Shallow had the movie trailer attached to it. go touch grass. 

every YT reactions for the intro is a kii

2 minutes ago, Vrajesh said:

yes maam but i belive shallow had more people excited than this 

 

this is why i wish the old pages were still here, beacause i could quote hundredths about how the song is awful and how the crowd noises are gonna keep people from streaming

 

not 224k likes

4 minutes ago, TaylorNation said:

Europe is sleeping 

 

we are at work maam not sleeping 

Stream it from Pop Rising at low volume (not mute, streams won't count)

 

 

The intro is not the tea. 

Some of the lyrics are hard to understand. 

 

The last 30-40 seconds is the best bit. 

I think it's OK. Not expecting it to do too well but you never know. 

Before I Cry is the better song, the outro runs (especially "before I, crrrrrryyyyyyyyy heee ahhoh") make it such a climatic listen

4 minutes ago, Bojana said:

 

this is why i wish the old pages were still here, beacause i could quote hundredths about how the song is awful and how the crowd noises are gonna keep people from streaming

Thats not what i said. They were complaining about that but people were genuinely excited for the song. 

On 4/26/2022 at 6:10 PM, Blade Runner said:

Yes, some of y'all are doing THE MOST expecting this song to debut at #1, get 1B streams on Spotify, and win 5 Oscars. It feels like y'all are insecure about her career and are trying to prove something to her haters... AGAIN. 

 

What are you gonna do when it peaks at like #34 or something? Didn't the Oscar snub teach you something? It's JUST a song from a movie. Not a lead single. Chill a little. 

 

Y'all should listen to me, and only me, all the time. 

 

It's just a song from a movie. Nothing else. Cute, touching, and it's gonna do its job. 

Edited May 3, 20224 yr by Blade Runner

1 minute ago, Negev said:

Before I Cry is the better song, the outro runs (especially "before I, crrrrrryyyyyyyyy heee ahhoh") make it such a climatic listen

i keep singing the BIC outro at the end of HMH 

no, but in all seriousness I like it. it’s very soccer mommy but her vocals sound amazing 

 

5 minutes ago, BadMonster said:

It's not

 

3 minutes ago, Vrajesh said:

we are at work maam not sleeping 

I know sisterns, i’m on my way to work trying to bop to Hold My Bible but it’s not fully clicking yet 

I have some thoughts.. I love the vocals! Dope vocals found dead. It actually reminds me a bit of the cure and joanne lyrically. Melodically its before I cry and When I look at You by miss Miley. I do like the song, I just think some melodies could be stronger.. The intro is wierd, but at first listen it didnt bother me tbh. Maybe it will in the future, but there will be a radio edit. I dont see this getting an oscar, nomination maybe. Will this be a hit? Top 20 would be very cute for this song, top 15 ideal almost. If it goes top 10 it will exceed my expectations. This needs some viral tiktok trend.. little managers better have something up their sleeve.

I just listened Hold My Hand, so...

 

How can I put it into words? It's not the type of Gaga song that I love in first listen 

Before I Cry is the worst original Gaga song on ASIB (except Why Did You Record (That Abomination)?). Hold My Hand is infinitely better than that song.

I need Gaga to work with whoever produces for Ava Max. The production is always top notch and punchy 

Just now, MadMax12 said:

I need Gaga to work with whoever produces for Ava Max. The production is always top notch and punchy 

Jesus. At least say Dua or something. 

 

Y’all should go back to doing discography dark bawp rates. Only this fanbase would make a release day completely unenjoyable  

 

Gaga would be better off completely ditching any pop persona and just going full jazz residency/actress.

4 minutes ago, MadMax12 said:

I need Gaga to work with whoever produces for Ava Max. The production is always top notch and punchy 

I mean I don't like HMH too but this take is just gaga has enough issue with cheap sounding production already we don't need another bloodpoop

Damn it just keeps getting better on every listen

 

After listen 28 or something, it's really PUNCHING. It's SOOO good

I am convinced Gaga still hasnt found her production soulmate just yet. Once she does, her true magnum opus album will arrive. I know people claim BTW is her opus but I legit think she hasn't released a proper album where we can all universally say is her best work indisputably. I am so excited for when that day comes. I just hope it does sooner rather than later.

So far. 7 #1s, 21 top 10s 

 

i love the released version but the raw instruments in the second verse are >

 

https://video.h5.weibo.cn/1034:4765017774686271/4765018153027690

4 minutes ago, Marry Illusion Glory said:

So far. 7 #1s, 21 top 10s 

 

22 Top 10s actually, it jumped to #9 in Austria  

The song works well with the movie.