I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

There is really no competition here, even when the best song on Midnights (WCS) is excluded. Midnights ranks as Taylor's best pop album while Lover is her worst. Cruel Summer was done dirty being against Maroon though because it would have won against any other standard tracks on Midnights. 

Edited December 29, 20223 yr by Klein

 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

9 - 9
only her two best pop albums 

3 minutes ago, Michael196 said:

 Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

 

7 vs 11

 

Midnights WINS!

Midnights and it's not close

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question...?

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

 

6 vs 12. Not even close.

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Lover - 11

Midnights - 6

 

Lover is just not a very well put together record and it has a lot of filler. It does contain some of her best songs however. A bit of trimming a re-arranging of the tracklist would've made for a great pop record. There's like 8-9 songs on it that are better than anything on Midnights (sans WCS). 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth (both suck) 

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

ME! Winning for once.

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're on Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & the Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than the Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

8 vs 9

MIDnights wins this mid-off by a hair

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

 

I prefer Midnights overall though, even if Lover is winning

38 minutes ago, Taeyong said:

Midnights and it's not close

 

36 minutes ago, Taeyong said:

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question...?

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

I won’t even count this because it isn’t even fair.  Midnights is the more rounded work of art as a whole, but Lover remains her most underrated work. The matchups aren’t quite fair; Lover is an 18 song album with three bad songs, and Midnights is a 22 album song with two. They’re even as far as I’m concerned. 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on the Beach

The Archer vs You're on Your Own, Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & the Heartbreak Prince vs Question…?

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by a Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need to Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger than the Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice to Have a Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infidelity

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Lover 8 and Midnights 10 - Im kinda surprised cuz Midnights hasn't hit me yet like most Taylor albums do but I do enjoy it.

5 minutes ago, Michael196 said:

 

Help 

As an album, Midnights is better. These track by track comparisons are fun but aren't a representation of how I actually feel about the actual album

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

Lover 9 - 7 Midnights

 

Midnights but I enjoy Lover and if it's lows were cut it would be an amazing pop album
 

 

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

Lover > 

 

I’m not even a huge fan of Lover, but this shouldn’t even be a debate.

Midnights sweetie get behind me 

The one with Cruel Summer, Paper Rings and Death by a Thousand Cuts. (Career Highlights)

Midnights only have Hits Different

Edited December 29, 20223 yr by Reiner Braun

Midnights is better! Lover is bottom of the barrel of Taylor's discography.

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain (Both are weak)

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing  (Both are weak)

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky  (Really love both)

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader
 

7 vs 11

Hits Different and WCS are excellent... Glitch is very meh.

I Forgot That You Existed vs Lavender Haze

Cruel Summer vs Maroon

Lover vs Anti-Hero

The Man vs Snow on The Beach

The Archer vs You're On Your Own Kid

I Think He Knows vs Midnight Rain

Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince vs Question

Paper Rings vs Vigilante ****

Cornelia Street vs Bejeweled

Death by A Thousand Cuts vs Labyrinth

London Boy vs Karma

Soon You'll Get Better vs Sweet Nothing

False God vs Mastermind

You Need To Calm Down vs The Great War

Afterglow vs Bigger Than The Whole Sky

ME! vs Paris

It's Nice To Have A Friend vs High Infedility

Daylight vs Dear Reader

 

It's basically a tie for me but neither is up to Taylor's standards