It feels like That OJ American Crime Story season was his absolute peak imo

Edited March 27, 20233 yr by MadonnasBoyfriend

I don't follow or watch his work like that to know about an artistic peak but Pose is the only thing with his name on it that I loved... and Scream Queens season 1. 

The Glee Project

Hmmm Scream Queens season 1 followed by 911 Lone Star

AHS Coven. He never had a project as entertaining as that afterwards. Everything in that season felt natural and was organic. All of Ryan Murphy's dialogues after Coven felt like he's trying to make another successful meme like he did with Coven. 

Edited March 27, 20233 yr by Josh

American Horror Story Asylum, the first half of season 1 of Glee, and the first episode of Scream Queens are complete and utter classics. Every single other of his numerous terrible projects that he’s put out has been despicable garbage that never deserves to have been placed on our TV screens

 

okay I lied, Feud: Bette and Joan is also good but no one knows about that. 
 

it seems like, commercially speaking, 911 does pretty well, but it looks dumb to me and I don’t think he actually has a ton of creative control on it. Haven’t watched Dahmer but it seemed like that was a hit too (even though it was in horrible taste)

I'm a sucker for Glee, but realistically it's gotta be Pose. Pose was incredible from episode 1 to the tearjerking finale 

Scream Queens was camp done perfectly so I’m gonna say that

Jeffrey Dahmer story Was iconic

AHS: Cult... all down hill after that  

AHS Asylum.  

22 minutes ago, stjosephprey4us said:

American Horror Story Asylum, the first half of season 1 of Glee, and the first episode of Scream Queens are complete and utter classics. Every single other of his numerous terrible projects that he’s put out has been despicable garbage that never deserves to have been placed on our TV screens

 

okay I lied, Feud: Bette and Joan is also good but no one knows about that. 
 

it seems like, commercially speaking, 911 does pretty well, but it looks dumb to me and I don’t think he actually has a ton of creative control on it. Haven’t watched Dahmer but it seemed like that was a hit too (even though it was in horrible taste)

Ratched was amazing.

Scream Queens S01 followed by Feud

First season of Glee, AHS Asylum

AHS Asylum was GRIPPING and was some Next level great tv. The show slowly descended into hell after that. 
 

O.J Simpson was also excellent. After that?…..

 

He did pretty good with “impeachment” and Jeffery Dahmer though 

It is definitely Scream Queens Season 1, despite the horrible final episode.

He always starts out strong then fizzles… 

 

Nip tuck, Glee, AHS, crime story, Ratchet, Monster 

 

all first seasons good 

FEUD.

 

The first three seasons of American Horror Story. He's never been a great writer, but the concepts, the characters and the aesthetics were perfect. He had it 

individual emmy wins:

directing - acs

glee

 

but he was never nominated for writing acs.

 

i would say of the ones that he was viewed as the main creative Mastermind of, glee

One two punch of AHS asylum and coven. 

The reason I never dropped AHS even after they keep dipping down every season. 

 

Scream Queen 1, Dahmer, Feud were also interesting watch.

 

Had to drop pose and scream queen few episodes into 2nd season

He peaked with his debut project, Popular imo. That was glee before glee existed. It even has an episode that’s basically what became scream queens.

The People vs. OJ is his best project followed by Pose. The rest is disposable 

With The Normal Heart

54 minutes ago, Dystopian said:

The first three seasons of American Horror Story. He's never been a great writer, but the concepts, the characters and the aesthetics were perfect. He had it 

this basically. 

 

but OJ was also absolutely fantastic. 
 

I feel like he can still surprise tho he hasn’t peaked.