Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ATRL

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Login issues
New Music Out Now!! 🎧💿

K-Pop Thread: 2023 Archive

This is part 1 of the K-Pop Thread: 2023 Archive discussion.

Featured Replies

I just couldn't imagine Kpop without Fancy

1d0258881ca1fcab666ddf875485baa6faee4705

Edited by Pluto2022

  • Replies 131.8k
  • Views 10.9m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • aespa #1!    MYs can have arts AND charts now No chart updates on Spicy from you then?   I think not. Nope. They're at #1 now. Consider your points deb

  • Also @Mel. now that thread banning is back your two week ban starts now. 

  • Antisocialites
    Antisocialites

    some of the new members not giving new at all 

1 hour ago, New Edition said:

 

I hope fromis_9 will join. The only way Pledis could make up for their messy way of handling them :coffee2:

53 minutes ago, Save-Me-Oprah said:

 

is that Pluto I hear in the background

"Oh my gawwd"

 

He may deny it but it definitely sounds like him. 

 

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

 

 

 

c63065a2fce367b25ffea3fc1e31506c.jpg

This image brings me physical pain but it's hard to explain why.

1 minute ago, kendoll2001 said:

Not HYBE and Scooter also recruiting Cirkut for Jungkook’s debut. A collapse incoming I fear :jonny5:

 

Jungcock is going to outdo BTS alone :redface: Him and V will probably also surpass 2m sales 

19 minutes ago, Eternium said:

Incorrect. Most groups only had their songs available for free download in the third week to try and secure a Triple Crown. SNSD didn’t abuse FreezOne - SM wasn’t interested in digitals at all which is why they were constantly cutting ties with most digital companies (even when their groups were smashing digitally) because the revenue they received was almost non-existent. Digitals didn’t mean **** until 2012 when Circle finally started to weed out fraudulence.

IdgKcVO.gif

In a world where this was an option open to EVERY company, including ones that are even more known for media play and sajaegi than YG, nobody had hits as big as GD, period. Charts are there to measure relative popularity and he destroyed every kpop act in every country at the time, with few exceptions(TVXQ in Japan being one of them). This is the hag equivalent of a Blink pretending their favs are the #1 kpop group because BTS uses bulk buys and streaming farms. The call is coming from within the house any way you look at it.

IdgKcVO.gif

 

19 minutes ago, Eternium said:

Have Big Bang even done Nissan Stadium? TVXQ did 3 concerts in a row with 75k seats despite being down to just two members (and not even the most popular members).

Never at the Nissan Stadium because TVXQ is the only kpop act to ever hold events there and given that not even BTS or Twice is booking it, I think it might be a nationalism thing(or some classic underhanded SM dealings). 

 

BB have plenty of double/triple date concerts at the Tokyo Dome and Nagai Stadium though(there's some 4 day stops at the domes in there too but I don't believe at Nagai). 100k+ is coming from the single tour stop not single dates. No kpop act has managed that to my knowledge.

 

TVXQ's biggest showing in Japan: 225k attendees at Nissan Stadium in 2018

 

BB's biggest showing in Japan: 196k attendees at Kyocera Dome in 2017

 

The big differentiator here is that Big Bang does stadiums in more than one country and were doing arenas in the west long after TVXQ was chained to Japan only.

Spoiler

and before you bring up TVXQ's one time being able to do stadiums in China, Big Bang was able to do full scale tours there and not just once in a career one/two city blowouts.

Edited by Century

Big Bang's last domestic smash was a year ago almost to the day, if we're including solos it was less than 4 months ago.

 

TVXQ hasn't had a real domestic hit in the gaon era other than the one that was capitalizing on their scandal. :bibliahh:

 

Edited by Century

To be clear though, the SINGLE TVXQ hit from last decade, was outsold and outcharted by two different Bigbang B-sides in that same year, with several more right behind it. Again, charts are relative so being from the exact same time/climate equalizes other factors.

32 minutes ago, Britney Jean said:

I hope fromis_9 will join. The only way Pledis could make up for their messy way of handling them :coffee2:

Do you really want that?

The whole concept of this is to create a group that will be handled by Ahn Joon Young "Mister healthy p*rn" (his description of IOI and Produce 101 season 1). The guy that was in prison for rigging the show. He returned to MNET last week as the HEAD OF MNET Music department, so he'll be in charge of every groups and music released.

 

Fromis going to this show since their show was actually rigged and by him would basically give them the X1 express ticket. 

Edited by Xalric

  • Author
  • ATRL Administrator

Would y’all be interested if I did monthly giveaways for physical albums and stuff? I really wanna grow our KTRL community and would love ideas to help that. Including making invitation links y’all can send to friends. 

Just now, Ryan said:

Would y’all be interested if I did monthly giveaways for physical albums and stuff? I really wanna grow our KTRL community and would love ideas to help that. Including making invitation links y’all can send to friends. 

