Which 2000s Hot 100 female #1 banger produced by Timbaland do you prefer?

 

 

 

 

Nelly's best song wins. Aaliyah has better songs in her discog.

Controversial opinion but I think Aaliyah is overrated. She's only considered one of the greats cos she died. Nelly is the goat 

56 minutes ago, Contessa said:

Nelly's best song wins. Aaliyah has better songs in her discog.

honestly Try again is her best to me and still sounds futuristic compared to other Timbo beats which feel more time capsule-y today. THAT'S MY OPINION!!!

41 minutes ago, Asparagus Spears said:

Controversial opinion but I think Aaliyah is overrated. She's only considered one of the greats cos she died.

this has to be one of the worst takes ever

1 hour ago, Asparagus Spears said:

Controversial opinion but I think Aaliyah is overrated. She's only considered one of the greats cos she died

The audacity with who you have in your avatar. 

Damn that was a hard vote because both songs are classics. I chose promiscuous but Try again is that song. You can't help but sing along to both when they come on

it's been a long time…

Promiscuous really is that song 

 

 

 

but Try Again IS my favourite Aaliyah song

7 hours ago, Asparagus Spears said:

Controversial opinion but I think Aaliyah is overrated. She's only considered one of the greats cos she died. Nelly is the goat 

There's a thick line between controversial and stupid. You fell behind the latter with your opinion. 

 

 

 

 

Edited April 29, 20251 yr by Mickie

7 hours ago, Asparagus Spears said:

Controversial opinion but I think Aaliyah is overrated. She's only considered one of the greats cos she died. Nelly is the goat 

You literally could of just answered the actual question without being unnecessarily disrespectful. 

 

-

 

I've always preferred ''Promiscuous'', which is a masterpiece in my opinion but Aaliyah has much better Timbaland produced tracks 

Promiscuous but I personally don't think that either song is a discography highlight 

I personally couldn't be able to pick one out of these two. They're both so good

Promiscuous is an awful song. Try Again absolutely, and not it's even a little close.

Promiscuous

9 hours ago, Asparagus Spears said:

Controversial opinion but I think Aaliyah is overrated. She's only considered one of the greats cos she died. Nelly is the goat 

so true and so brave

both songs are good but i prefer promiscuous 

I never liked Promiscuous like that, sorry.

Try Again is that girl all day every day.

try again. promiscuous is mad overrated to me lol.

Loved "Promiscuous" in 2006, love "Promiscuous" to this day. It's just such an excellently crafted pop song, infectious production and seductive and playful lyrics. It's just THAT classic.

 

"Try Again" a classic as well.