With the years certain female acts have amassed great touring prowess, consistently drawing huge crowds and massive grosses. Tina Turner, Madonna, Beyonce, P!nk, and Taylor Swift standing out the most over the years. So which of these performers is the best and which one is the worst?

Edited November 13, 20232 yr by lonnie

think we can all agree taylor swift is LAST & most questionable of this group. 

2 minutes ago, Devin said:

think we can all agree taylor swift is LAST & most questionable of this group. 

Agreed

Best Madonna and Beyonce.

 

Worst is obviously Taylor Swift!

I think group Taylor is the weakest, for me Tina is the best. 

Worst is obviously Taylor Maria Swift

one of these is not like the others 

What is this set up 

Best: Beyoncé

Worst: Taylor

Beyonce > Tina > Madonna > Pink 

 

These ones are all great performers honestly. Also you get really different kinds of excellence from each. 

24 minutes ago, Opulence said:

What is this set up 

I think it is based on touring numbers and records, no? 

Taylor is not bad she's just the worst out of these girls. 

Based on those options for worst people picked Tina Turner?

 

i prefer performer who can play instrument like guitar, piano, and singing LIVE while perform.

not only dance and lipsing for the entire song 

Beyoncé and it’s not even close 

43 minutes ago, LosingHimWasBlue said:

i prefer performer who can play instrument like guitar, piano, and singing LIVE while perform.

not only dance and lipsing for the entire song 

Well some performer and their off key voices should lip sync more often because they sound flat and off key when singing live even if they play guitar, piano, ukelele etc lol

Best: Celine Dion even if she is not included

 

Worst is nobody. They are all good performers, hence their touring stats.

Taylor best because audience connection 

1 hour ago, LosingHimWasBlue said:

i prefer performer who can play instrument like guitar, piano, and singing LIVE while perform.

not only dance and lipsing for the entire song 

Do you really believe the other women mentioned here would not be able to play Taylor's swift's basic guitar chords while also outsinging the hell out of her at the same time?

 

 

Best:

Madonna ( for pushing the boundaries )

& Beyonce  ( for executing the idea )

 

Worst:

 

Taylor ( She improved a lot  over the years )

4 hours ago, Sonny said:

Best Madonna and Beyonce.

 

Worst is obviously Taylor Swift!

For me it’s Pink just because her acrobatics bore me to death. Taylor is fun. 
Madonna and Beyonce are the best of course.

Beyoncé and Tina are the best 

I personally would give it to Tina, just out of the sheer longevity and the things she was still able to do well into her mid and late 60s. 

 

Also P!nk seems to be highly underrated given the poll results. I do agree that her swinging act has kind of gotten old but the sheer vocal strength and stamina needed to do what she does places her amongst the best in the group with Bey, Tina and Madge.

 

4 hours ago, Opulence said:

What is this set up 

All the women included had/have undisputable touring numbers, it's just to gauge who out of those is the best and worst perfomer.

 

4 hours ago, Ron Ng said:

Taylor is not bad 

yeah, she’s awful as a performer 

Best: Tina

Worst: Taylor