It's time for the moment of truth.

The Best: The Archer

The Worst: either the one from Evermore or the one from Speak Now

Best: tolerate it

Worst: Eldest Daughter

I had a very hard time with best, lol. I finally went with Delicate, but was about to press So Long, London.

ED is the worst for me.

Best: tolerate it, All Too Well, my tears ricochet

Worst: Eldest Daughter, no contest

The best just IS All Too Well. Sometimes the common consensus is correct. Taylor herself knows it, too.

Honorable mentions to Dear John, Tolerate It, and My Tears Ricochet which would each be the very best song in MANY discographies.

Erectile Dysfunction is BY FAR the worst and is responsible for at least 50% of the Showgirl lashings alone.

Edited March 10Mar 10 by DevilsRollTheDice

Best: Tolerate It

Worst: Cold As You

You forgot How Did It End?

It has to be YOYOK for me

Best is So Long London for me

Your second Taylor thread in half an hour won't Lady GaGa start to get jealous?

1. All Too Well

2. Tolerate It

3. Delicate

4. My Tears Richochet

5. So Long London

6. You're On Your Own, Kid

7. White Horse

8. All You Had to Do Was Stay

9. Dear John

10. The Archer

11. Cold As You

12. Abandoned Daughter

You know, I haven't properly processed this since 2021.. the Taylormania years were a lot to digest but now that the waters are calmer, I can assess this better.

S Tier: Dear John, All Too Well, tolerate it

A+ Tier: Delicate, YOYOK, So Long London

A Tier: My Tears Ricochet

A- Tier: White Horse

B+ Tier: Cold As You

B Tier: All You Had To Do Was Stay

B- Tier: The Archer

C Tier: Eldest Daughter

of the 3 best, it honestly just depends on the day I genuinely can't decide.

All Too Well. Followed by You're On Your Own, Kid and my tears ricochet.

33 minutes ago, TayDuaStan said:

The Best: The Archer

The Worst: either the one from Evermore or the one from Speak Now

I am sorry, but this is one of the worst takes ever Dear John and Tolerate It are immaculate.

I voted for ATW tho. Eldest Daughter is easily the worst

All Too Well

Dear John

tolerate it

Delicate

White Horse

my tears ricochet

So Long London

Cold As You

You're On Your Own Kid

All You Had to Do Was Stay

The Archer

Eldest Daughter

Dear John and All Too Well >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

My fav is The Archer but all of these are great

obvs ED is the worst tho

My personal preferences:

So Long London
tolerate it
my tears ricochet
All Too Well
You're on Your Own, Kid
Cold As You
The Archer
Dear John
All You Had To Do Was Stay
Delicate
White Horse
Eldest Daughter