Only if they're aespa giveaways and are bought from a vendor that counts towards charts. 

IMG_1593.thumb.gif.52c42e0954f4430b1a493

BigBang can announce a tour tomorrow and they will fill stadiums in the whole Asia I fear
They are the biggest 2nd act, so is GD the biggest idol my queen can compet with him but in Korea only

I don't like it but it's a fact 
 

The Pinks have been super busy as of late between rehearsing for Coachella, attending events, 2 sold out dome shows and Jisoo doing promotion and this in a span of one week

 

i can’t help but laugh at the kpoppies who run the narrative and say “BLACKPINK are privileged and don’t work hard like other girl groups” lmaoo please! They have been working non-stop since August of

last year

 

they work HARDER than some of the groups people accuse them of not working hard as

Yeah, isn't G-Dragon like the biggest it-boy in Korea ever? 

Edited by Pluto2022

3 minutes ago, dlwlrma said:

BigBang can announce a tour tomorrow and they will fill stadiums in the whole Asia I fear
They are the biggest 2nd act, so is GD the biggest idol my queen can compet with him but in Korea only

I don't like it but it's a fact 
 

Spill it

21 minutes ago, Century said:

In a world where this was an option open to EVERY company, including ones that are even more known for media play and sajaegi than YG, nobody had hits as big as GD, period. Charts are there to measure relative popularity and he destroyed every kpop act in every country at the time, with few exceptions(TVXQ in Japan being one of them). This is the hag equivalent of a Blink pretending their favs are the #1 kpop group because BTS uses bulk buys and streaming farms. The call is coming from within the house any way you look at it.

IdgKcVO.gif

 

Never at the Nissan Stadium because TVXQ is the only kpop act to ever hold events there and given that not even BTS or Twice is booking it, I think it might be a nationalism thing(or some classic underhanded SM dealings). 

 

BB have plenty of double/triple date concerts at the Tokyo Dome and Nagai Stadium though(there's some 4 day stops at the domes in there too but I don't believe at Nagai). 100k+ is coming from the single tour stop not single dates. No kpop act has managed that to my knowledge.

 

TVXQ's biggest showing in Japan: 225k attendees at Nissan Stadium in 2018

 

BB's biggest showing in Japan: 196k attendees at Kyocera Dome in 2017

 

The big differentiator here is that Big Bang does stadiums in more than one country and were doing arenas in the west long after TVXQ was chained to Japan only.

  Hide contents

and before you bring up TVXQ's one time being able to do stadiums in China, Big Bang was able to do full scale tours there and not just once in a career one/two city blowouts.

“Everyone could cheat the digital charts, so why does it matter that YG did?” is not a good argument. SM didn’t cheat the charts and so it’s not significant to compare sajaegi’d digital sales to actual digital sales. On top of that, those $.02 sales (and later $0.29) don’t make up very much profit. Even if you look at Cherry Blossom Ending’s 8M digital copies, those $0.29 copies would only be worth about 250k album sales. That would be significantly less for songs released back in the days of $0.02/free downloads.

 

TVXQ is big because they changed their identity. Their name was literally DBSK in Korea but because they got so big in Japan, they translated it and it became TVXQ. They established K-Pop in Japan alongside BoA and they were one of the top acts in East Asia, too. Hence them pulling 600k+ with Mirotic in a time where 100k was a groundbreaking number for South Korea. Big Bang can’t even pull 300k in a much, much healthier climate.

 

As far as touring goes, Big Bang has to travel to other countries and do bigger global promotions because they weren’t able to achieve TVXQ’s popularity. TVXQ’s third and fourth most popular members can literally outgross Big Bang with just one country and then sell more in merchandise than they sell from their tickets. On top of that, TVXQ did 16 dates on their last tour and only had to go to 5 venues to pull 710,000 - do you have any idea how much they save just on travel?

 

https://newsfeed.dispatch.co.kr/1369180

 

https://n.news.naver.com/entertain/article/052/0001390360

 

And for the record, I’m not a TVXQ fan. I just think you girls are so quick to discredit them and it’s weird. They outsold BB 3x over and outgrossed them. 

Just now, Pluto2022 said:

Yeah, isn't G-Dragon like the biggest it-boy ever? 

