JackOfHearts

I don't even remember Christina's part in the song.

Noooooo, not this legend 😢 Back-to-back hits with Dolly and Tim, this week is brutal! Rest in Peace Tim Curry 🖤

Wasn't this revealed a loooong time ago? I woulda been here for it but there would be RIOTS from the GP at the time.

One Assassination Under God, Chapter 2 dropped on Aug 14 and I've been listening to it front-to-back since then.

It doesn't deserve it, but then again, neither did Midnights. Guess we'll see?

Favourite is The One That Got Away, and the next one to go viral should be Walking On Air. 🙌

I really don't think Sam ever tanked their career. After their debut, they've kinda flown pretty steadily right under the radar where nobody really cares what they do one way or another. I've found it kind of annoying, cause they try to be outrageous and many would be canceled for trying so hard, but the GP doesn't really react that much. Homo milk is just a little thicker than 2%, it's not outrageous to the GP.

Roar is peak cheesy terrible Katy. And right after those tacky funeral videos of her blue wig, like she was gonna do anything else but release aerosol cheese music. Yes, And doesn't make me grimace like the other one.

For me, I figured Mariah. It's so… acceptable. But, after I already voted, I realized her shrill whistle notes might cause stress and anxiety in an elevator, so maybe it's not her. Either way, I don't doubt millions end up listening to AIWFCIY in the elevator at some point. But then there's Taylor. The safest, most vanilla, background, common denominator music. No danger there.

Old Katy might keep New Katy from completely sinking to the bottom of the void, but "save" isn't the word I'd use. All the attention to her (s)old catalogue will only bring nostalgia, it has not at all been translating to interest in her new catalogue.

Honestly the worst song on the album. Maybe of her career. Yes I'm aware of Jewels and Drugs, yes I stand by my statement.

I don't know why, but this user's posts all read like a parody. Like, you read what they say and it's like, there's no way this is a real person. Maybe on some Nickelodeon show where it's fully grown men writing like they're tweens, maybe that's where you'd read dialogue like this. And for someone who is such a hater of Gaga, it's super hypocritical to keep bleating on and on about how people need to leave Katy alone. You are part of the problem.

Does anyone remember The Box? I think it must've released in 2019 but I think it still counts as hella forgotten.

Happy birthday Madonna! But I thought it was a couple of days ago, no?

Wtf is a "Xtina's Moves Like Jagger"? I didn't think she sang on it long enough to justify more than a ft credit. If that.

Zero shade, first thought, Normani. It's just… not plausible.

Does this really belong in Base? No.

I didn't realize Die With a Smile came out on Madge's birthday And Disease came out on Katy Perry's

I feel like it would have made more sense to either exclude Madame X and leave the rest in the poll, or only include the ones mentioned in the OP with Madame X. Anyways, I think the answer in any given scenario is Madame X.

I'm kinda tired of this narrative that ARTPOP was this giant flop. It actually did pretty decent numbers, but Gaga had reached peak overexposure and was recovering from physically BREAKING. Her manager also peaced out right before the era got into full swing, and I'm pretty sure he started sabotaging her at Spotify. Despite all that, the album and the tour did good, and she managed to mostly sidestep more catastrophe by abandoning DWUW. There were literally phony trolls posing as detractors to write hit pieces on her and the album. Like who tf thinks to do that? AND, why would this album be the benchmark for flopping? It was nowhere near the underperformance as Bionic years before, nor Witness > Smile > 143 in the decade+ that followed it.

Idk, it's a little bit the black sheep of the album, doesn't fit what everyone wanted maybe? Idk. Doesn't have the traditional song structure, lotta marching band kinda funky jazzy-ness to it.

Such a great finish to The Fame Monster! People love to dunk on it but it's one of my favourites from that album. Haters' teeth are probably yellow.

Either The Fame Monster or Born This Way deserved a spot on this list, regardless of which one they consider to be Gaga's sophomore album. Teenager Dream also deserves a spot on this list. 21 placed, which was definitely deserved.

I don't think I've ever replayed Short N Sweet. Teenage Dream, I do tend to listen to once in a while, in full or at least mostly,

Either there'll be implants in our brain or the whole grid will go down and we'll be back in the dark ages, working our way back to streaming.