AMERIICAN REQUIEM vs Disease

BLACKBIIRD vs Abracadabra

16 CARRIAGES vs Garden of Eden

PROTECTOR vs Perfect Celebrity

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs Vanish Into You

BODYGUARD vs Killah

JOLENE vs Zombieboy

DAUGHTER vs LoveDrug

SPAGHETTII How Bad Do U Want Me

ALLIIGATOR TEARS vs Don't Call Tonight

JUST FOR FUN vs Shadow of a Man

II MOST WANTED vs The Beast

LEVII'S JEANS vs Blade of Grass

FLAMENCO vs Die with a Smile

the one w more streams  

Cowboy Carter and Mayhem are my favorite albums from both of them, but Cowboy Carter aligns more with the kind of music I mostly listen to anyway and I adore the album.

I fear I have already stopped listening to Mayhem as much (except Disease, Abracadabra and Vanish Into You) but I usually spin Cowboy Carter a couple times a week.

 

AMERIICAN REQUIEM vs Disease

BLACKBIIRD vs Abracadabra

16 CARRIAGES vs Garden of Eden

PROTECTOR vs Perfect Celebrity

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs Vanish Into You

BODYGUARD vs Killah

JOLENE vs Zombieboy

DAUGHTER vs LoveDrug

SPAGHETTII How Bad Do U Want Me

ALLIIGATOR TEARS vs Don't Call Tonight

JUST FOR FUN vs Shadow of a Man

II MOST WANTED vs The Beast

LEVII'S JEANS vs Blade of Grass

FLAMENCO vs Die with a Smile

 

Voted for Cowboy Carter for overall and cover.

Voted for Mayhem for singles.

 

Edited July 7, 20251 yr by Clearblue

AMERIICAN REQUIEM vs Disease

BLACKBIIRD vs Abracadabra

16 CARRIAGES vs Garden of Eden

PROTECTOR vs Perfect Celebrity

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs Vanish Into You

BODYGUARD vs Killah

JOLENE vs Zombieboy

DAUGHTER vs LoveDrug

SPAGHETTII vs How Bad Do U Want Me

ALLIIGATOR TEARS vs Don't Call Tonight

JUST FOR FUN vs Shadow of a Man

II MOST WANTED vs The Beast

LEVII'S JEANS vs Blade of Grass

FLAMENCO vs Die with a Smile

 

10 vs 4

 

FLAMENCO would've won against every single song here, CC included.

4 minutes ago, fossora said:

the one w more streams  

not the first post fdsghff

Spaghetti alone clears 

The one I've listened to 

I prefer MAYHEM and its singles but that Cowboy Carter artwork is a serve and a half! 

The post chorus of Abracadabra alone clears all of CC

 

AMERIICAN REQUIEM vs Disease

BLACKBIIRD vs Abracadabra

16 CARRIAGES vs Garden of Eden

PROTECTOR vs Perfect Celebrity

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs Vanish Into You

BODYGUARD vs Killah

JOLENE vs Zombieboy

DAUGHTER vs LoveDrug

SPAGHETTII How Bad Do U Want Me

ALLIIGATOR TEARS vs Don't Call Tonight

JUST FOR FUN vs Shadow of a Man

II MOST WANTED vs The Beast

LEVII'S JEANS vs Blade of Grass

FLAMENCO vs Die with a Smile

AMERIICAN REQUIEM vs Disease

BLACKBIIRD vs Abracadabra

16 CARRIAGES vs Garden of Eden

PROTECTOR vs Perfect Celebrity

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs Vanish Into You

BODYGUARD vs Killah

JOLENE vs Zombieboy

DAUGHTER vs LoveDrug

SPAGHETTII How Bad Do U Want Me

ALLIIGATOR TEARS vs Don't Call Tonight

JUST FOR FUN vs Shadow of a Man

II MOST WANTED vs The Beast

LEVII'S JEANS vs Blade of Grass

FLAMENCO vs Die with a Smile

 

Mayhem sucks

Cowboy Carter

 

It also wins all the track-by-track matchups except Jolene vs. Zombieboy for me

 

for all 

 

well actually gaga can have the singles, she chose better ones and at least performed and promoted them. i don't care that much about TH'E and II Least Wanted is a snooze (and is hardly an actual single ). 16C alone clears anything on mayhem tho >>>>

 

AMERIICAN REQUIEM vs Disease

BLACKBIIRD vs Abracadabra

16 CARRIAGES vs Garden of Eden

PROTECTOR vs Perfect Celebrity

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs Vanish Into You

BODYGUARD vs Killah

JOLENE vs Zombieboy

DAUGHTER vs LoveDrug

SPAGHETTII How Bad Do U Want Me

ALLIIGATOR TEARS vs Don't Call Tonight

JUST FOR FUN vs Shadow of a Man

II MOST WANTED vs The Beast

LEVII'S JEANS vs Blade of Grass

FLAMENCO vs Die with a Smile

Edited July 7, 20251 yr by ScorpiosGroove

Has anyone even listened to Cowboy Carter in full?

Edited July 7, 20251 yr by DaphneGuinness

6 minutes ago, frankvert said:

The post chorus of Abracadabra alone clears all of CC

 

The intro to American Requiem alone clears all of Mayhem.

5 minutes ago, frankvert said:

The post chorus of Abracadabra alone clears all of CC

 

False.

 

"Bodyguard" eats both albums up and leaves no crumbs.

 

5 minutes ago, Slamless said:

Mayhem sucks

 

Mayhem, minus album cover.

21 minutes ago, right where you left me said:

 

AMERIICAN REQUIEM vs Disease

BLACKBIIRD vs Abracadabra

16 CARRIAGES vs Garden of Eden

PROTECTOR vs Perfect Celebrity

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs Vanish Into You

BODYGUARD vs Killah

JOLENE vs Zombieboy

DAUGHTER vs LoveDrug

SPAGHETTII How Bad Do U Want Me

ALLIIGATOR TEARS vs Don't Call Tonight

JUST FOR FUN vs Shadow of a Man

II MOST WANTED vs The Beast

LEVII'S JEANS vs Blade of Grass

FLAMENCO vs Die with a Smile

6/8

 

My most played 2024 album vs my most played 2025 album

The album where the label didn't cheaply tack on a song that wasn't supposed to be on it 

8 minutes ago, DaphneGuinness said:

Has anyone even listened to Cowboy Carter in full? 

well yes! the album is still charting over a year later and the entire recording academy that has over 13000 members listened to the album in full and decided it was the BEST ALBUM OF THE YEAR 

Mayhem.

Disease alone clears all of CC btw

AMERIICAN REQUIEM vs Disease

BLACKBIIRD vs Abracadabra

16 CARRIAGES vs Garden of Eden

PROTECTOR vs Perfect Celebrity

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs Vanish Into You

BODYGUARD vs Killah

JOLENE vs Zombieboy

DAUGHTER vs LoveDrug

SPAGHETTII How Bad Do U Want Me

ALLIIGATOR TEARS vs Don't Call Tonight

JUST FOR FUN vs Shadow of a Man

II MOST WANTED vs The Beast

LEVII'S JEANS vs Blade of Grass

FLAMENCO vs Die with a Smile

 

If Blackbird was original it would stan a chance against Abra, THE vs VIY was hard, and LJ vs BOG the mid off

 

I choose Mayhem because the highs to me are higher, but CC is one of Beyonces best albums

Edited July 7, 20251 yr by TedLasso