19 minutes ago, hausofdave said:

it’s not like it’d be win-competitive for BP or BA either way

 

How so?

13 minutes ago, FameFatale said:

The way the ARTPOP anniversary came and went and she didn’t say a thing. 
 

that's not true she said http://shop.ladygaga.com

 

She needs to release the Chromatica Ball Film, earn her Emmy nomination and lose to whoever

17 minutes ago, ViviLittleM said:

She needs to release the Chromatica Ball Film, earn her Emmy nomination and lose to whoever

I wonder how she would’ve fared against this year’s nominees had it been released in time

 

https://www.emmys.com/awards/nominees-winners/2023/outstanding-variety-special-pre-recorded

All these theses about ROM   

 

The base lost its mind when this #1 Grammy-winning pop gem first came out but nah, let's pick apart a microsecond-long part of the song because of a streaming metric only 13 people on a pop forum care about

38 minutes ago, Leptine said:

How so?

-Musicals have a trend of over-performing in audience/highbrow critic reactions and then underperforming in awards (see Mary Poppins Returns). Even successful musicals like Les Mis and recent films like Tick Tick… Boom! or WSS came short. A nom is the ceiling, its not snuffing out the current Top 3 (Oppenheimer, Holdovers, Poor Things/KOTFM) nor is it competition in director nor screenplay which is a usually must combo to pull off a BP win

 

-also doesn’t help WB already has another contender named Barbie. Robbie is also competing with Barrino with similar votes & awards (C/M GG, if Stone doesn’t win). i doubt both will squeeze a nom given how crowded the BA field already is 

Edited November 21, 20232 yr by hausofdave

I don't know if The Lady & the Legend will feature anything just after the ARTPOP era, but even a few minutes of her talking about how the era had impacted her would finally put the era to bed and temper unrealistic expectations of the base. Anyone who stanned during the ARTPOP era was not shocked that the 10th anniversary celebration was just new t-shirts.

Remember when she told us Perfect Illusion was about Instgram

 

2 minutes ago, hausofdave said:

-Musicals have a trend of over-performing in audience/highbrow critic reactions and then underperforming in awards (see "Mary Poppins Returns") Even successful musicals like "Les Miserables", and recent films like "Tick Tick... Boom!" or "West Side Story" came short. A nom is the ceiling, its not snuffing out the current Top 3 (Oppenheimer, Holdovers, Poor Things/KOTFM) nor is it competitive in director nor screenplay which is usually a must combo to pull off a BP win

-also doesn’t help WB already has another contender named Barbie. Robbie is also competing with Barrino with similar votes & awards (C/M GG, if Stone doesn’t win). i doubt both will squeeze a nom given how crowded the BA field already is 

My point was about a possible scenario if this was delayed next year and be against JFAD, not the current race, it could have been strong competition for JFAD since both have musical elements, this year for sure there are stronger contenders on the paper, however you never know what can happen, you can't write off a contender, the official reviews for this haven't  came out, the main actress is 6th on Goldderby and a black woman hasn't won best actress in over 20 years since Halle Berry, it could be a strong narrative.

11 minutes ago, Aden said:

I don't know if The Lady & the Legend will feature anything just after the ARTPOP era, but even a few minutes of her talking about how the era had impacted her would finally put the era to bed and temper unrealistic expectations of the base. Anyone who stanned during the ARTPOP era was not shocked that the 10th anniversary celebration was just new t-shirts.

I stan since Paparazzi but still I expected a tweet about ARTPOP and not a link to the shop 
I said a million times that act II was never coming, to celebrate an anniversary you don't need a complete new album but, again, she may hate that period of her life but not the music, the art she made! That's what heald her and it is just what also happened with the creation of Chromatica.

The way she quickly shortened Perfect Illusion on tour

 

The way she snubbed Joanne era in her vogue iconic looks video

 

27 minutes ago, Bhabylon said:

Remember when she told us Perfect Illusion was about Instgram

 

She lied and said it was about social media. 
 

She is actually classy for not saying it was about her ex fiancé. Other artists love to talk about how their songs are inspired by famous ex boyfriends 

32 minutes ago, hausofdave said:

-Musicals have a trend of over-performing in audience/highbrow critic reactions and then underperforming in awards (see Mary Poppins Returns). Even successful musicals like Les Mis and recent films like Tick Tick… Boom! or WSS came short. A nom is the ceiling, its not snuffing out the current Top 3 (Oppenheimer, Holdovers, Poor Things/KOTFM) nor is it competition in director nor screenplay which is a usually must combo to pull off a BP win

 

-also doesn’t help WB already has another contender named Barbie. Robbie is also competing with Barrino with similar votes & awards (C/M GG, if Stone doesn’t win). i doubt both will squeeze a nom given how crowded the BA field already is 

I was reading this and ready to argue but started to confuse when Barbie was mentioned

 

Thought you were talking about JFAD

Anyway there is also case of La La Land so who knows. These days stats are nothing really

8 minutes ago, Marry The Gods said:

The way she snubbed Joanne era in her vogue iconic looks video

 

Well she didn’t pick those pics to react to/talk about. There were way too many ARTPOP looks

30 minutes ago, Leptine said:

My point was about a possible scenario if this was delayed next year and be against JFAD, not the current race, it could have been strong competition for JFAD since both have musical elements, this year for sure there are stronger contenders on the paper, however you never know what can happen, you can't write off a contender, the official reviews for this haven't  came out, the main actress is 6th on Goldderby and a black woman hasn't won best actress in over 20 years since Halle Berry, it could be a strong narrative.

-either or WB wouldn’t move JFAD’s slot release, it’d be likely competing more w Wicked Pt. 1 which would categorize under the same as TCP moreso than JFAD, since the latter would stay in Drama like its predecessor and Yeoh just won this year, which perfectly fits the POC narrative & unless TCP replicates the cultural and cinematic behemoth that was EEAAO, Barrino isn’t beating Stone / Gladstone 

20 minutes ago, Si Hoo said:

I was reading this and ready to argue but started to confuse when Barbie was mentioned

 

Thought you were talking about JFAD

Anyway there is also case of La La Land so who knows. These days stats are nothing really

-Stone’s win was locked when it was clear that LLL had the upmost momentum at the time, tho still lost BP at the end despite sweeping the pre-cursors

-TCP isn’t the type of film that would rank egregiously high on a preferential ballot especially when you have more original academy friendly highbrow films in play

 Joanne era was not iconic visually   it had to be ignored

I need to heal the way you make me feel
 

 

Happy 12 years to Born This Way: The Remix

 

 

Edited November 21, 20232 yr by Almodusa

2 minutes ago, Almodusa said:

 

the deep-cut that could
 

58 minutes ago, Almodusa said:

The way she quickly shortened Perfect Illusion on tour

 

there was already a lot of shouting in that opening segment and mama had more songs to sing! it was the smart thing to do

 

we already know how that tour ended - we didn’t need her voice giving out too

 

Bloody Mary at 99 on YEC & The Fame at 111 on the BB200 YEC. All on a hiatus year too 

her first solo entry since 2013