Which one do you enjoy more? (not which one is better) 

Edited September 27, 20241 yr by MonsterJohn

143 obviously, at least she delivered what was expected from a pop singer which was an album full of bops

 

Who wanted another jazz album from Lady Gaga in 2024?

Edited September 27, 20241 yr by gui

Harlequin obviously, at least she delivered what was expected from a vocalist which is an album full of vocal delivery. 

 

Who wanted another album produced by a rapist in 2024? 

Harlequin, sweetie

JazzGa 

Each of The Joker, Happy Mistake, and Close To You alone clear the entirety of 143 IMO, and the rest is just a bonus.

vs 

2 minutes ago, Dear Reader said:

Harlequin obviously, at least she delivered what was expected from a vocalist which is an album full of vocal delivery. 

 

Who wanted another album produced by a rapist in 2024? 

Just another album you won't ever listen to again 

 

Also the guy wasn't found guilty. Next.

jazz/traditional pop remakes > teenage dream remake

143 is more enjoyable so 143

1 minute ago, gui said:

Just another album you won't ever listen to again 

 

Also the guy wasn't found guilty. Next.

Jazz music is not for everybody but Gaga served quality at least. Can't say the same for 143 

2 minutes ago, gui said:

Also the guy wasn't found guilty. Next.

The way y'all think you eat every single time you use that excuse. Fix yourself sis 

But it makes no sense to compare those two anyway… We should wait for Gaga to put LG7 out and then we can compare 

There's nothing on 143 even half as good as The Joker, World On A String or Happy Mistakes. 

I can see why some ATRLers would prefer 143, and no shade intended. It's a genre thing.

 

I'll go with Mother Monster.

10 minutes ago, Wookkruk said:

But it makes no sense to compare those two anyway… We should wait for Gaga to put LG7 out and then we can compare 

Even Gaga knows this won't have much appeal, which is why she's putting out LG7s lead single in just a few weeks. But asking Kats to put on their thinking cap is a lot to ask. 

Sexy confident so inteligent me Harley Quinn

The one showcasing talent!!

LOLL not the liddos pretending to enjoy another tryhard Gaga album

 

we've already seen this with Cheek to Cheek, Joanne and Love for Sale 

i really like Harlequin, 2/3 jazzy songs that are not my cup of tea but the rest its good

10 minutes ago, jordanjm said:

Even Gaga knows this won't have much appeal, which is why she's putting out LG7s lead single in just a few weeks. But asking Kats to put on their thinking cap is a lot to ask. 

This is just a gift to fans and something she wanted to do to pair this with the film. Jazz music is not commercial and this is a known fact. Im glad she did this record and now we can wait for LG7 💕

Harlequin has 2 songs I like, #143 has 0 so…

I wanted some cute bops and Katy delivered, I may use Harlequin when I have trouble sleeping 

i really like Harlequin, 2/3 jazzy songs that are not my cup of tea but the rest its good

I voted Harlequin because even if I much prefer pop to jazz, 143 is really bad