1 minute ago, sillycilla said:

You lack comprehension it’s ok.

 

And you think you won an argument because I ignored and didn’t reply? Lmao, girl ok. 
 

Everything you posted is easily refutable, I just didn’t care to engage anymore on that. 

Everything you post is easily refutable too. “Lmao, girl, ok.”

1 minute ago, sillycilla said:

You lack comprehension it’s ok.

 

And you think you won an argument because I ignored and didn’t reply? Lmao, girl ok. 
 

Everything you posted is easily refutable, I just didn’t care to engage anymore on that. 

mhmm sure. silly cilla indeed.

 

 

2 minutes ago, Draper. said:

Anyway, new show tonight and no more than three days between shows until the end of the tour. 

welp its over

1 minute ago, Draper. said:

Everything you post is easily refutable too. “Lmao, girl, ok.”

calling me a psychological abuser because I'm not dragging Beyoncé  the clownery!

8 minutes ago, aaron511 said:

Y'all constantly complain how there's nothing to talk about yet somehow manage to produce a few pages everyday  More than any other Base that I follow

it’s the complaining that fills the pages  at least we’re being useful unlike others in here 

3 minutes ago, kimberly said:

yes, I said I just came across it.

 

there's no science to defining someone's status as a legend and how "well remembered" they are. it's all qualitative mama.

 

* unless some serious organization randomly decides to run an actual research study about this question only ATRL thinks about.

But I think what everyone is saying and what you seem to be arguing against is that the numbers and statistics all show the decline. That is scientific evidence.  The newer generation is unfamiliar with her work. Beyonce doesn't even make recent most famous people lists. Just because someone knows pretty hurts doesn't mean it's in the zeitgeist of the general public and that seems to be the case with a lot of her music unfortunately. 

 

Beyonce is dominating on tour today because of her goodwill with her performances. But since the choreo is slowing down and changing she will need to rely on her music going forward, and with the lack of promo or push that's going to be difficult. 

I think we all need to meet in a parking lot and fist fight, then we go to the renaissance tour ending show together holding hands

2 minutes ago, QueenB said:

I think we all need to meet in a parking lot and fist fight, then we go to the renaissance tour ending show together holding hands

Why is this hot

 

 

4 minutes ago, Draper. said:

Everything you post is easily refutable too. “Lmao, girl, ok.”

 

2 minutes ago, kimberly said:

calling me a psychological abuser because I'm not dragging Beyoncé  the clownery!

Coming from the two people who have yet to disprove anything LOL.

 

I love it .

 

5 minutes ago, kimberly said:

mhmm sure. silly cilla indeed.

 

 

You got it Kimberly. 

4 minutes ago, carameldelight said:

But I think what everyone is saying and what you seem to be arguing against is that the numbers and statistics all show the decline. That is scientific evidence.  The newer generation is unfamiliar with her work. Beyonce doesn't even make recent most famous people lists. Just because someone knows pretty hurts doesn't mean it's in the zeitgeist of the general public and that seems to be the case with a lot of her music unfortunately. 

 

Beyonce is dominating on tour today because of her goodwill with her performances. But since the choreo is slowing down and changing she will need to rely on her music going forward, and with the lack of promo or push that's going to be difficult. 

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 
 

 

9 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Its actually quite easy to explain why: because there is nothing else to talk about.

Do you want to talk about a perfume? Wait, no one has smelled it yet, sry.

 

People have though. I'm pretty sure even yesterday someone was talking about it here.

 

9 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Do you want to talk about the tour? But there are no changes, so also same old since 5 months.

She literally changes every night, there have been setlist changes ("The Big Three"), guest appareances, etc. It's not MAJOR changes but...is that something we expect from Beyoncé, and if so, based on what precedent?

 

9 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Do you want to talk about her albums and do rating things? Also same old.

Valid, but is complaining about the same topics not "same old"?

 

9 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Do you want to talk about some fan theories that have nothing to them aside from being cute dreams? 

Any sort of "this is what she should do" is cute dreams as well.

 

9 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Like, we might as well close the thread then till sth happens cause there is nothing to talk about and there wont be anything to talk about cause she makes sure no one talks about her, the recording etc.

If the thread is still open despite there being nothing to talk about, who cares? Is there a quota we need to fill? Because there are plenty more interesting topics we could find than the same tired complaints people have recycled since 2013.

If you want to complain, if that's how you like to engage with Beyoncé, just say that. But these excuses for why you are FORCED into complaining rather than choosing to do so doesn't quite prove anything. 

