What do you guys think?

Chromatica bigger and better. 

 

Flowers was bigger than even Miley herself. Its another Havana situation.

Is that a real question 

Miley has Flowers

CSCP:

Endless Summer Vacation - 4,649,000

Chromatica - 3,888,000

 

Metacritic:

Endless Summer Vacation - 79 (Two Grammys including Record Of The Year)

Chromatica - 79 (One Grammy)

 

Miley wins.

I will say both are equal, especially when you add in CBT.

 

But at the end of day, Chromatica is just another era for Gaga. It has some nice stats but nothing new to Gaga.

 

On the other hand, ESV got Miley her biggest hit, her first grammys, ROTY.

'Endless Summer Vacation' is bigger, 'Chromatica' is better.

Chromatica era lasted for 4 years and had a successful tour so they're not equal at all. Touring will always be the determining factor.

 

I don't care what you say about Flowers being a smash, the rest of the album failed.

 

The people that votes Gaga must live in Chromatica.

On earth it's a flowers world

1. Chromatica

2. Chromatica

 

Y'all so funny for chosing unlistenable chromatica over mature masterpieces as Jaded, Thousand Miles, island, Used to be young, Rose Colored Lenses and violet chemistry... Atrl proves they just love generic music with zero meaning once again

Chromatica was biggest...in my heart. 

 

And it's definitely better. 

ESV is bigger and better and I'm not really that into it 

Is ESV even an era? It was just Flowers taking over everything including the album itself 

Flowers was a Goliath hit, but Chromatica is my favourite album of the 2020s…

 

Gonna say Chromatica was both bigger and better, even though Flowers was bigger than any of Gaga's singles.

 

It didn't feel like Flowers contributed to ESV's success, which is what a lead should do. It felt like it overshadowed ESV and made it look like a flop by comparison.

30 minutes ago, Digitalism said:

The people that votes Gaga must live in Chromatica.

On earth it's a flowers world

52 minutes ago, Wildcat said:

CSCP:

Endless Summer Vacation - 4,649,000

Chromatica - 3,888,000

 

Metacritic:

Endless Summer Vacation - 79 (Two Grammys including Record Of The Year)

Chromatica - 79 (One Grammy)

 

Miley wins.

Wait, didn't know ESV was that high, Flowers was such a huge smash, I can't

 

ESV but it had 4 singles and a deluxe edition where as Chromatica only had two. I think if Gaga/interscope had at least pushed Sour Candy as a single the album would have done better overall. 

They're pretty equal as eras and both were pretty much carried by their respective major hit.

 

Chromatica is a far better album, though.

Chromatica as an era.

 

Flowers may as well have been a standalone single, the era started and ended with it 

both albums were not great lmao but chromatica felt like a bigger era thanks to ROM and the tour, ESV was very underwhelming despite flowers behemoth success

 

9 minutes ago, Aden said:

They're pretty equal as eras and both were pretty much carried by their respective major hit.

 

Chromatica is a far better album, though.

Nah Chromatica was not carried to the extent of ESV. Flowers was like 5x bigger than Rain On Me and still the album's performance as a whole pales in comparison to Chromatica which was consumed as a body of work. Not even getting into the tour. 

Just now, SweetOreosOfHeaven said:

Nah Chromatica was not carried to the extent of ESV. Flowers was like 5x bigger than Rain On Me and still the album's performance as a whole pales in comparison to Chromatica which was consumed as a body of work. Not even getting into the tour. 

Actually, you're right.

 

When you think about Flower's massive success, ESV should have outstreamed Chromatica far more than it actually did. Miley also didn't have a 100% sold out stadium tour.

 

Chromatica bigger and better.

 

Chromatica era of course. Chromatica's sold out global stadium tour alone > the "Flowers" album.

I just remembered Miley's album wasnt even #1  People didnt cared at all. 

1 hour ago, zoldyck said:

I will say both are equal, especially when you add in CBT.

 

But at the end of day, Chromatica is just another era for Gaga. It has some nice stats but nothing new to Gaga.

 

On the other hand, ESV got Miley her biggest hit, her first grammys, ROTY.

.