G.U.Y is pop perfection and one of the most undeserved flops of all time.

ARTPOP walked so MAYHEM could run!

Abra song, GUY video

Abra for both 

love GUY tho

abra for both, guy is just ok 

G.U.Y. for both as it's been my favourite song of hers for years

 

But I totally get the people who pick Abra, especially the song, because it's just excellence, clean af and an anthem!

GUY is great but Abra really pulls ahead with that bridge. I also slightly prefer the Abra video too. 

Abracadabra for both

GUY intro alone >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

GUY aged for me sadly, and Abra has that godly bridge

she somehow looks younger in Abracadabra's MV than G.U.Y.'s 

 

17 minutes ago, Rino said:

she somehow looks younger in Abracadabra's MV than G.U.Y.'s 

She's uses face tape now. This is known. 

GUY has the housewives in it so it wins 

Sorry Abra but it's GUY for both, one of my favorite Gaga songs. 

I'll give G.U.Y. that is more innovative compared to Abra. But Abra is just perfect. G.U.Y. had no business having that long ass intro.

I think i love both equally

Abra is perfection. GUY is bottom 5 on Artpop and I'm not gonna discuss that with anyone. 

GUY's music video was so over-the-top  I hope she taps into that energy again one day 

 

 

ICONIC 

Edited February 13, 20251 yr by Reginald

GUY for both.

ARTPOP was such a Hot B**tch era, ugh 

Abra is more polished so that one for both. GUY will always have a special place in my heart though, the video was definitely a labour of love for the fans

Edited February 13, 20251 yr by Dolce Vita

Gonna say Abra for both maybe just because of recency effect and just how clean and concise it is. Not an ounce of fat on the song or video.

 

I love G.U.Y. though and I think one area where it has Abra beat is just having more musical variation. The intro, verse, pre-chorus, chorus and bridge all have their own unique chord progressions, while Abra is the same four chords the whole way through (minus the upward glissando part during the post chorus and first half of verse which kinda just drones on the tonic). However, I think Abra compensates by just having every single melody be total fire, whereas G.U.Y. doesn't quite have as interesting melodies, and its bridge melody is a blatant recycle of the Bad Romance chorus. 

Abra is better in every way and ARTPOP is a horrible album. Fight me.

 

 

Edited February 13, 20251 yr by nadiamendell

i voted Abra for both but it's very close

 

i've said elsewhere that Abracadabra is her best video since G.U.Y. and I stand by it, it deserves VMAs recognition