Both songs were released today in 1995 and 1999.

 

But which one do you prefer?

 

 

 

Fantasy.

 

But I most admit. I've been hearing Heartbreaker a lot more recently and it's starting to grow back!

 

Edited August 23, 20233 yr by jdmc219

Fantasy f/ ODB > Heartbreaker > Fantasy

For me Heartbreaker 

fantasy definitely. it's such a timeless classic and it never gets old. heartbreaker is great too and i do hear it quite frequently but it did kind of replicate the fantasy formula. fantasy also used sampling more creatively

Fantasy is the correct answer.

 

There's just something so captivating about "Heartbreaker" that I can't put my finger on

 

 

 

 

I like Heartbreaker's chorus and song structure more, but overall Fantasy is just better. 

 

Loverboy might be better than both of them, tho.

Before, I would've chosen Fantasy

it's such a classic song and sound...

 

I couldn't really get into Heartbreaker for some time, even thought it was overrated

but now, I found God

Fantasy is so beyond unbothered by a Heartbreaker.

1 hour ago, Virgos Groove said:

Fantasy f/ ODB > Heartbreaker > Fantasy

Came here to post this 

Heartbreaker 100% 

Both are 10s

I loooove both. I think both are in my top 5 Mariah songs... but I'm going with Heartbreaker here. 

Fantasy was one of my favorite songs of all time but in the last few years Heartbreaker has crept above it. It’s just a bit “edgier” than Fantasy for me and the on again off again story is more relatable to me. Plus Jay D’s verse and the “gimme your love” really elevate the song

Fantasy outsold 

Fantasy by far

Fantasy remains the better song, but I find myself listening to Heartbreaker a lot more these days though.

Fantasy Remix > Heartbreaker > Fantasy 

Heartbreaker remix > Heartbreaker >= Fantasy > Fantasy remix

 

i listen to heartbreaker more but fantasy is just legendary so idk, both are masterpieces