Mariah for all. People who say otherwise are either delusional or weren't alive in 2008. 

Renaissance by default. E=MC2 is one of Mariah’s worst projects.

Touch My Body was a legit HIT. These Beyonce songs don’t compare. 

touch my body is a bigger hit than any REN single, but the REN singles are bigger than E=MC2 singles overall

 

also REN clearly the bigger and more global album, beyonce bigger starpower and celebrity status

 

people who say otherwise are either delusional or weren't alive in 2008

Beyonce 

 

RENAISSANCE is bigger (facts)

B bigger everything 

But if you would have asked which one is better E=MC2 would have won by far

Renaissance

 

Touch My Body/Bye Bye

 

Beyoncé

 

Touch My Body was SUCH a moment. Literally one of my all time favorite songs and videos to this day. 

4 hours ago, johnny_9ss said:

Mariah for all. People who say otherwise are either delusional or weren't alive in 2008. 

I lived and loved the era but it wasn’t that big. BMS going number 1 and especially Cuff it going viral + the tour + the acclaim makes RENAISSANCE win by far. 
 

TMB was number 1 in America, while 4 Minutes was top 3 only, but in the end 4 minutes ended up a bigger hit

 

Bye bye, the second single flopped, I thought it was a cringe & terrible single choice (the theme of the sing is great for an album track but if you’re trying to milk that theme for the charts it’s a no no)

 

II’ll be loving u flooped completely 

 

I stay in love flopped completely 

 

Of course not releasing Migrate was a massive mistake #timelesstune

 

Beyonce for all and I say this as a Lamb

 

Touch My Body was HUGE.

Beyoncé clears in performance, but as an album I prefer E=MC².

6 hours ago, GraceRandolph said:

Touch My Body was a legit HIT. These Beyonce songs don’t compare. 

Depends where you’re from I guess. 
 

UK

 

#5 TMB (3 weeks in top 10)

#30 Bye Bye 

#3 E=MC2 (13 weeks) 

 

 

 

9 hours ago, VioletsandRoses said:

Neither smashed outside the US

This is categorically false.