He most definitely is

the undisputed king of Kpop

 

he just had an exhibition in Korea where the line was several blocks of people

1 hour ago, Pluto2022 said:

he has such thick and well defined leg muscles, due to years of dance experience :WAP: Too bad he likes to keep it classy and doesn't show skin that often 

 

1d0258881ca1fcab666ddf875485baa6faee4705

Well he should stop being a b!tch and show it :bird:

Not just skin but that thick juicy ass of his 

 

Spoiler

Lord forgive me I’ll go to horny jail for 2 minutes

 

44 minutes ago, kendoll2001 said:

Not HYBE and Scooter also recruiting Cirkut for Jungkook’s debut. A collapse incoming I fear :jonny5:

 

Meh

Looking at Jungcock’s recent solo releases, I’m not very excited about that tbh, no matter who the producer is. :mandown:

PEAKTIME FINAL SONGS

SINGLE FOR THE TOP 6

  1. GT (Produced by KENZIE)
  2. NOIR (Produced by Huta (Minhyuk from BTOB))
  3. Prime Time (Produced by Ryan S Jhun)
  4. This That Sh*t (Produced by Jay Park with BIG NAUGHTY, PH-1 and cha cha Malone)
  5. Turning Point (Produced by Jooheoney of Monsta X)
  6. Wave (Produced by Groovy Room)

 

I'm not hyped by Jungkook future release. HYBE & Scooter are trying TOO HARD to find the hit producers/songwriters to make quick lil hit singles. 

The way both him and Jimin will never top Begin & Lie.

Edited by Xalric

27 minutes ago, Eternium said:

“Everyone could cheat the digital charts, so why does it matter that YG did?” is not a good argument. SM didn’t cheat the charts and so it’s not significant to compare sajaegi’d digital sales to actual digital sales. On top of that, those $.02 sales (and later $0.29) don’t make up very much profit. Even if you look at Cherry Blossom Ending’s 8M digital copies, those $0.29 copies would only be worth about 250k album sales. That would be significantly less for songs released back in the days of $0.02/free downloads.

Bigbang doesn't compete in album sales and dominate digitals/streaming because of their older, male demographic, not Qanon sajaegi conspiracies. To this day their singles are verified hits and trading blows with groups that have jobless rich teens making charts their hobby. BB members are the only non-soloists competing with JYJ on richest idol lists last I checked so the profit argument seems very odd. The money is coming from somewhere and we all know it isn't these millions of free downloads that you're hallucinating. :bunny:

27 minutes ago, Eternium said:

TVXQ is big because they changed their identity. Their name was literally DBSK in Korea but because they got so big in Japan, they translated it and it became TVXQ. They established K-Pop in Japan alongside BoA and they were one of the top acts in East Asia, too.

TVXQ is huge because the boy band scene was weaker in the early 00s in Japan and they arrived at the right time to become an enormous craze and were talented enough to sustain it. BoA did much, much more for kpop in Japan because she wasn't seen as too cringe, too foreign(All 5 of them severely struggled with the language in the early days), or too pandering to teen girls in heat. This is the group that was bold enough to put the line really wanna touch myself in Purple Line with a straight face. If a 4th gen group did that kind of pandering they'd be mocked until they were forced to disband, let alone the optics of selling it to CHILDREN. They really weren't respected in Japan the same way they were in Korea until the scandals started rolling in a few years back.

 

27 minutes ago, Eternium said:

Hence them pulling 600k+ with Mirotic in a time where 100k was a groundbreaking number for South Korea. Big Bang can’t even pull 300k in a much, much healthier climate.

They started the trend of garnering a huge fanbase to then inflate album sales in the singles era, I'll give you that. Their predecessors from SM destroyed them in albums and so have several SM groups since though so this is also a weird argument. BB still wins in real music consumption in every country on Earth except for Japan.

 

:bunny:

27 minutes ago, Eternium said:

As far as touring goes, Big Bang has to travel to other countries and do bigger global promotions because they weren’t able to achieve TVXQ’s popularity. TVXQ’s third and fourth most popular members can literally outgross Big Bang with just one country and then sell more in merchandise than they sell from their tickets. On top of that, TVXQ did 16 dates on their last tour and only had to go to 5 venues to pull 710,000 - do you have any idea how much they save just on travel?

 

Saving on travel costs is the funniest way to spin being local I have ever heard in my well over a decade of being a kpop stan. Big Bang could throw darts at a map of Earth and sell out at the bare minimum, an arena in any country they could land on. The only other kpop group capable of that is BTS. :bibliahh:

 

27 minutes ago, Eternium said:

And for the record, I’m not a TVXQ fan. I just think you girls are so quick to discredit them and it’s weird. They outsold BB 3x over and outgrossed them. 

 

For the record, I'm a big fan of both and just get annoyed by the gross over-inflation of TVXQs stats and popularity by the other remaining 2nd gen hags. Big Bang annihilates TVXQ in every country in the world except for one country which is neither their home market OR the biggest market. BB has hugely outgrossed and outsold TVXQ ww. This is a rare instance where Chinese sales count because their Chinese base puts asses in seats when BB announces dates there.

Edited by Century

1 minute ago, kendoll2001 said:

Celine really said A-List only :gaycat5:

 

Not daddy Bogum showing some thighs 

 

spacer.png

 

 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.