Better first 2 singles

 

Mariah: 
Vision of love

Love takes time

 

JLo:

If you had my love

Waiting for tonight

 

Edited March 17, 20242 yr by HardBambi

Love takes time>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

JLo serves bops at least, Mariah's music pre-Butterfly is boring and schmaltzy

Waiting for Tonight >>>

If You Had My Love is an A and Waiting For Tonight is an A+ so JLo clears

 

its Mariah like cmon now.

Mariah ofc  

Both are amazing but choosing Mariah

No matter what … JLove takes this easily and whoever votes Mimi has a constitutional right to be deluded

This is actually really hard… both were serving quality 

The non-covers. 

I have to go with J-Lo

JLO

Mariah's first two singles are  among her best so her.

Vision of Love clears all.

JLo clears

JLO. 

If You Had My Love & Una Noche Más 

I like those Mariah songs but she has better ones so even tho I usually prefer Mariah I voted for Jlo bcs those are my fav Jlo songs.

I'm partial to Waiting For Tonight as that's my favorite thing JLo has ever done whereas Mariah has had better offerings down the line. So JLo it is! 

Vision of Love sweetie

for me 99% of the time it's Mariah > JLo

 

But let's be real 1990 =/= 1999

WFT is perfection timeless 

JLo easily

Mariah's discography is a lot better than J.Lo's but If You Had My Love clears all singles from Mariah's debut.