Both albums were a disappointment compared to their previous masterpieces (One Of The Boys & Teenage Dream, Folklore & Evermore) 

Midnights clears in every metric

Finally a mid off ! 

PRISM. Dark Horse is honestly undefeated 

Album: Midnights 

Singles: Midnights 

 

Visuals: Prism

Albums: Midnights

Singles: Prism

Visuals: Prism

Album: Midnights

Singles: Prism

Visuals: Prism 

Midnights doesn't have a Legendary Lovers or International Smile so Prism wins.

39 minutes ago, Josh said:

 

39 minutes ago, Josh said:

were a disappointment

Midnights sweetie

Midnights is a better album but the visuals are tragic, Taylor should be banned from directing videos honestly. 

3 minutes ago, SalvoPK said:

 

You clearly were not here in 2013 when the album came out. 

the 61 Metacritic album is the better one

Prism has the much higher highs and has less mid songs than Midnights. On top of that, it also contains career highlights Unconditionally and Walking On Air.

 

Midnights didn't miss with the singles though, every chosen single was good. In comparison you have Birthday which is a very mid single choice instead of Walking On Air or even Legendary Lovers.

Girl walking on air alone obliterates 

 

prism is more consistent but midnights highs are just too high, prism for the rest

PRISM for all

 

underrated imo Katy’s best album

5 minutes ago, Ron Ng said:

Midnights is a better album but the visuals are tragic, Taylor should be banned from directing videos honestly. 

tbh. she needs to hit joseph khan back up because at least people were truly hyped for a taylor mv when he was directing. but i guess it doesnt even matter anymore as youtube is dead and she doesnt want to be a leader in the visuals department

Prism for all! 

better album: Midnights

better singles: Prism

better visuals: Prism

1. Lavender Haze vs Roar
2. Maroon vs Legendary Lovers
3. Anti-Hero vs Birthday
4. Snow On The Beach vs Walking On Air
5. You’re On Your Own Kid vs. Unconditionally
6. Midnight Rain vs Dark Horse
7. Question…? vs This Is How We Do
8. Vigilante **** vs International Smile
9. Bejeweled vs Ghost
10. Labyrinth vs Love Me
11. Karma vs This Moment
12. Sweet Nothing vs Double Rainbow
13. Mastermind vs By The Grace of God
14. The Great War vs Spiritual
15. Bigger Than The Whole Sky vs It Takes Two
16. Paris vs Choose Your Battles
17. High Infidelity
18. Glitch
19. Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve
20. Dear Reader
21. Hits Different
22. You’re Losing Me

 

Midnights Wins.

1 hour ago, Josh said:

Both albums were a disappointment compared to their previous masterpieces

 Lie regarding to Katy. Some people prefer this over Teenage. 

5 minutes ago, Facelessboy said:

 Lie regarding to Katy. Some people prefer this over Teenage. 

Not ATRL in 2013

Midnights for everything. Midnights is a great pop album, one of the best this decade. People just hate on it because it came after folkore/evermore and because it's not a groundbreaking album for Taylor's standards. But yeah, it's an amazing album that gets too much hate. Well, the hate is usually coming from ATRL and Stan Twitter. The general public and audiences love the album. It's also critticly acclaimed (her 2nd most acclaimed album on Metacritic) and it won lots of industry awards including AOTY at the Grammys. So yeah, Midnights is a fantastic pop record and a huge success in every single metric. ATRL has to wake up and stop with the "MID" narrative. It's just pathetic and delusional at this point.

Edited February 23, 20242 yr by Pop Fan