How can anyone with taste prefer this over PINKY UP?

This could have been made by basically anyone… it's not completely bad per sé, but it's a bit soulless and underproduced. PINKY UP is truly theirs and has a proper personality, forever their best song for me tbh.

Still, they do look good.

Are there more eurodance-oriented songs on the EP?

I need HYBE to go all out with radio payola for this one Cause the gays are not going to carry this one

This is how you ruin a girl group, with an ed Sheeran song… bye

So far for me its

Gnarly > Gabriela >>>>> Pinky Up >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> everything else >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Animal

5 minutes ago, shark_heather said:

So far for me its

Gnarly > Gabriela >>>>> Pinky Up >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> everything else >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Animal

Gnarly was hated on here, so I'm kinda surprised

Just now, The Prophecy said:

Gnarly was hated on here, so I'm kinda surprised

Well ATRL,'s majority taste is a bit questionable

Im a bit sour tbh with the label

You have a young fresh and talented girl group , you cannot even release a full length album and you drop EPs with random songs that one has nothing to do with the other like WTF

Just now, shark_heather said:

Im a bit sour tbh with the label

You have a young fresh and talented girl group , you cannot even release a full length album and you drop EPs with random songs that one has nothing to do with the other like WTF

They're following the k-pop model of releasing EPs and quite clearly it's working because what other girl group has has a fraction of their success. I mean their arena tour selling out in seconds is proof of this.

Their music does need to improve though, I would love for them to go down this route:

I liked it until I found out it was Ed Sheeran, lol

Hm, Pinky Up was 1000% better as it had their own spark and was something different. This was ok at first listen, but I don't think it will go into my Playlists (but i will try a couple of more times)

wasn't this supposed to be for Britney? because it sounds like a Britney song from later eras

6 minutes ago, The Prophecy said:

They're following the k-pop model of releasing EPs and quite clearly it's working because what other girl group has has a fraction of their success. I mean their arena tour selling out in seconds is proof of this.

Their music does need to improve though, I would love for them to go down this route:

But k pop artists have also k pop songs . They have an identity 😂

These girls they go from a GP song to a k pop song to a dance song and then to a generic song

My comment has nothing to do with their success of their tour . Actually the contrary . They are so successful that I dont understand how difficult is to drop an 11 song album with 6-7 k pop bangers , 2 ballads and 2 GP friendly . And let the world decide which is the hit

32 minutes ago, The Prophecy said:

Gnarly was hated on here, so I'm kinda surprised

When people reference it to express how lopsided or bad their discography is, but it's ACTUALLY Internet Girl that's the shitty song.

1 minute ago, MP2K said:

When people reference it to express how lopsided or bad their discography is, but it's ACTUALLY Internet Girl that's the shitty song.

I've actually liked all their songs including the ones on the ep, but internet girl was their first real chop for me

this song is such a throwback... and not in a good way

song is so bad, but they look sickening in the video

Already playlisted by Radio 1

1 minute ago, The Prophecy said:

Already playlisted by Radio 1

Truly doesn't deserve it. Should have been PINKY UP…

is this a joke? it's literally an ed sheeran song and nothing more

A listenable song but at what cost because this is nowhere near Gameboy or even Touch quality wise

Edited July 24Jul 24 by Billionaire

6 minutes ago, ZENO said:

Truly doesn't deserve it. Should have been PINKY UP…

Yeah I agree, I feel like they could have at least pushed Pinky Up on UK radio

4 minutes ago, The Prophecy said:

Yeah I agree, I feel like they could have at least pushed Pinky Up on UK radio

Amen.

1 hour ago, MP2K said:

When people reference it to express how lopsided or bad their discography is, but it's ACTUALLY Internet Girl that's the shitty song.

Animal low-key made me appreciate Internet girl...

I've listened to the song a few times. The chorus is catchy, it does get stuck in your head.

I think clearly they've listened to all the fans moaning about the hyperpop music they've released - everyone who has moaned about Gnarly, Internet Girl and Pinky Up.. I hope you're happy and you better not be calling it generic or uninspired because this is for you, it's what you asked for.

To my German sisters:

Why is this giving Queensberry?