Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.
ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues
RIP Dolly Parton ❤️

Joanne vs Midnights

Ghostface91
in Base

Joanne vs Midnights 50 members have voted

  1. 1. Whose album do you prefer?

    • Joanne
      42%
      21
    • Midnights
      57%
      29

  2. 2. Which aged better in 2024?

    • Joanne
      38%
      19
    • Midnights
      62%
      31

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Joanne, which tells you everything you need to know about Midnights

lastfm.thumb.gif.947b600618ede5b0e3727bc

    • Like 1

    Midnights is a pop bible so that

    • Like 1
    • Confused 1

    Diamond Heart vs Lavender Haze

    A-YO vs Maroon

    Joanne vs Anti-Hero

    John Wayne vs Snow on the Beach

    Dancin' in Circles vs You're on Your Own, Kid

    Perfect Illusion vs Midnight Rain

    Million Reasons vs Question...?

    Sinner's Prayer vs Vigilante ****

    Come to Mama vs Bejeweled

    Hey Girl vs Labyrinth

    Angel Down vs Karma

    Grigio Girls vs Sweet Nothing

    Just Another Day vs Mastermind

    Angel Down vs The Great War

    Bonus:

    Joanne (Piano Version) vs Bigger Than the Whole Sky

    The Cure vs Paris

    • Like 1
    • Haha 4

    Midnights as lackluster as it is, is better than Juana.

    Midnights isn't Taylor's best album, sure, but this is offensive :deadbanana4:

     

    This kind of quality just isn't there on Trashcanne :deadbanana4:

    • Like 1

    Diamond Heart vs Lavender Haze

    A-YO vs Maroon

    Joanne vs Anti-Hero

    John Wayne vs Snow on the Beach

    Dancin' in Circles vs You're on Your Own, Kid (genuinely can't pick) 

    Perfect Illusion vs Midnight Rain

    Million Reasons vs Question...?

    Sinner's Prayer vs Vigilante ****

    Come to Mama vs Bejeweled

    Hey Girl vs Labyrinth

    Angel Down vs Karma

    Grigio Girls vs Sweet Nothing

    Just Another Day vs Mastermind

    Angel Down vs The Great War

    Bonus:

    Joanne (Piano Version) vs Bigger Than the Whole Sky

    The Cure vs Paris

     

    It's not even close. The middle-end of Midnights is absolutely dreadful, only the first 5 tracks are usable in 2024 :cm:

    Listenable songs on both albums:

     

    Joanne: Sinner's Prayer, Diamond Heart, Perfect Illusion, Dancin In Circles, Million Reasons (5)

     

    Midnights: Midnight Rain, Maroon, You're On Your Own Kid (3)

     

    Joanne wins but yeah neither album is fantastic.

    I don't think it can get worse than Joanne. And I love Gaga but her discography after BTW is the pits :sad:

    • Thumbs Down 1

    I'm not really sure why we are comparing these, but

     

    a. I love Joanne.

    b. Midnights is a great pop album.

     

    Diamond Heart vs Lavender Haze

    A-YO vs Maroon

    Joanne vs Anti-Hero

    John Wayne vs Snow on the Beach

    Dancin' in Circles vs You're on Your Own, Kid

    Perfect Illusion vs Midnight Rain

    Million Reasons vs Question...?

    Sinner's Prayer vs Vigilante ****

    Come to Mama vs Bejeweled

    Hey Girl vs Labyrinth

    Angel Down vs Karma

    Grigio Girls vs Sweet Nothing

    Just Another Day vs Mastermind

    Angel Down vs The Great War

     

    Bonus:

    Joanne (Piano Version) vs Bigger Than the Whole Sky

    The Cure vs Paris

    Diamond Heart vs Lavender Haze

    A-YO vs Maroon

    Joanne vs Anti-Hero

    John Wayne vs Snow on the Beach

    Dancin' in Circles vs You're on Your Own, Kid

    Perfect Illusion vs Midnight Rain

    Million Reasons vs Question...?

    Sinner's Prayer vs Vigilante ****

    Come to Mama vs Bejeweled

    Hey Girl vs Labyrinth

    Angel Down vs Karma

    Grigio Girls vs Sweet Nothing 

    Just Another Day vs Mastermind

    Angel Down vs The Great War

     

    The definition of MID-off :skull:

     

     

    Midnights has always been great to me. Joanne I love the production, I have more of an issue with her vocals on it.

    Edited by Raphy23

    Diamond Heart vs Lavender Haze

    A-YO vs Maroon

    Joanne vs Anti-Hero

    John Wayne vs Snow on the Beach

    Dancin' in Circles vs You're on Your Own, Kid (genuinely can't pick) 

    Perfect Illusion vs Midnight Rain

    Million Reasons vs Question...?

    Sinner's Prayer vs Vigilante ****

    Come to Mama vs Bejeweled

    Hey Girl vs Labyrinth

    Angel Down vs Karma

    Grigio Girls vs Sweet Nothing

    Just Another Day vs Mastermind

    Angel Down vs The Great War

    Bonus:

    Joanne (Piano Version) vs Bigger Than the Whole Sky

    The Cure vs Paris

    Lavender Haze

    A-YO

    Joanne

    John Wayne

    Dancin' in Circles

    Perfect Illusion

    Million Reasons

    Sinner's Prayer

    Bejeweled

    Hey Girl

    Karma

    Sweet Nothing

    Just Another Day

    The Great War

     

    Bonus:

    Bigger Than the Whole Sky

    The Cure

     

    Joanne is the better album, Midnights standard edition is not very good tbh. The 3AM tracks is where's it's really at.

     

    Neither of them are timeless whatsoever.

     

     

    Go to topic listing

    Account

    Navigation

    Configure browser push notifications
    Chrome (Android)
    1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
    2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
    3. Adjust your preference.
    Chrome (Desktop)
    1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
    2. Select Site settings.
    3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.