Midnights 3AM > Lover > Midnights

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Lover: 12

Midnights: 6

 

Lover wins

Midnights is more consistent but Lover has higher highs.

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

6 (Lover) x 13 (Midnights)

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind 

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

9/9

 

Makes sense to be honest, both albums have very high highs but also very low lows. It's hard for me to choose between them because Lover has more tracks that I really love, but Midnights as an albums feels more cohesive.

lover has higher highs and lower lows

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante **** (both are bottom of the barrel) 

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

All for midnights

Midnights is way better

 

What I’m really shocked is the amount of people that places Maroon over Cruel Summer tho .

 

Cruel Summer is one of the best tracks in her discography even in that horrible album and Maroon is by far one of the worst in Midnights.

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth  

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky (i love both those songs so i can’t choose)

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs Hits Different

Daylight vs Dear Reader (i can’t choose, both are incredible)

Only The Young (it’s a Lover reject) vs Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve 

Edited December 29, 20223 yr by TayDuaStan

Lover because it at least has some great songs while all midnight tracks are just mid

People picking YNTCD over TGW

 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Mid 10-8

Lover is way better, i'll never get the hype that Midnights gets. 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth  

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

9 - 9  Overall I prefer Lover because it has higher highs.

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

It’s like choosing between gonorrhea and syphilis 
But answering question, for me Midnights 3AM part is best.

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

6 vs 12

Lover by far. It had weak singles but the overall album is decent. Half of Midnights is a tuneless mess and the other half sounds decent but like the fillers/good album tracks from… Lover

 

So yeah that’s easy for me

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader