliver with the album.

 

I think Type Dangerous is such a bop idg why everyone hates it

Yes this song is a massive disappointment bigger than the mess that was I Don't and GTFO. Songs like Portrait and 8th Grade prove she's out of touch

 

 

We got this a year ago too, this is an unshakeable musical foundation and talent  

She's AI now and it's so obvious..

I don't think it's her fault, she's genuinely talented. This, to me, seems more like the label trying to get a viral moment.