A joke

asib is miles better 

Imagine thing Traumatica is as good as ARTPOP

ARTPOP is better than Chromatica. 

Chromatica is her best album and ARTPOP is her worst. 

we love it for her

The way they dont even want to give any of her album over 8. Pretentious mess they are.

Joanne with the lowest score just like it deserves. 

 

I think Chromatica is better than Artpop and I'd probably put artpop at like a 7 but it's nice that we are past trashing it. Born This Way and TFM deserve above 8 though. Her best work. 

Dead aunt confirmed WORST Gaga album 

59 minutes ago, Sombre said:

Excuse me? Artpop is not as good as Chromatica (though IMO Chromatica does deserve a score in the 8's).  Slay at BTW being at 7.9 though. 

??? I think ARTPOP is milesssss above Chromatica. The lyrics on Chromatica are very surface-level imo, some of her worst. 

if artpop could be 7.3 then chromatica would be a 8.3  

Her music remains a bit underrated by critics, but I’m glad that the poptimism that was ushered in in part by the success of The Fame Monster is finally benefiting Gaga herself. 

4 minutes ago, CottageHore said:

??? I think ARTPOP is milesssss above Chromatica. The lyrics on Chromatica are very surface-level imo, some of her worst. 

in what world are ROM, 911 and Replay surface-level? 

They heard the greatness of Venus and ARTPOP. 

ARTPOP always wins 

My ARTPOP's trinity

 

10 minutes ago, Mikeymoonshine said:

Joanne with the lowest score just like it deserves. 

mte 

 

I think it’s ok. In 2013-2014 I really enjoyed this album but now it sounds a bit dated to me  maybe in the future I will think the same about Chromatica.

 

Of course, I still enjoy BTW and TFM like the first time. 

11 minutes ago, CottageHore said:

??? I think ARTPOP is milesssss above Chromatica. The lyrics on Chromatica are very surface-level imo, some of her worst. 

This early on Sunday you wanna sin and lie? The lyrics on both albums are surface level, but that's just how Gaga writes her music. She always explicitly says what she means, but there are some songs on Chroma where she's more vague than usual (ROM for instance where it could be interpreted in multiple ways).

 

Regardless, Chromatica overall (imo) is a much better album. It does have it's downs (like Plastic Doll and Fun Tonight), but nothing as putrid and revolting as Donatella.  Artpop feels very rushed, themeless and incoherent whereas Chroma is coherent and produced beautifully. 

GUY and RoM Gaga’s best dance songs? They on crack 

Also SCREAMING at "G.U.Y." being 'her best ever dance song' are they ******* high ?

Not that GUY praise. Review is a joke nowadays.

ATRL is really out of reality. ARTPOP is a masterpiece and y'all will deal. 

Yes artpop was underrated but not so underrated that it’s better than ASIB or Chromatica  Swine and jewels and drugs alone should knock it 4 points from 10 

A retrospective 7.3 for an album with an intentional R. Kelly feature, and a song title that’s a slur is wild. 

 

 

I will say, the things Artpop got right it really got right, and there are a few tracks I still regularly revisit, but there are a few too many missteps to redeem the album as a whole. 

That album literally has two listenable songs  tragic review

15 minutes ago, Sombre said:

This early on Sunday you wanna sin and lie? The lyrics on both albums are surface level, but that's just how Gaga writes her music. She always explicitly says what she means, but there are some songs on Chroma where she's more vague than usual (ROM for instance where it could be interpreted in multiple ways).

 

Regardless, Chromatica overall (imo) is a much better album. It does have it's downs (like Plastic Doll and Fun Tonight), but nothing as putrid and revolting as Donatella.  Artpop feels very rushed, themeless and incoherent whereas Chroma is coherent and produced beautifully. 

I would say there’s an esotericism (and eccentricity) to some parts of BTW and Artpop that are wholly absent from Chromatica. 
 

Like, the lead for Artpop has a reference to Jeff Koons - and I doubt most people who heard the song know who that is