Robyn.

I feel so sorry for people who still don't get I Luv It… It's such a banger

Nicki Minaj is a whole act... you know? She isn't oustreaming daily Rihanna, Taylor, Lana Del Rey, Lady Gaga, etc. and many more acts.

Gaga stans celebrating outdoing a 67 year old woman with +40 years of career to her credit… Why are you guys always targeting the weakest links? It's never the current pop girls that are smashing y'all going against. I wonder why.

Because someone who was that huge is not supposed to be frozen in the 90s-00s? It's natural for artists of her caliber to transcend generations.

+1 post Thank you

No offense but Xtina, Shania, Kelly Clarkson, Janet... are flops on streaming... so it's not saying much. Mariah's career sales are above ALL OF THESE girls you named... So naturally she should generate more interest among streaming audiences...

I am more shocked at the fact that her sales were THAT consistent, yet her streams are... fragile... Why does nobody care?

Why are you copying my thread? Let's stream the original, not the sample

I'm not one to defend miss Gaga, but Swine, Aura & ARTPOP (even Dope) were more daring tracks, than whatever is on Petal?

it's bland, generic and doesn't go nowhere. From someone who released Good For You, Bad Liar & Fetish... it felt very flat. She's just lost interest. Let her be an actress.

No because at least ARTPOP was the last time Gaga was actually authentic and true to herself... It was the last time she was actually being bold and experimenting, regardless of public reception. Petal is just another slow album from Ariana, with her toning down her voice for some reason when she has always given us vocal moments. She has become just uninspired and boring... ARTPOP was at least fun, in some way.

If she wants to drop her album, she needs to go independent... Otherwise, she's just another pretty girl who can sing and make music. The music market is oversaturated with those... If she doesn't have a great branding/something that sets her apart, she'll just fall flat.

I used to think this, until I realized Xtina's biggest career hits were manufacturated and written for her… This applies to many pop stars, their most successful songs were given to them. Y'all be giving credit for writing, but it be albums cuts no one cares about…

You named more SOLO hits that you could name for your fave, regardless of longevity… That's already saying something

Meh, he gives me fuckboy vibes. Bookmark if this don't last

Not me getting back in here and seeing this thread reached 5 pages This being my 4th hit thread in the past weeks. Thank you Monsters

You should spend that time answering the question of… The thread…

I have 8 albums to listen to... Gaga has less albums, less singles, less music videos, etc.

Does it hurt?

They've been combining both albums since the end of time but when we point out declines, they want to separate both albums

In most chart recaps, they are merged into one... so...

So if little monsters agree they're a joint album, why are we mad... solely, on this context?

LMFAOOOOOOOOOOOOO.... Y'all consider it 2 different albums when it's convenient... Mind you The Fame/The Fame Monster does not sound like 2 different eras...

can't wait for your Britney stan accusations

Britney had 4 albums over +10 million units Gaga had 3 albums over +10 million units