Both of them are past their prime and had big peaks. Think that both are underrated within the streaming audience and deserve way better numbers. Which one has more classics?

or

Ummm Janet. She made art.

Yall know its Xtina cmon

What are their Spotify numbers?

1 minute ago, Supernatural94 said:

What are their Spotify numbers?

Genie in a Bottle does ~500k

Janets whole discography ~770k

Edited December 20, 2025Dec 20 by Nico Robin

Nobody under the age of 25 even knows Janet's music

Artist vs. singer

3 minutes ago, Vox Lux said:

Nobody under the age of 25 even knows Janet's music

You're saying this like they do Xtina

Im sorry what GLOBAL hits does Janet have? Lets be reaaaal

Xtina has at least 5 hits

Love Legendtina down, but Janet's run from 1986 to 2001 is filled with classics. That's 15 years of them... She's criminally underrated and deserves a Kate Bush kind of resurgence.

But Christina isn't that far behind, and stan circles play too much with her.

Gurl.... Really. It's JJ and it's not even close.

Don't compare miss Jackson to Maroon 5's featuring girl.

Edited December 20, 2025Dec 20 by swiss3234

10 minutes ago, Nico Robin said:

Genie in a Bottle does ~500k

Janets whole discography ~770k

Omg

Just now, bjorn said:

Im sorry what GLOBAL hits does Janet have? Lets be reaaaal

Xtina has at least 5 hits

Together Again, All For You, That's the Way Love Goes, Scream, What Have You Done for Me Lately

This tired question

Just now, Armani. said:

Together Again, All For You, That's the Way Love Goes, Scream, What Have You Done for Me Lately

This tired question

These are not Global? That's US hits

4 minutes ago, bjorn said:

Im sorry what GLOBAL hits does Janet have? Lets be reaaaal

Xtina has at least 5 hits

You must be 12.

This alone >>>>

2 minutes ago, bjorn said:

These are not Global? That's US hits

They went top 10 in many countries outside the US

Janet obviously clears

in the US, maybe Janet. but ww it's Christina for sure. even that MJ duet, i know it was a famous collab at the time, but i haven't heard it or seen it mentioned anywhere in a long long time.

I've heard the following in parties and on radio across Europe in the last year:

• Nasty

• Control

• Pleasure Principle

• Rhythm Nation

• Best Things in Life Are Free

• That's The Way Love Goes

• If

• Anytime Anyplace

• Scream

• Together Again

• All For You

• Genie in a Bottle

• What a Girl Wants

• Moulin Rouge Lady Marmalade

• Dirrty

• Beautiful

• Ain't No Other Man

• Moves Like Jagger

I ran so fast in here to vote for Janet.

For me personally Janet by far even though I love Xtine

For the GeePee Genie is bigger than any and all Janet classiques

24 minutes ago, Vox Lux said:

Nobody under the age of 25 even knows Janet's music

Neither do people know xtina. But at least Janet made good music.

Janet's music inspired a whole generation of Pop stars. Look up the MTV tribute to Janet. All of your late 90s/early 00 favs were there, honoring Janet.

Britney, Destiny's Child, Xtina, P!nk, Aaliyah, Mya, and many more.

Stop this nonsense!

37 minutes ago, Supernatural94 said:

What are their Spotify numbers?

Genie daily doing more than Janet's top 20. Skinny trumps

Janet put out at least one classic for 5 eras in a row. Plus, four of those albums are certified classics and highly acclaimed and influential.

Xtina has a few from her debut and Stripped. I'm struggling to call anything off BTB classic. It doesn't seem to be remembered, talked about and referenced all that much.

Clearly Janet.