Which of these 2018/2019 eras was bigger?

Hm, should we really compare them? One was really huge among the moms and another among the gay teens 

Shallow feels way bigger than the entire tun era tbh and I stan Ari 

Lol

ASIB
 

That era will be remembered and that’s all that matters 

Edited April 28, 20224 yr by Mercurio

What are their soundscan totals?

ASIB clearly.  

ASIB not only album or Shallow but also the movie was legendary success and going to be remembered forever. 

You compare without shame. TUN >>>> ASIB 

Compare their last albums & stop living in the past 

 

TUN outstreamed & she did it all solo so I say TUN!

No one had to carry Ariana on TUN so easily her album. 
Thank you, Next? 

ASIB

 

An acclaimed, successful and timeless era.

 

2 minutes ago, youkneekorn said:

No one had to carry Ariana on TUN so easily her album. 
Thank you, Next? 

Ofcourse, huge recording artist Bradley Cooper made ASIB huge

10 minutes ago, Mystic Boy said:

Ofcourse, huge recording artist Bradley Cooper made ASIB huge

Receipts prove that solo Gaga can’t be super successful post BTW (single) over a decade ago. 
 

If not for Ariana’s support on Rain On Me, the Chromatica era would have been a BOMB. Without Bradley Cooper and his movie it’s therefore not far fetched to assume the same fate awaited ASIB. 

Edited April 28, 20224 yr by youkneekorn

TUN, 7R and BWYGIB are solo hits.

AISB has Bradley and a woman growling in some songs.  It's not fair.

14 minutes ago, youkneekorn said:

Receipts prove that solo Gaga can’t be super successful post BTW (single) over a decade ago. 
 

If not for Ariana’s support on Rain On Me, the Chromatica era would have been a BOMB. Without Bradley Cooper and his movie it’s therefore not far fetched to assume the same fate awaited ASIB. 

In the meantime, these are her projects which she wrote and co produced and was highly acclaimed for and you ll keep SEETHING while she embarks on her sOLo stadium tour and you will keep lurking on your fave instagram while she keeps ridiculing and embarassing herself

 

We don't have the same standards sweetie, stay in your lane 

Edited April 28, 20224 yr by Mystic Boy

38 minutes ago, moonlitdick said:

Compare their last albums & stop living in the past 

 

TUN outstreamed & she did it all solo so I say TUN!

There was a 7 Rings remix so clearly not all solo 

People know TUN was an actual pop music era 

The GP only knows Shallow was in that movie 

TUN, it outstreamed, outacclaimed, had more hits, its recurrent stats are better, and it also outcharted and outdebuted ASIB

TUn considering wasn’t attached to a movie with hella promo

TUN. tun + 7 rings were an EVENT

tun won in the end

ASIB. A classique indeed  

Doesn anyone have the total WW SPS for both instead of throwing whatever they can to downplay Gaga phenomenal success with ASIB ? 

ASIB is nearing the 10M WW SPS, what about about TUN?

8 minutes ago, Mystic Boy said:

Doesn anyone have the total WW SPS for both instead of throwing whatever they can to downplay Gaga phenomenal success with ASIB ? 

ASIB is nearing the 10M WW SPS, what about about TUN?

Chartmasters:

 

A Star Is Born: 8,817,000 units (2,030 units yesterday)

Thank U, Next: 8,293,000 units (2,510 units yesterday)