Both singles were jumping the shark moments for both eras, the MVs were a mess.

Alejandro. Judas for the video.

Judas for everything 

I dislike Alejandro so much it's insane  HATE that music video and the song is just boring

 Judas outsold

Judas for everything lowkey  love Alejandro too but Judas has always been a thrilling pop masterpiece that kinda epitomizes everything that's always been so great about Gaga

Alejandro. Probably Gaga's best single and the video aged so well

Alejandro for all. 

Alejandro just sounds much "smoother" if it makes sense. It was catchy, and I felt it was more "versatile" in the sense that it was catchier to a larger audience within the general public than Judas.

12 minutes ago, psychodiva336 said:

I dislike Alejandro so much it's insane  HATE that music video and the song is just boring

 Judas outsold

What an interesting take

 

It was such a big smash  

 

Im still obsessed with it to this day

ive always hated the judas video, very corny. ive got no idea what monsters see in it. love the song tho!

aje for all!



 

Judas for all 

 

The bridge alone >

Jesus is my virtue but judas is the demon that I cling to

so I voto for Alejandro

Judas for all 

 

Alejandro video had me shook at the time, though 

Judas for all.

 

Alejandro is one of her best songs too though.

judas was ahead of its time

1 hour ago, Junipero said:

Alejandro for all. 

Alejandro just sounds much "smoother" if it makes sense. It was catchy, and I felt it was more "versatile" in the sense that it was catchier to a larger audience within the general public than Judas.

This^

 

Alejandro was just the girl 

The cultural impact and change it brought upon music in general was astronomical 

Judas is good, but it's no Ale-alejandro

1 hour ago, Junipero said:

Alejandro for all. 

Alejandro just sounds much "smoother" if it makes sense. It was catchy, and I felt it was more "versatile" in the sense that it was catchier to a larger audience within the general public than Judas.

This^

 

Alejandro was just the girl 

The cultural impact and change it brought upon music in general was astronomical 

Judas is good, but it's no Ale-alejandro

Alejandro for all. That's my fav song ever

Omg this is like choosing between your children

 

I think "Alejandro" was superior though somehow. She subverted expectations. Everyone heard this summery Latin American influenced bop and was ready for a sexy spicy video and she came and served ICE cold, ugly, frozen abyss and haunting Catholic imagery. Maybe "Judas" is more of a bop though? Lol

 

There's something lazy about "judas" choreo. Boomkack was dialling in the moves 

Judas for all

MV version of Alejandro > Judas

Judas MV was probably one of my all time gave gaga video but the Alejandro was the bop

 

but I did love the choreography for Alejandro like that bed scene 

Judas x 3

Loterally her two best songs 

Judas changed my life forever so that

I slightly prefer Alejandro as a song but they are both great. 

 

Literally my favorite two gaga videos. I ended up voting Judas though I think it just has a bit more originality. 

 

Judas has the better choreo.