ATRL decides…

For starters some of these sneaks aren’t legends. 

1 minute ago, Devin said:

For starters some of these sneaks aren’t legends. 

Who is a sneak? I tried to be objective.

hildegard von bingen

a certain child prodigy, singer, songwriter, pianist, arranger, dancer, poet would like a word

(love all of em though!)

Just now, JoeAg said:

a certain child prodigy, singer, songwriter, pianist, arranger, dancer, poet would like a word

I just don’t know if she’s an undeniable legend (yet) but she’s definitely talented. 

Not the Legend X erasure. 

 

 

Madonna, Aretha, Judy, Beyoncé, Taylor & Whitney. Honorable Mention to Mary J. Blige! 

Just now, toxicgenie said:

Not the Legend X erasure. 

 

 

She’s at icon status. 

Feel like people will be mad about my answer for least talented so I won't say anything 

Most talented: Mariah, since she has the singing, songwriting, production, etc.

 

Least: Diana Ross. Her voice is okay, and she has a dreamy tone whose appeal I can see, but the voice is not that good, and the songwriting and creativity are nonexistent. She's still a legend and an icon, but she's truly Bad Gyal Die-Die in that she's a beauty fashionista that gets passes for being a mediocre artist all around.

Stevie Nicks and Aretha having 0 votes in most talented. ATRL do better. 

Most talented: Barbra Streisand, Beyoncé, Mariah Carey, Stevie Nicks and Tina Turner

 

Least talented: Taylor Swift

24 minutes ago, Devin said:

For starters some of these sneaks aren’t legends. 

 

The very obvious sneak   

1 minute ago, Sept said:

The very obvious sneak   

Wait, who's being snuck on there?

From here the most is Barbra, the least is Taylor.

The Gaga sneak  you tried it

 

OT: asides from the obvious sneak, they’re all talented hence why they are legends 

1 minute ago, Frogger17 said:

Wait, who's being snuck on there?

I think they’re pressed at Queen Judy. 

Just now, GraceRandolph said:

I think they’re pressed at Queen Judy. 

Judy Garland was thee girl before a lot of these girls on the list were even born and paved the way for many of them, so if she's not, they aren't either.

19 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said:

She’s at icon status. 

She's both. Shakira and Jlo are also missing. I sense a pattern of Latinidad erasure. 

Just now, toxicgenie said:

She's both. Shakira and Jlo are also missing. I sense a pattern of Latinidad erasure. 

I probably should’ve included Shakira. JLo and Xtina aren’t legendary, they are celebs and icons. 

1 minute ago, toxicgenie said:

She's both. Shakira and Jlo are also missing. I sense a pattern of Latinidad erasure. 

I would give it to Selena Quintinilla before J-Lo, tbh 

1 minute ago, Frogger17 said:

I would give it to Selena Quintinilla before J-Lo, tbh 

Anything for Selenas.l I said Jlo because I know the Gaga Stan @Gracewhatever is counting ASIB for their fave to get legend status, so Jlo's movies would also make her legend status.