Moonstar is several tiers above Jennie, Irene and Yeri ()

1 hour ago, Billionaire said:

Love them but GIDLE have absolutely nothing going for them other than a hit song 

What are they supposed to have going on?

I was wondering how is I-dle is going to manage their world tour, Yuqi is supposed to go back to China this summer for that one show she's in. 

 

oh no one even posted this  nothing redeemable about the song, they haven’t put out anything worthwhile in almost two years 

 

Gidle's can still score another hit if they play their cards right. If they fumble the bag (release a boring song), they would pull a Oh My Girl kind of underperformance/ floppage.

1 minute ago, K$Ellie said:

 

oh no one even posted this  nothing redeemable about the song, they haven’t put out anything worthwhile in almost two years 

 

The intro  it's always Mark doing something embarrassing like that 

now since Beatbox is out... aespa must be next right?

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

How would y'all rank Blackpink, Twice, Red Velvet and Mamamoo aka the top 4 biggest girl groups of 3rd gen vocally? 

Correct me if I'm wrong, but this is how the vocal ranking is objectively, from what I have observed:

 

*The God tier*

1. Wendy -  Shine on me let it shine on me 

2. Whee In - Sis is as good as Wendy, and was very close to snatch the number 1 spot 

3. Solar - She is the best at belting high notes, and is the 2nd prettiest idol ever after Chaeyoung, so she kinda won  

 

*The top tier*

4. Hwasa - 3 Mamamoo members snatching the top 4 spot 

5. Seulgi - I think Hwasa is a little better than her, but they are very close

 

*The good tier*

6. Joy - "Red Velvet" - Feel My Rhytmn, 2022 

7. Jihyo - If this was a subjective vocal ranking, then she would be last on this list 

8. Jeongyeon - JYP better give her more lines, cause she has the best vocal tone out of 3mix 

9. Nayeon - Her struggling high notes gives me life 

 

*The alright tier*

10. Rosé - "What you gonna do when I come come through with that that uh uh huh" 

11. Irene - Yes, she is a better vocalist than Jennie.

12. Yeri - She's an SM idol so she can't be too low either 

13. Jisoo (She has my favorite vocal tone out of all them all, and is the winner in my heart) 

14. Jennie - Alright I guess

15. Moonbyul - She's from Mamamoo

 

*the weak tier*

16. Lisa - I honestly feel like Lisa is a better vocalist than most of Twice except for 3mix, her voice has more power than theirs. 

17. Chaeyoung - I like her vocal tone a lot actually, and she is the prettiest idol ever, so she won. 

18. Mina - Too much whispering, I know that she is an introvert, but does she have to be one while singing also? 

19. Tzuyu - The same applies to her as Mina, but beautiful gowns however

20. Sana - Cute

21. Dahyun - You make me fee' speciur 

 

*The "How Did You Debut?" tier*

22. Momo - Even I can't defend her sometimes, however I would place her way higher if the vocal ranking was according to me heart

 

Couple of disagreements

I think you vastly underrate Blackpink. Rose is a better vocalist than Jeongyeon & Nayeon. Jisoo & Jennie are much better than Yeri & Irene, who belong at the top of the weak tier, or maybe in their own tier between weak and alright

Also, Wendy is clearly in a tier of her own here. Whee-in and Solar are great - but they don't have her head voice, her musicality, her lower register.

My take:

 

Wendy tier
Wendy 
God tier
Whee In 
Solar 
Top tier
Hwasa
Seulgi 
Good tier
Joy
Jihyo
Rosé
Alright tier
Jeongyeon
Nayeon 
Jisoo
Jennie
Moonbyul
Mediocre tier
Irene
Yeri
Weak tier
Lisa
Chaeyoung
Mina
Tzuyu
Sana
Dahyun
Tone Deaf Tier
Momo
 

 

 

 

Not someone trying to shade Twice's Hanteo sales. The lack of self-awareness is astounding in this thread sometimes.

Beatbox 

15 minutes ago, K$Ellie said:

 

oh no one even posted this  nothing redeemable about the song, they haven’t put out anything worthwhile in almost two years 

 

better than anything txt has released this year 

1 minute ago, NeonTiger said:

Beatbox 

better than anything txt has released this year 

not at all but the bar is in hell for bg releases this year from nct to txt to svt to skz

dream snapped with the bsides this year 

 

beatbox is great 

27 minutes ago, getinthezone said:

What are they supposed to have going on?

IVE, aespa & LE SSERAFIM all have strong physicals in addition to having decent international presence & great domestic charting. GIDLE only really has one of these  I'd even rank ITZY above them atp

Edited May 30, 20224 yr by Billionaire

Beatbox is super good Deserved to be the original TT

 

To my first as well 

3 minutes ago, Billionaire said:

IVE, aespa & LE SSERAFIM all have strong physicals in addition to having decent international presence & great domestic charting. GIDLE only really has one of these  I'd even rank ITZY above them atp

The one thing the Griddles do have is the current multinational corporation that controls Cube was attracted to the investment primarily for the Griddle girls to peddle their cosmetics throughout Asia.  Particularly Yuqi in China.  The other groups are just disposable company cogs.  Heck, Ive's corporate overlords are trying really hard to overpay for aespa's company just for the international brand awareness it could bring to their IT services.

 

It's kinda true G-IDLE is falling into OMG's territory. They used to have great physical numbers but now they look weak af compared to IVE, aespa, LE SSakurafim and ITZY. 

 

They don't have an It girl either, so their next comebacks would either be hit or miss

I don’t really like G-idle that much but I feel everyone is always underestimating them. They just had a huge hit and everyone is writing them off  Even My bag is doing well. And Miyeon seems quite popular in Korea. 

Hey, Brave Entertainment's first NFT artist Hip Kongs just dropped his its debut single.

 

 

So that's what they're going to do with those alleged ~600 songs they haven't released.

 

Edited May 30, 20224 yr by harrythevifan

Idle has always done decently and their rise is the definition of organic  

OMG feels very much like a flash in the pan though.

 

2 minutes ago, Somi said:

Idle has always done decently and their rise is the definition of organic  

OMG feels very much like a flash in the pan though.

 

Yeah, maybe Jiho made the right choice by leaving the group

 

 

Just now, Britney Jean said:

Yeah, maybe Jiho made the right choice by leaving the group

 

 

Wrong group sis, Jiho is still in TWICE...

 

No wonder Stray Kids is eating everyone up. 

3 minutes ago, Somi said:

Wrong group sis, Jiho is still in TWICE...

 

sis...

 

5 minutes ago, Somi said:

Wrong group sis, Jiho is still in TWICE...

 

Kang Daniel is out of Jihoe though 

 

Edited May 30, 20224 yr by sunmimi imfurst