https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/justin-bieber-swag/?utm_source=instagram&utm_medium=social&utm_content=instagram-bio-link&client_service_id=31190&client_service_name=pitchfork&service_user_id=1.78e+16&supported_service_name=instagram_publishing&utm_brand=p4k&utm_social_type=owned

Congrats to justine

I listened to 10 seconds of the first track and already know this is a lie

a JOKE

More like 3.7

Them actually taking a stand on an opinion (in either direction), color me shocked. I personally didn't care for the album at all tho 

after ice spice getting 7.6 everything is possible

Better than HMHAS according to them, which says a lot.

I don't agree with 7.3, but I don't think it's a very bad album. 6.0-6.5 sounds more reasonable

that's surprising to say the least. but congrats! i listened to it in full yesterday and i would give it a 6/6,5. It's better in full than separate tracks like i did Friday. 

still, surprising score from them! 

 

Edited July 16, 20251 yr by Selegend

It's still **** Pitchfork and all the other critics btw

 

but thanks I guess!

Deserved 8 but well done Justin  

I enter the critic's page on Pitchfork and the last review she did was Justin's Justice and she gave it a 7.2

Definitely a belieber and definitely unprofessional but that is pitchfork nowadays. Pop reviews are generally done by fans of the artist

40 minutes ago, Johnny Jacobs said:

after ice spice getting 7.6 everything is possible

right, way too low 

Pitchfork is no longer the magazine we fell in love with... (and it's been like this for quite some time now)

Edited July 16, 20251 yr by bielneira

A little higher than I would expect but, it makes sense. The album is pretty great, the production is fantastic, the lyrics are serviceable, and the risks play off. The Druski interlude and Sexxy Red verse are the only thing wrong with the album.

24 minutes ago, Digitalism said:

I enter the critic's page on Pitchfork and the last review she did was Justin's Justice and she gave it a 7.2

Definitely a belieber and definitely unprofessional but that is pitchfork nowadays. Pop reviews are generally done by fans of the artist

Pitchfork reviews are written by 1 person, but the score is the average of several people at the office.  This is why sometimes the score doesn't reflect the review.

Edited July 16, 20251 yr by Kavish

I enjoyed the album. I think it's his best by far. So I agree with them. 

1 hour ago, Johnny Jacobs said:

after ice spice getting 7.6 everything is possible

No way! Was the reviewer on coke? 

Well deserved 

52 minutes ago, Digitalism said:

I enter the critic's page on Pitchfork and the last review she did was Justin's Justice and she gave it a 7.2

Definitely a belieber and definitely unprofessional but that is pitchfork nowadays. Pop reviews are generally done by fans of the artist

then Katy Perry and J-Lo definitely have the worst fans

57 minutes ago, Digitalism said:

I enter the critic's page on Pitchfork and the last review she did was Justin's Justice and she gave it a 7.2

Definitely a belieber and definitely unprofessional but that is pitchfork nowadays. Pop reviews are generally done by fans of the artist

Her last review was Justice???? Nah insane 

Serving this: 

https://forbes.com.br/autores/?nome= Jemima McEvoy
Article attacking selena and another praising Hailey back to back 

Edited July 16, 20251 yr by Selegend

Do people actually read these articles? Pitchfork always has the worst takes lmao. And they write like an edgy Tumblr user from 2014.

It must be their yearly troll review, like that last Ice Spice album.