I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

 

 

Lover would be better if the album was shorter

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on the Beach

The Archer vs You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question...?

Paper Rings vs Vigilante Sh*t

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Glitch

All of the Girls You Loved Before vs Would've, Could've, Should've

 

Lover: 8; Midnights: 11

 

Both could do with huge amounts of trimming, but Midnights sweetie... as a whole and as an era.

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Midnights; 12

Lover; 6

Edited February 17, 20251 yr by KatyPrismSpirit

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Lover 13

Midnights 5

Midnights >>

The AOTY for all

Better album - Midnights

Better singles - Lover

 

Lavender Haze > Cruel Summer > The Man > Lover > Anti Hero > You Need To Calm Down > ME! > Karma (remix)

 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

None for Lover

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Lover: 6

Midnights: 12

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

Midnights.

3 hours ago, Feanor said:

 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Lover 13

Midnights 5

Are you Nicki Minaj? 

Oh Midnights. The AOTY winner. I still cannot forget the moment I heard Maroon for the first time. That song alone makes Midnights a classic although Cruel Summer is definitely up there. 

Lover rly is bottom of the barrel

 

there alongside TTPD (for me at least) ((I wonder if it's the same for others)

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

Midnights: 10

Lover: 8

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Lover 4 | Midnights 14

I adore Midnights but Lover is stronger for me. I won't do track vs track but will put songs I love form each album.

 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon - THIS IS HARD. It's a tie.

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky - This is so hard too, I'm the biggest BTTWS fan, but AG is great too. Another tie!

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

10 vs 10, wow it's a tie. BUT with WCS, Hits Different and You're Losing Me, Midnights edges a bit. I actually thought Lover would win. I guess if it's not track vs track, I would still prefer Lover because of how strong the album tracks are (Cornelia, DBATC, False God, Paper Rings, Daylight, Afterglow >>>>>)

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Lover: 8

Midnights: 10

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Glitch

All of the Girls… vs Would've Could've Should've

Beautiful Ghosts vs Dear Reader

Christmas Tree Farm vs Hits Different

 

Lover: 5

Midnights: 16

 

Midnights >>>

Her best pop album 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

11 / 8 

Unpopular opinion: Lover for all