Which experimental song and video is better? 

 

This had to be done girls. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

You have to be ******* ******ed to choose that crap over the masterpiece that is Die Another Day.

DAD is Madonna's third best song.

It made me think of Die another day when I saw the video

 

You can't properly compare them though because Madonna does it miles better 

Sorry Madonna, we don't mean this 

Its like comparing a blockbuster movie to a home video. Gaga's video basically has no budget. 

Die Another Day 22 years after release still sounds absolutely fantastic, fresh and progressive and same applies for the video

Edited October 30, 20241 yr by mike_int

90s-00s was Madonna at her artistic prime. Comparisons are unfair 

This comparison makes no sense. Voted for Die Another Day though because that's greatness.

10 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

This comparison makes no sense. Voted for Die Another Day though because that's greatness.

The reason I made this poll is because..... 

 

They are fighting themselves in the videos. 

 

The songs are so called experimental even though one of them was more so during its time. 

 

Both creepy death like videos. 

 

Plus the titles of the songs speak for themselves. 

 

This poll makes more sense then most of the other wierd random ones on here lol. 

Die Another Day, obviously.

1 minute ago, Shaner69 said:

The reason I made this poll is because..... 

 

They are fighting themselves in the videos. 

 

The songs are so called experimental even though one of them was more so during its time. 

 

Both creepy death like videos. 

 

Plus the titles of the songs speak for themselves. 

 

This poll makes more sense then most of the other wierd random ones on here lol. 

I mean, yeah... there are parallels but just visually and even there the message is completely different. Did I watch Gaga's video and think of Die Another Day? No, not really. So this feels like the 800th Gaga set up thread of the week to me, no offence.

Voted for Disease just to make you fume! 

The Madonna Gaga comparisons stopped making sense 12 years ago, Gaga has proven Madonna's shoes are too big for her

DAD is 1000x better in every way

Vote and bop girls. 

What's great about Madonna is she never became creatively bankrupt and was never caught in a cycle of rehashing concepts and imagery she already used, and Die Another Day was no different.

She looks stunning throughout and the choreographed fight scenes are incredible, which means a lot of work went into that video.

 

The other is nothing but a lazy rehash of boring old looks and imagery from a decade ago.  I supposed she tried though.

Edited October 30, 20241 yr by Charmed Life

Die another day is one of the greatest songs ever ..    Disease is cute but it will never be the legendry Die another day 

madonna clears this one x

I like both but Die Another Day >>>>>>>>

Satanic rumors?

Madonna comparisons?

WE ARE SO BACK!!!

DAD for both, though I really like the Disease video.