I did not like it at all but that is no reason for me so say it is overrated.

I used to think so, but then I revisited it, and it was kinda hitting.

 

Yes

No

 

however it's time to acknowledge I think about it all the time is the most unlistenable thing released this year

No. You're just Covid positive 

47 minutes ago, Josh said:

How? One would think this was the second coming of Thriller the way this site praises it

Well I wasnt just talking about this site. ATRLers also praise everything else when an artist does it from hairstyles to viral tweets. In reality while BRAT Is a critical success its still very unknown to the GP. Which is why I said it was underrated.

in stan culture yes, outside of it no one cares about it

1 hour ago, Lagerfeld said:

That title goes to Taylor Swift's The Tortured Poets Department.

 

 

Beyond overrated. So, so sick of hearing this word and esp seeing the Brat Weirdos out at clubs

A little bit. The lyrics and subject matter deserve all of the praise it's getting though! 

 

Not really, if anything the music deserves more mainstream exposure. 

I think it's underrated tbh 

At first, I didn't really like the album, but now it's hitting. It's a good album. It's overrated a little bit, but still good. Some of the songs there are just bad BAD, while others are amazing and super smart. 

No.

and Guess is SOTY

it has some fun moment, but aoty is a reach.

 

1 hour ago, Kuntmonster said:

Fine it's a tie between brat, TTPD, deeper well 

 

Well cut it 

 

OT: no.

not at all + the way it's making swifties suffer only adds more flavor to it

3 minutes ago, Mark Rih said:

not at all + the way it's making swifties suffer only adds more flavor to it

How is this bothering Swifties in any way?

 

 

No cuz 95% of the world population has not heard it

Absolutely not!

In what sense? It's a pretty daring, fun, serious, and brashly honest album with uniquely stellar production so it makes sense critics love it.

 

Then you have triumphant pop songs that create escapism and a perfect aesthetic that make people love it. It's a perfect modern pop album. I don't see what's confusing about this.

 

It's a great record but it's classic Charli so nothing new to the table and the era feels unauthentic 

Edited July 24, 20242 yr by campelo

3 hours ago, Lagerfeld said:

That title goes to Taylor Swift's The Tortured Poets Department.

 

 

Lmfao

1 hour ago, Mark Rih said:

not at all + the way it's making swifties suffer only adds more flavor to it

Taylor has been glued to #1 for like 12 weeks. I feel they will be okay lmao.

No, it's an amazing album and a culmination of Charli's career. It deserves all the praise it's getting.