Did everyone try the Brazilian butt lift? I thought the Brazilian butt lift was lovely

6 minutes ago, carameldelight said:

The newer generation is unfamiliar with her work. Beyonce doesn't even make recent most famous people lists. 

Can you stop lying?

From yesterday: 

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/lists/taylor-swift-beyonce-top-platinum-players-music/

2 minutes ago, carameldelight said:

But I think what everyone is saying and what you seem to be arguing against is that the numbers and statistics all show the decline. That is scientific evidence.  The newer generation is unfamiliar with her work. Beyonce doesn't even make recent most famous people lists. Just because someone knows pretty hurts doesn't mean it's in the zeitgeist of the general public and that seems to be the case with a lot of her music unfortunately. 

 

Beyonce is dominating on tour today because of her goodwill with her performances. But since the choreo is slowing down and changing she will need to rely on her music going forward, and with the lack of promo or push that's going to be difficult. 

and what I (and most others who have accepted Beyoncé's antics) are saying is that the "slowing down" is natural, and she won't do Doja Cat numbers regardless of how she promotes (or doesn't).

 

she is a 43 year old mother of three, married for 15 years. realistically she can make the usual "Run the World" "I Slay" songs that are universal, but besides that her lived experiences and otherworldly vocals will not attract new 10-15 year-old fans.

 

and that is completely fine by me! she's still very well-known and regarded as one of the best performers to ever walk this earth. that's not something that fades away because "Spotify daily streams" or "most famous people lists" (what does that even mean?)

4 minutes ago, sillycilla said:

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 
 

 

Oh no!! It’s you proving points again!!!!!!!

Edited September 21, 20232 yr by Draper.

1 hour ago, Redporus said:

Single Ladies sitting right on first listen? 

Lyrically, not sonically. 

 

Sonically I wondered why Get Me Bodied part 2 was being pushed as a promo single (I wasn't in Stan world at the time and IIWAB was the UK lead), but the writing was always slick, seamless and memorable. There are still moments to Cuff/BMS/Summer Ren that feel a tad clunky... 

 

 

7 minutes ago, sillycilla said:

Coming from the two people who have yet to disprove anything LOL.

ignoring the proof then saying this... you are so weird.

2 minutes ago, Draper. said:

Can you stop lying?

From yesterday: 

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/lists/taylor-swift-beyonce-top-platinum-players-music/

Is this a joke??? How is this list even remotely what I am referring to. 

 

 

2 minutes ago, carameldelight said:

Is this a joke??? How is this list even remotely what I am referring to. 

How is it not? Are you Lea Michele?

4 minutes ago, Draper. said:

Oh no!! It’s you proving points again!!!!!!!

Oh no, it’s you saying nothing again! 

 

3 minutes ago, kimberly said:

ignoring the proof then saying this... you are so weird.

Your fifth grade argumentative brain wouldn’t comprehend. Still stuck on two pages ago because I didn’t want to write another essay. Lmao 

6 minutes ago, swissman said:

People have though. I'm pretty sure even yesterday someone was talking about it here.

yes, many people that went to the show in the US in Club Renny/BeyHive pit have smelled the perfume!

 

when we were in line, as soon as the perfume sampler ladies came out into the slight breeze, we all immediately were like "what's that smell, it's so good" before realizing it was her perfume and sampler ladies  it's quite a bit more rosy than I would usually go for, but it smells great, luxurious and complex (in a good way). a much more thought-out fragrance than her previous drugstore ones and other celebrity fragrances besides Fenty, which is also rich and complex.

I can tell winter is coming bc these insects are fighting for their lives!!!

2 minutes ago, sillycilla said:

Your fifth grade argumentative brain wouldn’t comprehend. Still stuck on two pages ago because I didn’t want to write another essay. Lmao 

I successfully graduated from a Top 5 university of the world. go back to the drawing board.

1 minute ago, kimberly said:

yes, many people that went to the show in the US in Club Renny/BeyHive pit have smelled the perfume!

 

when we were in line, as soon as the perfume sampler ladies came out into the slight breeze, we all immediately were like "what's that smell, it's so good" before realizing it was her perfume and sampler ladies  it's quite a bit more rosy than I would usually go for, but it smells great, luxurious and complex (in a good way). a much more thought-out fragrance than her previous drugstore ones and other celebrity fragrances besides Fenty, which is also rich and complex.

I love rosy perfume! So I'm glad I got my pre-order in!

2 minutes ago, Draper. said:

How is it not? Are you Lea Michele?

Most famous lists does not equal who had a successful year list. 

 

Anyways, I was referring to a list of most famous people in the world and Beyonce wasn't in the top 10 like she used to. It could have not been up to date though.